neither!!

Hilary ? she's nice, lindsay just seems like a ****...who takes drugs and gets drunk ?

Not thaat huge a fan of her music but Dignity is prretty allright CD, and i'm seeing her next month... though boyfriend says he's lost the tickets LOL

Hilary Duff

Lizzie Mcguire!!!!! I remember watching it every afternoon after school XD!!

neither

Lindsay has a lot of problems with drugs, alcochol, boys, clubs and...underwear :P
besides, she looks very unpretty for me
I saw her acting and actually didn't find anything special

Hilary is a good girl-cutie. but I think she also has not that big talent either

so not every of them can overcome the biggest unlucky sinner Britney, poor girl

just to add to that, these girls can't be queens

Madonna and Kylie rule the world

^agreed =)! except I don't think Hilary Duff is a cutie..... or a good girl. XD but the rest is true =)!

neither...

I love them both now :P

I like Hilary's new album, since she got rid of most of the tweeny pop rock =P So she wins by default, Lindsay's gone off the deep end... And I didn't like her before she did anyway. xD But uhh, neither are really Britney-ish...

I prefer Duff as a singer and Lohan as an actress, but they both do well interchangeably.

both had a few good songs but other than that I dont' really care for them. but they are pretty...at times.

Back in 2004, I would've said Lindsay Lohan, because she seemed like a nicer girl. But now... it's completely different. I gave Hil a chance and I listened to her latest album (Dignity) and even though there were so numbers I deleted at the first listen there were also some really surprisingly good songs and it did show she is really starting to become a mature woman. Lindsay on the other hand is now throwing herself in sex scenes, jumps in and out of a clinic 30 times a day, is whoring herself some naked pictures

So, I'm going for Hilary because she deserves more respect by keeping it together

Lindsay's albums are way hot. Too bad she went all junkie x/

Well, Lindsay's hotter than Hillary,and acts better, but Hillary has nice songs. But then again, I don't really care much about them.

I was both fan of them, but I love Hilary more (I have also an album of her)

Hilary Duff as a person, Lindsay Lohan as an actress. :yes

I think I'll vote for Duff, though, because she's grand in singing and in personality (and not the worst actress, I just think Lohan's a tad more appealing on screen).

EDIT: Oh, wait, the next Britney? Who cares? :P

Although, "I Know Who Killed Me" was a really bad movie!

As for who's the next Britney.... why would you want to be the next Britney? Be the next Madonna!

Hilary Duff is cute
Lindsay Lohan is sexy =P

i think Ashley Tisdale will be the next Britney Spears :laugh