^ is that considered acapella, peco and princess are vocalizing in the back and the piano is still playing?

I think evolution in AT 07 is more like an acoustic/piano mix... apacella is more like when you sing without any instruments, and with like other people to make up chords... it's kind of confusing imo... cos the most hardcore form of apacella is like having a "bass", "tenor", "alto" and "soprano" voices and sing. More often than not, the 'bass' can also be imitating the bass of the actual song.

its not acapella because theres piano, peco and princess would still be considered acapella though

yeah that's what i thought~ acapella is without any instrumental accompaniment~

i think Secret was acoustic rather than acapella.

Anyway, i dint noe there is link between t2m and MW. whats the link??!

^ if you are talking about the evolution opening in AT07, it was not acoustic, if a keyboard is used it's NOT acoustic
And the link between t2m and MW was explained somewhere in this thread, I think on the first page

I suppose he has read it, so I apologize for not explaining well.

Well, I think in talkin' 2 myself, when she sang that line... it corresponds to Mirrorcle World. Like 'creation comes after destruction', then you have 'Have I imagined such a future?'.

I think it's a case of 10 years, and there's a new creation (a NEXT LEVEL ^^), and has she imagined such a 'future'? Remember back in 1999 she honestly wasn't sure if singing was her thing and all that... but now I think she knows the answer.

And talkin' 2 myself x Mirrorcle World is the representation of the question and answer she has chosen for her career thus far.

"You should know creation comes after destruction"

"Have I imagined such a future?"

I sometimes think that fans over-analyze what Ayu does XD.. I think she just did it to add effect to the song/concert and that she felt like it :p Kind of a repeat of A museum. She just wants to give a good performance (imo).

A Song for XX with acapella was 10x better than talkin' 2 myself and her voice carried much more meaning.
Also Rule acapella for AT09 doesn't really seem to serve any role than as concert opener. (it does seem cool though~)

Buttt with that said.. I like waterballoon's explanation too :P

Honestly I think that only AT 08's apacella was on purpose to bring out a point. ^^

^ yep, A Song for XX acapella was just too long and too random to serve with special meaning IMO and Rule...is just cool xD with all the lights^^ and Rule isnt really acapella, there ARE instruments, just not in the same parts ayu is singing xD

A Song for XX acapella was the best performance she did of A Song for, I think... Even though it was long, it doesn't feel long at all, because every sentence has so much energy in her voice. Her singing A Song for in acapella really made you listen to the lyrics, and maybe even the people who it was written for could really understand then(Her mom and everyone around her at that time~).

Anyways, I really love the A Song for acapella, but Talkin' 2 Myself one is okay... and I think the Rule one is just to emphasize, "we won't follow rules set by someone else." etc.

Ok! "Analizing using translation" time!

A Song for XX

Why am I crying?
Why am I lost?
Why did I stop?
Please tell me
When will I grow up?
How long can I stay a child?
Where have I come running from?
Where am I running to?

I had no place to live. I couldn't find one.
I don't know if I could have any hope for the future.

Using her most iconic song to open the concert celebrating her 40th single seens to be normal to me :P Considering that when she wrote this, she didn't expect to be around for long time, having a 40th IS very special... And in the end, IMO, those lines of A Song for XX are stronger than the chorus

talkin' 2 myself

You know
That creation comes after destruction

Again, another celebration concert... To me she is just saying "time to kill the old ayu to create the new one that will be around for the next 10 years". To me, Guilty is the album she used to say "Ok, this circle of my life and career ends here...", and those lines from t2m are used to say the same thing on the concert, that she needs to finish that decade of singing in order to start the new one.

Rule

I don't need the Rules
Decided by someone else
Because we are the Rules
I can't give way in that matter

Isn't it the main theme of the album, the main theme of the concert and the main theme of her whole career? Don't letting the rules decided by the society to stop you from going further, or to the Next Level?

Great analysis... just one thing. A Museum was for her 30th single, not 40th. :P

Sorry! Sometimes I forget she has 557 singles and not 567!
hahaha :P