Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai

Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/index.php)
-   Ayu Celebrity News (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=92)
-   -   『M 愛すべき人がいて』The story of encounter & separation hidden in the birth of a songstress (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=124598)

Zeke. 27th July 2019 03:14 AM

『M 愛すべき人がいて』The story of encounter & separation hidden in the birth of a songstress
 
A Japanese friend pointed this out to me today. It looks like a book of sorts will be published by a popular non-fiction author centering around Ayu and Max Matsuura, and how their encounter ushered in the creation of Hamasaki Ayumi together, a creation that became too much for either of them to bear.

https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/43440349..._heVoDbFNW8XK6

それでもマサ、私は歌っているよ。
浜崎あゆみを生きているよ。

歌姫誕生に秘められた、出会いと別れの物語。

「二人で作り上げた“浜崎あゆみ"は、
マサにも、あゆにも、手に負えない
モンスターになってしまったね」

博多から上京したありふれた少女・あゆを変えたのは、
あるプロデューサーとの出会いだった。
やがて愛し合う二人は、“浜崎あゆみ"を
瞬く間にスターダムに伸し上げる。
しかし、別れは思いのほか、早く訪れ……。

maxikot 27th July 2019 09:57 AM

So he suddenly changes genres to fiction. It's interesting what's inside, though : >

EndOfTheWorld 28th July 2019 02:08 AM

Sounds very interesting. I don't think anyone will translate the whole book though.:laugh

ExodusUK 28th July 2019 02:29 AM

Is this an official book from Avex?

Aderianu 31st July 2019 10:35 AM

https://twitter.com/TA0413/status/11...541615616?s=19 video with today's news
They say that lyrix of M and Boys & Girls are about Ayu x Max love story

Minttulatte 31st July 2019 01:15 PM

This book sounds like a very interesting idea. Sucks that I don't understand Japanese at all tho so I can't read it. :/

aliceshields 31st July 2019 02:15 PM

Some info here, I guess...

浜崎あゆみ、松浦氏との恋を初告白 秘話綴られた本が出版

YUKARI 31st July 2019 05:40 PM

you can check more two-shot pics here https://curious-rabble.net/hamasaki-...ple_kiss_pics/

I wonder if this book really reveals anything new.

Aderianu 31st July 2019 06:11 PM

At the NTV Special Interview from 2000 they say "she turned her gratitude to her producer into a song Trust"

line "Our lips start to get closer" is from that song

JinHamasaki 31st July 2019 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aderianu (Post 3304459)
At the NTV Special Interview from 2000 they say "she turned her gratitude to her producer into a song Trust"

line "Our lips start to get closer" is from that song

Hmm I don’t remember that, I thought TO BE was the first song she wrote about Max.

I’ll have to rewatch the 2000 doc

Chibi-Chan 31st July 2019 09:37 PM

I wouldn't get my hopes up that this book is of any relevance at all. I read a few articles written by scientists from the social sciences in Japanese already and they were like 120% garbage.

orbitalaspect 31st July 2019 10:25 PM

Ayu over there on the TROUBLE cover like, "Grab my breasts, Max. I want them all to know..."

tokyoxjapanxfan 1st August 2019 01:36 AM

Me: Cool. Music?

DA1SUK1DAY01691 1st August 2019 01:57 AM

There's a bit of push back from some fans, who brought up the fact she was dating Nagase Tomoya around that time too. Interesting to see the author (Komatsu Narumi) interviewed Suzuki Ichiro, and wrote about X JAPAN's Yoshiki and GReeeeeN...

Translation of the Japanese:

Spoiler:
But even then Masa, I'm singing. Hamasaki Ayumi is still alive.

The story of the start and the end (of love) hidden in the birth of a diva.

"The 'Hamasaki Ayumi' we created has become a monster both you and I (Masa and Ayu) can't control anymore"

What changed Ayu, the plain girl from Hakata who came to Tokyo, was meeting a certain producer. Soon falling in love with each other, "Hamasaki Ayumi" was shot into stardom in the blink of an eye. However, the end came unexpectedly quickly...


Some are saying they'd rather have read about Nagase/Ayu, and others are concerned that coupling is next on the "target list."

The work is apparently "fiction based on fact" that Komatsu had gotten from Ayu herself. Some are saying they're not interested in something that happened 20 years ago, or are concerned that Ayu is that much on the verge of losing her A-list status (having resorted to selling her personal life stories in a tabloid-like fashion).

DA1SUK1DAY01691 1st August 2019 02:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aliceshields (Post 3304447)

I'll make this a separate post, haha.

This article says it covers from prior to her Avex debut to her big break in 1999 (roughly 4 years), and "reveals a forbidden love between herself and Matsuura, which will shed some light on the hidden details surrounding her hit songs at the time."

Spoiler:
Ayu and Nagase's relationship was comparable to a Hollywood relationship in terms of the affection and attention they got from the public, and that although some people thought the fact she married/divorced twice was due to the effects of her long relationship with Nagase, it was actually the strongest "pillar" in her life, Matsuura.

