Both are unimpressive... but I suppose Judas' composition is a tad better.

Not that it really takes much to be better than the ****storm that was BTW but Judas is infinitely better. Catchier, better production, better composition, overall better song.

RedOne is always good but Gaga eventually needs to stop with the ah-ah-ah-ga-ga-ga cheerleader chants in her lyrics, it's giving her songs an unpleasant sameness. It's okay now since it's still early in her career but it has to go down the road.

Judas is good, but I really think it's just The Fame Monster regurgitated :shrug

At least we had never heard Born This Way before.

Judas is on repeat right now lol

judas

Judas *__*

I was never a fan of Born this way. It's not bad, but I really wouldn't go out of my way to listen to it. I am really into Judas right now... the instruments and arrangement is so amazing! It sounds so fresh, yet retro and nostalgic~ :heart

born this way.

I can relate to Judas better than Born This Way so I picked Judas. :)

I like non of them, but Judas is better...

Judas, I'm not really liking BTW very much yet :D

Judas by a BIG mile!!!

BTW

Judas! BTW - both video and song - sucks! XP

saw the mv of judas today for the first time and i totally loved it! much better than BTW :yes

Judas
Both the song and video are amazing!

Judas

BTW is better for me. Sorry I really don't like Judas. :no
I'm a Christian so I feel it's some kind of blasphemy. :(

Judas...

Musically they both sound very similar so I had to decide based on lyrical content. Both have very literal yet metaphorical lyrics which is somewhat disastrous but "Judas" doesn't sound like it's trying to shove a message down your throat the way that BTW does. The vocal production on BTW is ten times better though.

Judas