alan all the way.

Both are really beautiful, but I prefer Ayu's.

I like Ayu's BALLAD a lot more.

ayu's all the way

lov alan's too

No doubt. Ayu's ballad is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>alan's one

alan's BALLAD. Its actually one of her best. Although Ayu's BALLAD is great too, she has much better ballads.

I thought about putting a thread like this but, non3ko beat me to it. ;)

I'm picking both.

But if I really have to pick one, it will be Ayu's BALLAD

:syeah I wins ! jk

alan's BALLAD imo... The lyrics killed me! and she has a lovely voice, her better song, stunning vocals...

I thoungt Ayumi's BALLAD will be better... but is OK... cute, ayu sangs like always, nice arrangament but is the same winter ballad in lyrics T_T

I prefer BOTH, however if I had to choice just one I would say alan, because her song has more original melody.

alan.

:love

Usually I prefer Ayu over Alan, but this time I have to say that I like Alan's Ballad better than Ayu's. Ayu's Ballad isn't bad, not at all, but somehow it is a little bit boring. Alan's Ballad is justa amazing, I think it's definitely one of her best songs so far!

ayu's BALLAD is over the top

Ayu's

I voted for both. I couldn't help myself haha. I love both of the songs very very much

Ayu's BALLAD

alan's BALLAD is really boring D:

alan's BALLAD. There's no way that Ayu's could have been better, I knew that from the get go. and I was right.

doesn't anyone sorta think that alan's BALLAD sounds sorta like an Ayu reject, and Ayu's BALLAD sorta sounds like an alan reject?

Ayu owns alan here.