Ayu then moved to Tokyo with her mother and grandmother (father was out of the picture) when she was scouted as an actress, and supported her family that way. Then in the VIP section of Velfarre, a disco in Roppongi, she met Matsuura. Initially she had been a part of a 3-4 person group and told to do the vocals, which she was against because she didn't have the cooperative nature to do so, citing her previous report cards saying "let's work harder" in cooperating in class. She said she'd be able to live on her own, but had difficulty with others.

Matsuura said he wanted her by herself, and started her solo. Ayu (who we all know wrote her lyrics), said everything she wrote was like a love letter to Matsuura, who she'd fallen in love with; she also said "every word that came to her head was about that someone."

Not having immediate success, even Matsuura was ready to punch a television studio worker when they said "she isn't popular."

Unable to keep control of her feelings, she confessed them to Matsuura. Recently divorced, he showed up at Ayu's house and told her mother that they're dating. Having moved in together, Ayu started calling him "Masa," which set off Avex who were staunchly against it. Matsuura explained it away, saying "nothing can beat love."

Since this was right before her big break, she was extra careful, listing Matsuura as "M" in her phone.

Soon after, both became extremely busy, and started to only pass by each other, losing a lot of the time they were able to spend together. In '99, she visited the apartment Matsuura was sleeping over in to find him surrounded by staff and other beautiful women at a party. Shocked, Ayu stayed in a hotel for about two days.

This depression/shock allegedly came out in her three singles the following year: vogue, Far away, and SEASONS.

Ayu was more earnest/honest in her thoughts, while Matsuura was trying to push the product of "Hamasaki Ayumi" more. This created too large of a gap between them, so she ended the relationship at the end of 1999.

An insider said, "it was right for her to break up with him, because it's possible we wouldn't have gotten the hit songs we did. She even became 40% of Avex's total revenue alone."

The insider also thinks by releasing this book, Ayu and Matsuura trying to go back to the start line. "By laying it all bare, no matter how uncouth she may be seen, she's still just as cool now as she was during her peak years."

Interspersed with her lyrics, you'll want to listen to her music again when you finish the book.

Xianghua 1st August 2019 03:46 AM

^ thank you for the translation!

God, this story is already on this morning’s news shows

Yagami Raito 1st August 2019 04:03 AM

Nothing new since everyone already knew it...
I am curious and just wonder why they decided to release it now.

I kind of hope that it's a PR marketing first step leading to some new music release.... lol

EDIT: btw, the cover of the book is a photo that Max poster on his twitter some months ago.

Marilyn 1st August 2019 04:11 AM

impaktada

Andrenekoi 1st August 2019 04:32 AM

Well, the official story about how Ayu and Max started working together was always very strange, like...

"Oh, let me get this girl who never acomplished nothing, can't sing, can't dance, is skipping the singing classes we are paying to her and send her to another country for 6 months so she can pretend she finally learned how to sing so maybe she can become profitable in the near future! OMG, I'm a genius!"

Putting that much effort into her career cuz they were lovers make a lot more of sense. :P

pommy48 1st August 2019 07:27 AM

Man, I don’t want to think of Max when I hear M

280301 1st August 2019 09:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi (Post 3304485)
Well, the official story about how Ayu and Max started working together was always very strange, like...

"Oh, let me get this girl who never acomplished nothing, can't sing, can't dance, is skipping the singing classes we are paying to her and send her to another country for 6 months so she can pretend she finally learned how to sing so maybe she can become profitable in the near future! OMG, I'm a genius!"

Putting that much effort into her career cuz they were lovers make a lot more of sense. :P

This. I feel it's always been obvious that there was a romantic element to their relationship, at least early on. It's apparent in her lyrics and the photos of them clearly kissing in the late 90s.

hidekirby 1st August 2019 01:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tokyoxjapanxfan (Post 3304474)
Me: Cool. Music?

Exactly... What's left of her career is really getting poorly handled. What a mess. This plus Pei. She doesn't have enough bad press already. I hope it's the sign for new music :rolleyes

alternarist 1st August 2019 04:31 PM

wait whut? are all these for real?

hud 1st August 2019 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tokyoxjapanxfan (Post 3304474)
Me: Cool. Music?

this

Minttulatte 1st August 2019 05:01 PM

Damn, I didn't know about their relationship until now but I always knew there was something more behind the lyrics of some of her old songs but thought I was just reading too much into those lyrics lol.

And honestly, I like the Max/Ayu pairing. They don't look bad together in those pics that were posted on this thread. :D

metropass 1st August 2019 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hidekirby (Post 3304515)
Exactly... What's left of her career is really getting poorly handled. What a mess. This plus Pei. She doesn't have enough bad press already. I hope it's the sign for new music :rolleyes

The author of this book said “Ayu wish to deliever her feelings to fans in this new era of Japan after her 20th anniversary” in a TV interview. Well, I believe fans do want new music rather than revealing such gossip which already two decades ago.

njanjayrp 1st August 2019 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi (Post 3304485)
Well, the official story about how Ayu and Max started working together was always very strange, like...

