They shamelessly used scenes from the korean MV of Whistle and added some new ones that didn't really match the original concept. Weird.

I'm so against Japanese Versions of any song but oh well.

i have kinda fell out from them :no i dont find myself listening to their songs anymore.. sad

I find their Japanese stuff is better than Twice, they have planned this long time ago since their debut, thats why they shoot the PV in two version, not like Twice that re create the PV with low budget (TT japanese PV version is so trashy). But I don't think the marketing is as good as Twice.

A reality, that's nice.
But just 1 comeback this year ? They need another one asap.

another forgotten YG group �� why YG why

me too :shakehead

I was checking the releases of the other top 3 girlgroups in Korea:
GFRIEND - 3 comebacks (FINGERTIP, LOVE WHISPER, SUMMER RAIN)
TWICE - 3 comebacks (KNOCK KNOCK, SIGNAL, LIKEY)
RED VELVET - 3 comebacks (Rookie, Red Flavour, Peek-a-boo)

Seriously, the competition is really strong.

I like their comeback!

I waited a year for their weakest comeback yet. Not that they are salty, but kinda underwhelmed because of that.

LOVE IT. the whole mini is fantastic too. very energetic and happy :)

Love the mini too, especially the title song!!

I don't like this comeback much.
For me their debut is still the best and every time after that it got worse.

^agree... although I kinda like square two, AIIYL was already very weak in comparison.
I feel this mini is nothing forward. it could have done by 2NE1 in 2010 - not only soundwise (looking at you Forever young) but also visual-vise (the Panzer, the fashion, the wigs, the theme)

It’s not my favorite comeback but there are some vocal notes in the title song that I like. I just hope they don’t wait another year before the next comeback. I got the impression that YG was having problems but I could be wrong.

Aiiyl is when I first listened to them, so it's become my favorite track by them.

I liked the poppier sound that it brought.

This comeback kind of sounds like anyone could've released it. It's not really "special" imo. Doesn't mean it's not good, just that...well, it's kind of generic I guess. It's "kpop."

the album is very flat to me and there are no hidden gems

They totally snatched my wig with this comeback. They're on fire right now and deserve all the attention they're receiving!