^ and kanariya, she pulled that off even with a squeaky voice lol

O_o I really didn't expect all the hate here. I love this song and I think the chorus is very lovely. I actually like their voices and lyrics as well.

I was worried about this song when I read all that hate on this forum but I think I could cry in happiness because the moment it started playing, I fell in love with it. It's such a sweet R&B ballad that I've always loved. :) I also think this is way better than Dream ON too. ANother song also has became my second favorite song on FIVE. :)

the more I listen to it the more I dislike, gosh. even the PV. I dislike both :no

no.

I dont know if this has been said yet but is her outfit a black version of her bunny outfit with little things that are different?

This song is so sweet and mellow. Though it felt REALLY LONG hahaha..
the PV alerady make it like it abit more..
This is a very Namie-song to be honest and if only Ayu had a lil choreography herself.

i mentioned in the main FIVE thread...this song makes me feel like Im in the stars after progress shot me up to space HAHHA

oh yea, Ayu looks FANTASTIC

only thing that irritates me is the weird synth that doesnt fit the beat at the beginning

nice song :)

somehow whenever i want to listen to Five, this is the first song i would play and listen

growing on me

today..i was in the mrt station when there was quite a crowd but it was still quiet because everyone was by themselves..
and I was listening to ANother song..and i felt the beauty of this song. I was feeling rather down and..I felt as though Ayu and Naoya were singing to me with the piano and all...it was a really nice moment..there seemed to be a connection between the song and my mood at that time..

Garbage.

Sorry, if I wanted to listen to a sappy R&B love ballad I'd turn to Kana Nishino or Miliyah Kato. Ayu RUINED the verses with the vibrato & wasn't too impressed with Naoya's voice either.

Not only that, the song was a huge lullaby cos it just went on and on and onto nowhere... it felt like Ayu gave in way too much to Naoya to sing a song that he's used to singing.

DREAM on was still fine cos it's pop with no annoying voices but this is just... thrash on a whole new level :no

I think it didn't help that this came in between progress & Why... my listens are always

*progress finishes*
"holy amazing song!"
*I wanna listen to Why... now*
*ANother song plays*
"YUCK WTF"
*Skip*

I had a similar experience today waiting around for the train on the way home today.

I was listening to FIVE, sitting down, deep in thought and just randomly observing stuff around me and the song just kinda... suited it and made me appreciate it a bit more :P

What a cute story. :)

I just received FIVE today and can finally put in my two cents. I like the song. It's not overflowing love on first listen and OMG! this is fantastic, but I really like it. It's calming and sweet and even though it feels like this, it is not boring! I don't think it makes sense to try to understand the reaction this song brought here. But what the hell happened that justifies so much hate? :rolleyes

I agree about the bad arrangement, especially the beginning sounds horrible.. But it's growing on me. It will never be that *Ayu_Masterpiece* -song, but I surely can listen to it, it's in the same category as Sweet season..

this song has grown on me, but I still think that the arrangement and PV suck :rolleyes

Listened to it halfway through then deleted it.

its my favorite.

I want to listen to this song all day.
It's better than progress.
Oh silly me.


It's amazing how they can grow O_O I'm ashamed.