"Oh, let me get this girl who never acomplished nothing, can't sing, can't dance, is skipping the singing classes we are paying to her and send her to another country for 6 months so she can pretend she finally learned how to sing so maybe she can become profitable in the near future! OMG, I'm a genius!"

Putting that much effort into her career cuz they were lovers make a lot more of sense. :P

Simple plans are always the best.

YUKARI 1st August 2019 06:49 PM

I think it was pretty obvious they had a romantic relationship for some time. I'd love to see them married! :( I even think Max/ayu is much bigger than Nagase Tomoya/ayu.

Andrenekoi 1st August 2019 07:27 PM

^Yeap. I don't think anyone ever believed on her potential at the same level he did..

orbitalaspect 1st August 2019 07:50 PM

Ayu was always a very fashionable and social teenager though. Add that to her appearance, and it's no wonder someone like Max would go through the trouble of getting Ayu to a national audience.

Let's compare Suzuki Ami here. Her entire second album was autotuned to (poorly) mask how bad her singing was. It still sold like 1.7 million copies. She just had the image.

I think Utada had also mentioned something similar to the start of her career, that it was far easier for her to break into music than it would have been for her to do what she wanted to do: be a teacher. She was the daughter of two known musicians. It was an easy cash grab to dress her up and have her bounce around for four minutes in front of a camera.

One thing I'm not sure many of you may have noticed about Ayu's career: the vast majority of it has been centered around her image. Rewatch her PVs. Andrenekoi has made the point before that she's been more artistic in her later years, and I think there's some actual truth to that. A lot of her first 10-15 years as an artist was centered around her beauty, her fashion sense, etc.

So, I genuinely don't think this was a romance thing. I think Ayu was pretty, friendly, fashionable. It was easy to get her popular. I mean, look at how Kuu's career took off after avex told her she was a bop and she completely changed her lifestyle and appearance to be more appealing to people.

DA1SUK1DAY01691 1st August 2019 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pommy48 (Post 3304497)
Man, I don’t want to think of Max when I hear M

This was the first thought I had when I read about her keeping him as “M” in her phone. :/

^^And yeah, the relatable lyrics definitely didn’t hurt her cause, but when you think back to the early ‘00s you bought into each artist’s image. Granted the music market and landscape changed, but I think the lack of promotional airtime on terrestrial airwaves is what hurt the Japanese market the most. You could watch Ayu fool around without Downtown for a bit then watch her performance and think, “oh, she’s funny and her song is kinda good! Maybe I’ll go buy it,” even if you weren’t a big fan. There aren’t as many opportunities for musicians to do that, so they feel a bit more distant than they did before. You felt like you knew the artist, so you’d be more willing to support them.

ohsixthirty 2nd August 2019 10:01 PM

You once said, long ago,
While stroking my hair,
"When you wake up, there'll be
A nice present waiting for you
By your pillow."
...
When I woke up,
I found by my pillow
A large teddy bear...
In place of Max Matsuura.

Ayumi Hamasaki - Teddy Bear

BlackSilence 3rd August 2019 12:43 AM

The funny/weird thing is i'm cool with her dating a fucking 19 year old but thinking of her in a close range age back in the day and Max, make me want to throw up lol But then again, some pics were fishy, so i don't think that is a surprise or a secret to anyone. Also NO they do not make a cute couple, he looks like a troll and she's a queen! NOOOOPE lol

So Ayu is alowing this BS to get released and GACKT is writing business advice books...gosh what are my fave artists doing? What is happening!? lol

Party_King 3rd August 2019 01:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ohsixthirty (Post 3304603)
You once said, long ago,
While stroking my hair,
"When you wake up, there'll be
A nice present waiting for you
By your pillow."
...
When I woke up,
I found by my pillow
A large teddy bear...
In place of Max Matsuura.

Ayumi Hamasaki - Teddy Bear

I ever thought teddy bear is about her father.
Especially after combining it with Memorial address...
I don’t want to believe that this track is for Max :o

Andrenekoi 3rd August 2019 03:10 AM

^Teddy Bear IS about her father.

But we can go a little freudian and point out Ayu's infatuation with a man that can be seen as a father figure anyway. :P

junshen 3rd August 2019 05:49 AM

Read the book! The content is interesting.

Getting positive reviews from
Japanese fans from
Negative

Andrenekoi 3rd August 2019 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by junshen (Post 3304612)
Read the book! The content is interesting.

Getting positive reviews from
Japanese fans from
Negative

Can you share some interesting stuff on it with us?

Edit: I read some reviews on Amazon Japan (thanks Google Translator).

Seens like a lot of people bought the book out of curiosity about celebrity gossip and ended up finding Ayu to be a very relatable person and admired the story about a common girl becoming a superstar. I don't think there was any review, even the negative ones, calling it a desperate move or some ridiculous exposition, people who disliked it mostly found it boring :B

Interesting... She may had just resignified the most iconic part of her career. And people seen to be reacting well to that.

