same here. too much vibrato, not only in the beginning for me.
actually i was expecting a version where she says "minna" instead of only "anata" once. like in the concert. that would have been 10th anniversary style in my opinion ^^

thank you :)

This sounds so amazing!
Thanks for the link and putting it up ^_^

owwwwwwwwww soooo cute! Makes me wanna run and hug ayu!

I love this new version! A great one.. But nothing beats the original! <3~

I like it alot! thank you!

Awesome,thank you.

Awesome 10x :P

I LOVE IIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!!
It gives me teary eyes... ;____;

will avex release a capella version for download? I really like it in the cm...

wow, thanks, it's about time anyway ^^

I'm in love with Who AGAIN!... That is if I'm ever out of love with it...

Thanks so much, haven't had the time to listen to it. Will do now. :yes

unlikely. it's not a digital single, only a bonus track for A COMPLETE.


but I really like this version and I'm not a fan of the other two.

It's not as 'epic' as I was hoping for... her vocals seem strained during parts and a little sharp.

Who... is one of my favorite songs ...

Yeaaaaaaaaaah, I really hope this isn't how she's going to deliver all her ballads from now on. :< Something about her vocals just bothers me now.

^ must agree. i was listening to it and was like... gawsh, she's just... not that great at singing anymore. she doesn't sound as steady anymore. she sounds restrained... and overdoes that a~a~a~
i can't help but think that she sounds like an old lady *scratches head*

and thanks to poster of the link.

^ Ouch! Is it really that bad? =/

This is yesterday's HK newspaper

It said that Ayu has recorded a mandarin version of "Who..." and contained in the Asia version of A COMPLETE. It also said Ayu may performed it in Hong Kong's concert...

If it is real, we will have a full mandarin version of Who... that performed in AT07...?

I like the version in A BALLADS more >_<