she reminds me on the second pic of mona lisa lol.
but most asians use such contactlenses which make your eyes bigger.
i believe she wears such, too, even if she has pretty big eyes.

http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/3...nf9lzpywn3.jpg

see? it's not everytime only the make-up.

Woah, she doesn't even LOOK like Ayu, er, herself. O_O How strange.

I didn't know this thread was still going. I remember reading it when it was first posted. Geez...

Apparently, she got some makeup base on, which means she is not "MAKE-UP FREE" at all. XD Make up base only helps one to cover all the pores, pimples and the dark circles around her eyes. If she didnt put on those stuff as well, can you imagine how she/all the women looks^^?~

But still, ayu looks better than the other artists without makeup, for instance koda kumi XD (have u seen the one without anything on) and Mika nakashima (i saw some recent photos of her without makeup)

I think she looks fine. A lot better that other celebrities you see without makeup.

:yeek Jeez, those pics of Ayumi are horrible....yea, Ayumi is definitely a make-up person.

Hey not too bad. Now it looks like she never did get plastic surgery at all! Go Ayuuuuuu!

ayu's natural face looks nice..unlike other celebrities who don't do make up, their faces will look definitely ugly...

ayu's face is smooth enough~

i agree with ayumixxx
i've seen many ayu without make up in documentary of cdl
and she's still look cute but just a lil pale.

and her skin smooth!!!!! i think she has much acne but she doesn't ^_^

with or without makeup ... still a hottie ...

she still is beautiful to me hehe maybe even better - i have a wierd thing...i think the best someone can look is when they are in home-clothes - when usualy you see them in dressed up and full makeup and then suddonly you see them at home, no makeup and with their glasses on and hair just normal... wah the best!

In the first pic, she does look tired and worn-out. But it then second pic it's cute, but she doesn't look the same without her make-up. She's beautiful with or without her make up anyways :D

i think she looks good
the first pic is ... meh
the second pic is really natural in a good way =]

yayayayah!! Ayu still looks attractive without make-up but a little bit less fancy... I really do believe that Ayu didn't have plastic surgery....Way to go, Ayu

OMG!!!
she looks so young
actually these two pics ayu had hade a little bit makeup
but it's not so clear like in ordinary

^ Yea title should've said "ayu with NO eye makeup"

Another one without make up (or at least a lil bit) is on the BEST of CDL 06-07 Documentary.
http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n...yuwomakeup.jpg

she looks good without make up

Ha ha...I'm gonna post again...

I think my opinion changed a bit...she still looks very pretty, just her eyes don't pop out as much.

i really shocked when i saw ayu like that...without make up..and look at her eyes... so small, i mean smaller than how she uses to have...
so i kinda believe that it's all MAKE UP that makes her eyes so big!!

and that picture above, she definitely looks like when she was young..