Yagami Raito 3rd August 2019 12:27 PM

https://taishu.jp/articles/-/67463?page=1

There's going to be a Drama/TV series adaptation!

tokyoxjapanxfan 3rd August 2019 01:00 PM

I’m so curious who will play Ayu...

hidekirby 3rd August 2019 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yagami Raito (Post 3304626)
https://taishu.jp/articles/-/67463?page=1

There's going to be a Drama/TV series adaptation!

That's good news! May shed some light on her and bring her back in people's interests.

mizuki-7 3rd August 2019 01:17 PM

Wow that’s cool :)

tokyoxjapanxfan 3rd August 2019 01:50 PM

Tie up with a best 3 and bam, you got yourself some promotion lol

Minttulatte 3rd August 2019 02:03 PM

Damn, it's getting a TV adaptation? That's pretty awesome. I'm always interested in these types of stories. They're fascinating to me. :)

chocopockymaster 3rd August 2019 04:21 PM

Oh for fuck’s sake

attractive nausea 3rd August 2019 04:24 PM

Wow, I honestly don't know how to feel about all of this (not her romance with Max but the book + tv adaptation thing) but i'm happy if she gets good publicity from this....

The picture from the article, where does it come from??? She looks stunning!

Chibi-Chan 3rd August 2019 06:27 PM

Yeah, intersting. A story about a wealthy successfull man fucking a teen who is so desperate to make some money to contribute to her mum's income because her father left the family and is therefore in the idol industry selling bikini shots to men to masturbate to. Lovely story. Really, what could possibly be wrong here?
If Max really was involved with Ayu at the beginning of her career, that's sexual abuse. And you all know it.
If this is just gossip, it's still disgusting that Ayu allowed this book/drama adaptation to happen. Not to mention that all that people will think after reading/seeing this will be that the girl with no talent happened to fuck her way to the top and doesn't deserve her spot among the most successfull female Japanese artists at all.

ExodusUK 3rd August 2019 06:44 PM

Has she done some sort of a tv interview to be released for the book?
https://taishu.jp/mwimgs/e/7/-/img_e...7471111043.jpg

YUKARI 3rd August 2019 06:50 PM

I think this pic was shot at some of Kouhaku Utagassen's rehearsals a few years ago

Corvina 3rd August 2019 07:03 PM

From what I've seen, reviews and opinions are very mixed about this.

Personally I don't really understand it - first I thought somebody is making a book out of those old rumours, so whatever.
But then Ayu published her foreword she wrote for it where she basically confirms it's based on truth and there's the info out she gave the author interviews so she can write the novel.
I mean, what? Does she have to sell parts of her private life now for avex in her current career path?
Cause I don't think she needs it for herself, at least financially.
Whatever she wants, but I'd like her to concentrate on other things.

And well, yeah, Japan has sadly a history of romanticising relationships between older guys and younger girls (like teacher - pupil love stories in dramas).
Btw. the info about the drama I haven't seen anywhere else so far, so Idk how true that is.

YUKARI 3rd August 2019 07:07 PM

comments at GirlsChannel are pretty harsh like 'she got to the lowest point', 'now she really sells her private life', 'the only way to get attention', 'nobody cares'

like I'm OK with the book but making a TV dorama? part of me is disappointed but another part wonders who's going to play ayu and Max :laugh

Corvina 3rd August 2019 07:15 PM

Yeah, whatever they thought before making this - creating trouble to promote Trouble and the tour? - I don't think this is going to be good promotion.
Man, Ayu.

pommy48 3rd August 2019 07:21 PM

I remember how genuine she was when she was younger about not wanting to be sold as Ayumi Hamasaki, a product.

This was a calculated move involving her. I miss the days when her private life was private.

relmy 3rd August 2019 07:41 PM

Anyone have a summary of her foreward for it?

Andrenekoi 3rd August 2019 07:52 PM

Guys... Her whole career was based on her exploiting her personal life to make money. The majority lf of her lyrics, and every single one from her peak, are about her personal life. WTH? O_o

And I dont get the pommy48 comment about her not wanting to be a product when she said several times at her peak that this was exactly what she was/is. A product. This is even more funny on a forum where most of the complains about her is that she is not being "product enough".

mizuki-7 3rd August 2019 08:43 PM

I didn’t expect good comments from girlschannel LOL
People are quite hypocrite considering the book is Number 1 online it prove there are indeed curious...
It’s juste like a biography nothing wrong with that all.

truehappiness 3rd August 2019 10:55 PM

Oh my.

primavera♥ 3rd August 2019 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Corvina (Post 3304648)
From what I've seen, reviews and opinions are very mixed about this.

Personally I don't really understand it - first I thought somebody is making a book out of those old rumours, so whatever.
But then Ayu published her foreword she wrote for it where she basically confirms it's based on truth and there's the info out she gave the author interviews so she can write the novel.
I mean, what? Does she have to sell parts of her private life now for avex in her current career path?
Cause I don't think she needs it for herself, at least financially.
Whatever she wants, but I'd like her to concentrate on other things.

