Real or fake?Ayumi Hamasaki autographed Rock'n'Roll Circus CD+DVD
 

Hi all

i was browsing ebay when i found this


http://cgi.ebay.com/Ayumi-Hamasaki-a...item27b1acf94f

the seller is located in singapore.

but a little bit confusing why the seller keep telling he/she is in China.
and the seller type this.

how could he/she invite ayu?
as i know ayu has never visit singapore nor china after her photoshoot in London.
so just be aware ^_^

I think it's fake Ayu writes the year on her autographs.

You can use this thread as a guide http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=100636

Sorry~

well.

i have a real ayu autograph.
but not with the year.

^_^

honestly i can not say if only look at ayu autograph.

ayu's autograph is very simple.

anybody can replicate it.

http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/2130/stampayuka0.th.jpg

This is indeed kind of hard... I suppose unless they give you any prove, you can't know if it's real or not... though I've seen this seller come up a lot of times... and I'm not sure what to think, can't help you with this, sorry..

Ohhh scary...I have no idea but I am curious to see what other people say about it.

If it was real why whould the person want to sell it after he got it?

^to sell it a higher amount


it's too dark to tell if it's real or not

Yeah, it's too dark to tell really, but it doesn't sound right...

i would never pay more for a sign CD, reason cuz she didnt sign the CD to me and would hold no real meaning to me.

^ Those are totally my feelings, too. :no

And really, as others have mentioned, it's really dark, so it's extremely difficult to tell, at least just from a picture..... Honestly, even if it is real, because it's so hard to see, I kinda wouldn't want it, anyhow. XD

Did you not read this?

last time I checked, Ayu =/= SNSD. lol. I call fake.

It's the cheap Hong Kong version for a reason.....

Hm it is quite hard to tell~ But it's not likely :(

I think it's fake...they're not making that much more by selling it at that price. I wouldn't buy it just to be safe :no.



I will say that the pic is a little dark to really tell though..

While I am an avid ebay shopper and there are some good deals up there... this is definitely not one of them. lol

i think it's fake. there is no date.

100% fake

How can you have 3 copies of the autograph cd available and sell them at $59.00 each?

Funny thing is this seller store has autograph cd's from different artists too....

it's probably fake . If ayumi really signed the album personally , why did she only supposedly only sign on the sticker & not on the photobook & booklet too ? :shrug

Also I myself will never sell away autographed CDs of my own as it's too precious .

I have autographed CDs of The Click Five and Gareth Gates & even though I don't listen to english music anymore , I still keep them cos they have sentimental value attached to it

no monetary value's enough to place on them at all

hmm this is hard to tell..
hmm but just don't buy autographed CD if u may..
not worth it, as for me..
I would rather to have the CD signed by the artist in front of me rather than i buy through ebay or anywhere else~
it's much precious if you got ur CD signed in front of you..
well, that's me though~

That's pure bulls-hit, what on Earth has Ms Hamasaki's autograph gotta do with SNSD? This seller is probably from China, whom doesn't know much about Japan and Korea celebrities. The message seems more like it's directly translated from other language.

sooo fake!! 59$ eh eh

I don't trust it to be honest...

This person seems shady. The overly long description also is just way too much and just rambles on, as if to convince you it's real.
The signature just happens to be on the darkest part of the cover? Yeah right. I think it's FAKE!

ayu does not write the year on all her autographs. not having the date doesn't mean it's fake.

but then, i think the ones in this auction is fake.

I saw this seller was selling YamaPi's Loveless with autograph earlier. It seems that he/she selling only cds with autographs but it's really weird how he/she get's them. Ayu wasn't in Singapore this spring and Yamapi wasn't there last autumn either

I saw the likely thing on taobao.com(that one must be fake.some artists are real.but ayu's is fake)
WARNING
ayu's signature is very rare
so if he doesn't take a photo when ayu signed it
Don't think about it

I agree with this, I buy signed items off YJA! but I always ask for pictures of when the artist signed them (I usually get them when I ask for them, one seller even sent the picture with the CD for me) ^-^

Ayumi Hamasaki's Autograph, Rare?

hahahhaha don't make me laugh.... it's not as rare as you think. if it were so rare she wouldn't have signed x amount of items in London - there were several people there who got all of their items signed when there wasn't a huge group... nor would she have singed x amount of items for her family,staff, friends, etc... nor would she sign x amount of items at concerts, tv shows, etc. It would be more rare for a person to get an original Nothing from Nothing single/mini album than her autograph. oh not to mention she's been around for 10+ years now!

i guess it's fake~~