i like it, its a good song but its not one of her best ballads tho.
beloved is better ;D

I smell trash can.

/facepalm.

However to stay on topic I'll say that I like Why... but I don't love it as for progress. Why... sounds much better than beloved imo. And Ayu and JUNO voices works nice together.

Can't people see that girl is just trolling around? x_x

---
About the song... found it to be very pretty... Ayu's voice is gorgeous on it, and Juno's voice really matches with her... They both give the song all the emotion it needs^^

It's not her most innovative track... But when u look at her discography, To be, You, Seasons, Dearest, A song is born, End Roll, No way to say, Carols, Together when, Days...

A lot of fan favorites, not only one "unique" or "innovative" track... Most of Ayu ballads are pretty damn generic

The song is okay for me but it ended abruptly :\
I don't have any problems with JUNO, he's good for her duet.

I love the lyrics but I really hope the song is a grower, just like beloved.
It's okay, so far.

I know that this is really off topic, but I like Why...

I like Why... more than beloved, but the only track that's really blown me away so far has been progress.

Oh guys, we need to do these!

To me it's:

Why... > beloved > progress

For me:

progress > Why... > beloved

I guess? I don't know, I'm kind of torn on Why... and beloved because I don't think either of them are great songs, but I'll probably listen to Why... more because beloved is REALLY lacking energy (like Sunset ~LOVE is ALL~, meaning of Love, etc.)

progress > Why... > beloved

for me as well. If the other two songs (ANother song and BRILLIANTE) are ballads I think I'm going to cry.

progress > why... = beloved

beloved > progress > why

mine why... > progress > beloved

ANother song was announced to be a ballad from the beginning. :( I think the only thing we've heard about BRILLANTE is that it's "mysterious" or something like that. But judging from the PV photos, it shouldn't be a ballad (unless Ayu's insane :)).

Powerful ballad. Ayu sounds good too. I will admit, I almost laughed when he started singing xD This would of been a GREAT song for Ayu to do alone.

*dies a little inside*
Oh well, 2010 was more of Ayu's year, so if this year isn't as amazing as the previous year, I'm okay with that. :D

I don't think many other members are happy about it, though...

For me, so far, it's:

Progress > beloved > Why...

Going to listen to ANother Song now.

Progress > Why.. > Beloved > ANother Song

currently: beloved = ANother song > progress > Why...

mine is like
beloved > progress > Why... > ANother song

I hope BRILLIANTE will be the best.