And well, yeah, Japan has sadly a history of romanticising relationships between older guys and younger girls (like teacher - pupil love stories in dramas).
Btw. the info about the drama I haven't seen anywhere else so far, so Idk how true that is.

She probably doesn't need it for herself? These are all assumptions people are making to make it so much more complicated. It's so much easier to be a fan of celebrities when you don't do that, but it's up to you.

It happened 20 years ago, so its literally history from a couple decades ago. Plenty of fictional stories like this exist where people interview the figures of interest (or related figures) and then edit to make the story they want. Ayu's career is old as shit and she's not in her prime anymore, so it doesn't seem like a big deal to take an interview for this. At least in my perspective. And a lot of this info is stuff people knew or assumed (but even if it wasn't, what I said applies).

She's also not writing this novel so the point on focusing on other things seems irrelevant, no? This doesnt stop her from doing anything else.

On another note, people complain about ayu selling her private life...but this story is old, and we've always known things to some extent about her private life, whether about relationships or family history, etc, so I don't think it's a new phenomenon.

In general, it's a book. People write books about many things, including celebrities. Nothing new.

Somewhat unrelated to the above, I'd honestly be interested in hearing more about ayu's first decade of her career in general. It's far away, so it would be neat if she shared stories (unrelated to someone else's personal project like a novel they want to write). That's up to her though I guess and also whatever she's allowed to say without repercussions from avex.

njanjayrp 3rd August 2019 11:23 PM

^ Also some AHS members have a need to seize every opportunity they have to portray ayu in the worst way possible, tbh the whole “selling of her private life” thing is beyond ridiculous. She is a public figure who has been in the medias for more than 20 years. Each of the songs she has been selling is a piece of her private life. It always has been.

Also that post by chibi-chan WTF??? Overreacting much?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi (Post 3304657)
Guys... Her whole career was based on her exploiting her personal life to make money. The majority lf of her lyrics, and every single one from her peak, are about her personal life. WTH? O_o

And I dont get the pommy48 comment about her not wanting to be a product when she said several times at her peak that this was exactly what she was/is. A product. This is even more funny on a forum where most of the complains about her is that she is not being "product enough".

To bad she isn’t having a single out in September. They definitely don’t know how to cash these in.

tokyoxjapanxfan 4th August 2019 01:27 AM

Honestly I’m pretty sure the Ayu we had at her peak was an absolute direct result of Max’s influence, control and input.

Once he disappeared from overseeing her, and she really became in charge, is the “real” Ayu, imo.

Zeke. 4th August 2019 01:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njanjayrp (Post 3304666)
Also that post by chibi-chan WTF??? Overreacting much

lol

URANUS 4th August 2019 01:41 AM

I'm actually excited what Ayu has up her sleeve because this is obviously a marketing plot to get her on the news.

I'm thinking something is being released soon (hopefully a new album) because this book is #1 on Amazon and is selling like hot cakes. It's definitely working and getting her a lot of attention.


I'm shocked and surprised M is about Max. It's making me curious and want to revisit some of the songs that are about Max.

Andrenekoi 4th August 2019 01:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njanjayrp (Post 3304666)
^ Also some AHS members have a need to seize every opportunity they have to portray ayu in the worst way possible, tbh the whole “selling of her private life” thing is beyond ridiculous. She is a public figure who has been in the medias for more than 20 years. Each of the songs she has been selling is a piece of her private life. It always has been.

Also that post by chibi-chan WTF??? Overreacting much?



To bad she isn’t having a single out in September. They definitely don’t know how to cash these in.

I wouldn't be surprised if either the book or the drama will be used as a way for her to release something...

The funny thing in here is that people are always running their mouth to say how irrelevante she became and them there she is grabbing people's attention again.

Machiko 4th August 2019 04:37 AM

If there's ever a fan translation or it gets translated to english — I'd be interested to read it for sure.

Marilyn 4th August 2019 05:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi (Post 3304657)
Guys... Her whole career was based on her exploiting her personal life to make money. The majority lf of her lyrics, and every single one from her peak, are about her personal life. WTH? O_o

And I dont get the pommy48 comment about her not wanting to be a product when she said several times at her peak that this was exactly what she was/is. A product. This is even more funny on a forum where most of the complains about her is that she is not being "product enough".


THIS :luv2

visionfactory 4th August 2019 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pommy48 (Post 3304652)
I remember how genuine she was when she was younger about not wanting to be sold as Ayumi Hamasaki, a product.

This was a calculated move involving her. I miss the days when her private life was private.

I think you got the wrong artist :shakehead

rikku1994 4th August 2019 12:04 PM

Man it makes me question how long some of y'all been fans of her? Her private life was never kept private in the first place. Not even through gossips but through lyrics? And that Max and Ayu gossip? Like that gossip was going on since the late 90's and anyone who really knew Ayu from the beginning already knows what's up, we're just gonna get more details. I'm not surprised tho cause there was smth "romantic" going on between the two of them at least for a few years. Tho it never really got serious compared to TK and Tomomi, now that was a total train wreck.

