black cherry was the first album i heard for kuu and it gave me a bad impression of kuu, i don't think i liked one song on that album...so secret gets my vote

i agree 100% :yes

So Secret and Black Cherry are both my fav albums from those artists, so I'm not going to choose. On Secret the only tracks I don't care about are It was and Beautiful Fighters, and on Black Cherry it's WON'T BE LONG ~black cherry v.~, Candle Light and Koi no Tsubomi, but Black Cherry has more tracks. If I HAD to choose one to save, and the other one to be deleted forever I'd pick Secret obviously because I love Ayu, but idk I love both. ^_^ Secret just has a more emotional pack for me because I'm an Ayu fan hehe. JEWEL makes me teary eyed. @_@

I love them both. But I go Secret, not because is an Ayu album, but I love every single track out of it, while I love most tracks off Black Cherry, but not as much as the Secret ones

I love both! But Black Cherry was perfect :)

Both.I can't belive you made me choose.

black cherry ~ :yes

Black Cherry for me.
There are so much emotions connected with this album - just love it. :luv2

And still I love more tracks on Kumi's albums than on Ayu's. :shrug

I was completely disappointed with Ayu's Secret. I was waiting for some smash album what (miss)understood was to me. And when Secret lacked all the (miss)understood power and feeling I was so angry and disappointed. I still don't like the album so much as a whole but I don't hate it either. It's only Ayu album besides A Song for XX that I really don't like so much. :p

When Kuu's Black Cherry came out, instead, I was completely hooked into it. Of course it's rockish sound bothers me because it's not really Kuu's genre. I see her always as an R&B artist. I loved the album into bits anyways. And I hadn't listened to any of the singles before I got the album so I was like 'woot!!!1'. Before I listened to Black Cherry, I had listened to BEST~second session~ and just got hooked into Koda's music. :3 Black Cherry impressed me so much I became her fan. Black Cherry has awesome songs like JUICY, Get Up&Move!! and Cherry Girl on it. And the best intro from Koda ever, INTRODUCTION. And I haven't gotten even bored with this album yet. :0 With Secret I got so bored with it in the end so I couldn't even listen to it for a while.

Black Cherry is indeed the best from these two. :)

Secret - Ayumi Hamasaki

both albums were bad IMO but secret is a bit better

Secret

Ugh, Secret's my second least favourite, while I love Black Cherry. Secret was my biggest disappointment from Ayu as far as albums go, and Black Cherry surprised me with how much I ended up liking it. So I pick Kuu.

:yes

Black Cherry!!!

Kumi is the best!

ah ! the first time i saw this thread ! i choose Secret ! i can't stand Black cheery although it has a good title and photoshoot

I much prefer Secret

my favorite songs on Black Cherry are Yume no uta, Unmei, I'll be there, Cherry Girl, JUICY, and Candle light.

and even my least favorite track on Secret is better than most of those.
so, Secret it is!