He didn't do the 3rd one. Hideaki has done the following PVs with Ayu: Greatful days, ANGEL'S SONG, About You, GAME, 1 LOVE, Don't look back, and MOON. I think that's all of them...?

Ah? Ok... I was confident he did You were... too. Because in my memories it was the same person in the making-of You were.../Dlb :tipsy
Sorry!

I'm so glad she's using him again! The PV's he has directed are so interesting.

Omg, Sparkle is a disaster and 1 LOVE is AMAZING! You cannot even compare the two!

^I love the Sparkle PV.

^
I think Sparkle was pretty cool too. Lacked a direction, but I think that was intentional. Then again I am no PV-expert.

My sister IS a PV expert and she says Sparkle is good.

I'm not, and I agree.

Some things about Sparkle were weird but overall I think it's an entertaining PV. It entertained me more than 1LOVE did.. I like both though.

She's flaming hot in both PVs so I have no complaints. ;D

Srarkle was very cool. Visually. It was fun and I liked it. :D 1 LOVE was pure awesomeness. All for me
If one isn't into her sexier images they also may not like. Or they just may not like it lol
Although I find her more creepy than sexy in both which is cool

Anyhow so the directors have done good works in the past so I hope for the next they will also be awesome. They have the ability

sparkle is the only pv I like from him.

Anyways, Muto~ I love his pvs! I'm glad ayu is continuing the awesomeness!

Sparkle had a fetish porn theme to it - that alone makes it brilliant.

Oh so true :lech

Uwaaa I didn't like 1 LOVE or Sparkle at alllll :laugh Sparkle was like...just :no and 1 LOVE was creepy and weird and Ayu looked pretty but pole dancing is like... :no:no:no

I'm not into her "overly sexy" image, like in 1 LOVE or Sparkle... But strangely, I liked the my name's WOMEN PV :laugh

I like her sweeter and deep PV's better :3 Like momentum, or No way to say~ or a few others (too lazy to type them out XD)

I just hope her newer PV's are sweet and deep (^^)

Erhm, yeah, but I would like to keep Ayu seperate from "fetish porn" please.

I don't like Sparkle's video at all. I think her look in it is horrible and the leather guys are weird. Sparkle is such an amazing song, I wish I could like the video.

That type of fetish porn creeps me out and could not make it brilliant to me (I saw those comparison pics to the sparkle video :tired). At least ayu didn't do anything that weird in it. The highlight of the Sparkle video for me is how hot she looks in those skin tight outfits. I'd kill for her body.
lol @ this turning into the Sparkle video discussion thread. We need more news.

i LOOOVEEED sparkle! :3 it was such an entretaining PV:P
I think crossroads is going to beamazing :P

I hope a really great and luxurious PV for her 50th single.
For crossroad PV i can imagine something cute

From the pictures we saw it looks like an apartment or something, which reminds me of is this LOVE
and then we learn that its the same guy that made the music video of is this LOVE ( i think, from what a gathered from previous comments)
im hoping crossroads has an is this LOVE feeling :P
you can tell i loved is this LOVE ;p

^i thought the concept used in that PV was brilliant.