Some of y'all are just so dramatic and act as if Ayu was an innocent girl when the fact is that she was never the typical japanese good girl from the start... Max discovered her at a club and she was a high school dropout for God's sakes lmao

I don't know what is the big deal, knowing that a lot of these stuff has happened nearly 20 years ago, I don't think Ayu nor Max cares and thus a confirmation from Ayu herself. At least these rumors would be put to rest.

Toniayu123 4th August 2019 12:37 PM

It seems we’re forgetting something, this is a fictional book based on reality, which part it’s true and what part is not we’ll never know.

Anyway, hope for some music release this autumn.

xLuna&1LOVE 4th August 2019 01:08 PM

Kinda sad it had to come to this. Also, I am not sure if I really want to know about all this... in so many details I mean. Slightly sided with Chibi-Chan here.

Also M about Max??!! Maybe it is just me, but it seems reaaaaaaaally farfetched.

Tho, if it is true about TV adaption, I kinda wish Mika Ninagawa would take the job and make Helter Skelter 2.

JinHamasaki 4th August 2019 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by URANUS (Post 3304673)
I'm actually excited what Ayu has up her sleeve because this is obviously a marketing plot to get her on the news.

Grabbing that cash! I foresee a launch of A BEST 3 around the Tokyo Olympics to not only grab domestic sales but also increase international exposure. All we need now is to see her being friendly with Sheena Ringo who is one of the five Creative Directors for the 2020 Ceremonies.

280301 4th August 2019 03:55 PM

I have an issue with the whole manager/producer dating a young/upcoming singer dynamic as others have mentioned, but I also want to mention that I hope this doesn't change the perception of prime Ayumi Hamasaki as a self made, motivated woman...but I can't help but feel this will. I know Max was always highly involved with her career/always believed Ayu and him had a thing, but I've also staunchly believed that Ayu paved her own way and wasn't dependent professionally or creatively upon the power of a man high up at Avex. I really hope no specific songs are mentioned, because the appeal of Ayu to me was always the ambiguity of her lyrics and thus their applicability to people in my own life / theorizing about who she could be talking about (simply for fun!). Confirmation of certain songs being about specific people (aside from of course, those songs that are about family/friends who have passed and are meant to be a form of remembrance) would impact how I perceive certain tracks. But whatever I guess, we get tidbits about songs in interviews every now and then regardless. This really is no different to that, though I suppose it feels more like a mass transformation of those earlier eras for me.

Cahz- 4th August 2019 04:17 PM

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EBDnTPmU...g&name=900x900
:mischief

SunshineSlayer 4th August 2019 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chibi-Chan (Post 3304644)
Yeah, intersting. A story about a wealthy successfull man fucking a teen who is so desperate to make some money to contribute to her mum's income because her father left the family and is therefore in the idol industry selling bikini shots to men to masturbate to. Lovely story. Really, what could possibly be wrong here?
If Max really was involved with Ayu at the beginning of her career, that's sexual abuse. And you all know it.
If this is just gossip, it's still disgusting that Ayu allowed this book/drama adaptation to happen. Not to mention that all that people will think after reading/seeing this will be that the girl with no talent happened to fuck her way to the top and doesn't deserve her spot among the most successfull female Japanese artists at all.

How is it abuse? A little unsettling, maybe, but I wouldn't go so far as abuse. We don't know exactly what or how things were said, and there has always appeared to be a genuine affection between them. And correct me if I'm wrong, but Ayu would have been between the ages of 18-21 at the time.

What you said is all true - she was an idol selling bikini shots for men to masturbate too. But why hide that? I honestly think it's kind of refreshing because she hid her pre-Avex career so much post-fame. It's what happened. Why not embrace it?

And this should come as a shock to no one. It was always heavily rumored and there were pictures of them kissing for christsakes.

I also don't see how this means she doesn't deserve her spot among the most successful female artists of all time. I mean, how she came to fame was always how she came to fame. So you're saying she deserved her spot so long as her past was never officially acknowledged, even though that is indeed what happened? That doesn't make sense. And just sayin' but MANY of the top female artists in Japan have something salacious to their stories. I mean, most of the top females (at least in Japan, not among foreign fans) are idols, and that entire industry is effed up to the max.

njanjayrp 4th August 2019 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer (Post 3304715)
How is it abuse? Correct me if I'm wrong, but Ayu would have been between the ages of 18-21 at the time.

What you said is all true - she was an idol selling bikini shots for men to masturbate too. But why hide that? I honestly think it's kind of refreshing because she hid her pre-Avex career so much post-fame. It's what happened. Why not embrace it?

And this should come as a shock to no one. It was always heavily rumored and there were pictures of them kissing for christsakes.

