I knew not to expect much from a winter song but it's worse than I thought.
I was expecting something like the songs from A ONE that I don't care much about (The GIFT, Anything For You...) but this is just... ugh.

I'm not a fan of Christmas songs and this is why.

Edit: Winter Diary ~LOVE is ALL~ would've been better after all.

I just heard the preview. I like how it sounds a little more upbeat then a simple ballad. It's decent :)

ermm... it's not really a full classical album and they had named the album to make sure of it. Read the album title again. It says 『Winter diary 〜A7 Classical〜』. It's like you have a BEST album which comes with new songs. Nothing new here. She had done it many times.

I listen to the preview via YouTube, and the beginning of this song it always reminds me of when she sang “Silent Night” X'mas show in 2001 with GACKT as a duet. If you guys haven't notice that yet.
I think, there's some message behind this song. Who knows...

yes! finally a happy/warm winter song, i've had enough sad winter ballad!!

I prefer sad ballads. :D

I guess the reason most people dislike this song is the same reason why I love it. I just LOVE christmasy songs like this, they always make me so happy. I'm not surprised it's not a popular opinion though.

It might be able to grow on me. I don't know. I am not so fond of it.
The english in the intro was really bad. Wish she had not include that part.

Great... Take THANK U, put in some Xmas-y arrangements, and BAM! you get the most boring and generic song ever AKA Winter Diary.
I was waiting for this song to decide if I buy the album, and I definitely won't.

I would have preferred a ballad version of Summer Diary, seriously.

I wasn't expecting something like that but I still need some time to digest Winter diary before judging it. Her English sounds really good in the first verses, though.

This. so much :P

I love this song!!! I thought I wouldn't like another wintery song but it has something special for me!

I can't say is a horrible song. But sure it's a plain and souless song. Nothing remarkable to me and I can't imagine it into a classical album :S
Is like she rushed to make a simple song to earn easy money xD

I really like this song, her voice is not so cheesy cute. I'm so happy she didn't sing the
beginning part with bad engrish like she usually does even though she knows English .

i'm glad to see that at least SOME people have some positive stuff to say about the song. frankly i don't know what would make majority happy on here *shrugs* it barely happens.

Kikuchi co-produced on Mirrorcle World. He produced the bridge following the second chorus and the closing of MW.

Not sure so far but the full song might grow on me. It's pretty but not grabbing me straight away. But I have really liked every other song released this year so one that I don't like straight away is fine!

High five? :D

Source? This seems like strangely specific info and I've never seen MW credited to anyone but Nakano.

Can't listen to the preview. Of course not, what was I expecting.
But wow, you don't seem to agree if her English at the beginning sounds bad or good. I'm excited... and also a little bit scared.