I also don't see how this means she doesn't deserve her spot among the most successful female artists of all time. I mean, how she came to fame was always how she came to fame. So you're saying she deserved her spot so long as her past was never officially acknowledged, even though that is indeed what happened? That doesn't make sense. And just sayin' but MANY of the top female artists in Japan have something salacious to their stories. I mean, most of the top females (at least in Japan, not among foreign fans) are idols, and that entire industry is effed up to the max.

100% on point.

rikku1994 4th August 2019 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer (Post 3304715)
How is it abuse? A little unsettling, maybe, but I wouldn't go so far as abuse. We don't know exactly what or how things were said, and there has always appeared to be a genuine affection between them. And correct me if I'm wrong, but Ayu would have been between the ages of 18-21 at the time.

What you said is all true - she was an idol selling bikini shots for men to masturbate too. But why hide that? I honestly think it's kind of refreshing because she hid her pre-Avex career so much post-fame. It's what happened. Why not embrace it?

And this should come as a shock to no one. It was always heavily rumored and there were pictures of them kissing for christsakes.

I also don't see how this means she doesn't deserve her spot among the most successful female artists of all time. I mean, how she came to fame was always how she came to fame. So you're saying she deserved her spot so long as her past was never officially acknowledged, even though that is indeed what happened? That doesn't make sense. And just sayin' but MANY of the top female artists in Japan have something salacious to their stories. I mean, most of the top females (at least in Japan, not among foreign fans) are idols, and that entire industry is effed up to the max.

THIS

Andrenekoi 4th August 2019 07:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer (Post 3304715)
How is it abuse? A little unsettling, maybe, but I wouldn't go so far as abuse. We don't know exactly what or how things were said, and there has always appeared to be a genuine affection between them. And correct me if I'm wrong, but Ayu would have been between the ages of 18-21 at the time.

What you said is all true - she was an idol selling bikini shots for men to masturbate too. But why hide that? I honestly think it's kind of refreshing because she hid her pre-Avex career so much post-fame. It's what happened. Why not embrace it?

And this should come as a shock to no one. It was always heavily rumored and there were pictures of them kissing for christsakes.

I also don't see how this means she doesn't deserve her spot among the most successful female artists of all time. I mean, how she came to fame was always how she came to fame. So you're saying she deserved her spot so long as her past was never officially acknowledged, even though that is indeed what happened? That doesn't make sense. And just sayin' but MANY of the top female artists in Japan have something salacious to their stories. I mean, most of the top females (at least in Japan, not among foreign fans) are idols, and that entire industry is effed up to the max.

It's also not like she never did it again post-fame either...

Aderianu 4th August 2019 08:01 PM

A COMPLETE back to top few weeks ago, a little before this book

Evan Odinson 4th August 2019 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer (Post 3304715)
How is it abuse? A little unsettling, maybe, but I wouldn't go so far as abuse. We don't know exactly what or how things were said, and there has always appeared to be a genuine affection between them. And correct me if I'm wrong, but Ayu would have been between the ages of 18-21 at the time.

What you said is all true - she was an idol selling bikini shots for men to masturbate too. But why hide that? I honestly think it's kind of refreshing because she hid her pre-Avex career so much post-fame. It's what happened. Why not embrace it?

And this should come as a shock to no one. It was always heavily rumored and there were pictures of them kissing for christsakes.

I also don't see how this means she doesn't deserve her spot among the most successful female artists of all time. I mean, how she came to fame was always how she came to fame. So you're saying she deserved her spot so long as her past was never officially acknowledged, even though that is indeed what happened? That doesn't make sense. And just sayin' but MANY of the top female artists in Japan have something salacious to their stories. I mean, most of the top females (at least in Japan, not among foreign fans) are idols, and that entire industry is effed up to the max.

Yes, so much yes :yes

chocopockymaster 4th August 2019 10:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tokyoxjapanxfan (Post 3304670)
Honestly I’m pretty sure the Ayu we had at her peak was an absolute direct result of Max’s influence, control and input.

Once he disappeared from overseeing her, and she really became in charge, is the “real” Ayu, imo.

This is 100% what happened and no one will ever convince me otherwise tbh

emi♡ 5th August 2019 01:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DA1SUK1DAY01691 (Post 3304475)
What changed Ayu, the plain girl from Hakata who came to Tokyo

Wait, the same plain girl who would dye her hair and run off and be gone all the time?

hahahahaahahaahaha

But omg her and Max? THIS IS BRAND NEW INFORMATION

Zeke. 5th August 2019 01:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chocopockymaster (Post 3304726)
This is 100% what happened and no one will ever convince me otherwise tbh

That’s right. Another important part of the text, which appears on the cover and I believe hasn’t been translated here yet, is something along the likes of “I loved one man so much I destroyed myself.”

I think ayu went on living as the creation Hamasaki Ayumi under his guidance, and in later years when she started pitching the “real ayu,” thing, like doing open interviews, “nude” themes and trying to convey herself on more of an personal level, is when she tried to regain who she was/is outside of the persona that was created for her.

freedreamer 5th August 2019 06:28 AM

I read through 4 pages and im still confused. LOL

1. Is this fiction or non-fiction ultimately?
2. M is about max?
3. Boys & Girls is about max too?!?

Ryusei 5th August 2019 09:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aderianu (Post 3304723)
A COMPLETE back to top few weeks ago, a little before this book

It always rises when it's on discount. I wonder why A COMPLETE and A BEST havent been certified gold yet... this has gone on for years you cant tell me that those albums havent sold 100k digital copies yet..

Aderianu 5th August 2019 01:57 PM

A BEST not gold yet? How can it be, it was on top at year chart

Corvina 5th August 2019 02:16 PM

In general digital album sales are pretty low in Japan.
But A Complete is going to reach 100k eventually.
Afaik it's around 50k something on Oricon's chart in total.

Edit:
This is the chart from last week:
https://imagizer.imageshack.com/v2/6...923/u3jaN3.jpg

Though you have to add what it sold before Oricon started its digital album chart about 2.5 years ago, so it must be a bit higher already.

Not many albums have reached a digital certification yet at all.
If you wanna check out, I regularly update the thread in the Asian Music section.

Chibi-Chan 5th August 2019 08:06 PM

I'm working at a summer school at my university right now and teaching German to Japanese students. Since it is always an easy topic to talk about in a language one just started learning, I talked to them about what kind of music/artists they like. In return they asked me whom I like. Also a Japanese friend came to visit me just today and stays at my place. Everyone seemed to have heared about this book and the first thing my friend asked me was like "is Ayu ok?". And she only was that nice in formulating the question that way because she knows how much I like Ayu. What she actually wanted to ask and did so later was more like "has Ayu gone totally nuts now?". The reaction from the students was kinda the same and it was obvious that they tried to be nice. What they said about her regarding the book in Japanese because they assumed I wouldn't understand was pretty clear.
My opinion on the whole "Max dating 17 year old Ayu" aside, selling her private gossip from 20 years ago was the worst idea she ever came up with. It's one thing if gossip like this is out there and something she can't control. But selling it on purpose? This really is a poor move only absolutely irrelevant people would normally do. If she wanted to prove the public right and to see her as irrelevant and as some has been and desperately attention seeking, she succeded.

orbitalaspect 5th August 2019 09:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chibi-Chan (Post 3304752)
I'm working at a summer school at my university right now and teaching German to Japanese students. Since it is always an easy topic to talk about in a language one just started learning, I talked to them about what kind of music/artists they like. In return they asked me whom I like. Also a Japanese friend came to visit me just today and stays at my place. Everyone seemed to have heared about this book and the first thing my friend asked me was like "is Ayu ok?". And she only was that nice in formulating the question that way because she knows how much I like Ayu. What she actually wanted to ask and did so later was more like "has Ayu gone totally nuts now?". The reaction from the students was kinda the same and it was obvious that they tried to be nice. What they said about her regarding the book in Japanese because they assumed I wouldn't understand was pretty clear.
My opinion on the whole "Max dating 17 year old Ayu" aside, selling her private gossip from 20 years ago was the worst idea she ever came up with. It's one thing if gossip like this is out there and something she can't control. But selling it on purpose? This really is a poor move only absolutely irrelevant people would normally do. If she wanted to prove the public right and to see her as irrelevant and as some has been and desperately attention seeking, she succeded.

I don't think people outside of Japan get that the dynamics of image are very different within Japan. Like, sure, we want Ayu to keep doing her thing, but unfortunately, that "thing" has literally chipped away at her legacy. Comments and questions about Ayu's sanity started years ago, but now it seems like they're more common within Japan than more positive comments and questions.

It's just so weird to see someone like Ayu flub this image thing so hard. I mean, she's only human, but it's just awkward to live in a time where so many people think she's a scandal magnet. And it's been building for the better part of 10 years now. And she doesn't seem to give a damn about that shift in attitude toward her legacy. She still does things that, regardless of gender, many people find inappropriate or bad rep.

I love Ayu for what she's given us, but I do wish her heart was still in this. All that talent has no message anymore. It's like she doesn't have anything to say or experiences to share with others. And what's worse is that now, more than at any time in her career, the whole world desperately needs messages of sadness, loneliness, isolation, and hope, inner strength, and integrity.

But nope. Ayu is now banging her backup dancer two marriages later, extending a tour she launched off a mini-album, hasn't put out anything solid for music in over three years, has basically dropped out of performing at huge events for all of Japanese pop music, and spends more effort posting fashion pics on Instagram than on original tour concepts or even non-music activities like Utada did during her hiatus.

Some days, I just wish climate change would hurry up.

Edit: I just want to emphasize my disappointment by pointing out I recently watched Yumi Matsutoya's Uchuu Toshokan Tour and was so moved by the whole set and Yumi's energy on stage. And she's been in the industry since the 70s. Her heyday was the mid-to-late 80s. But I just love so so much that even if she takes a few years to release new music, she's 60+ years old and that music feels like it has a message. To be 38 albums into your career and still performing like she did on that tour... It's sad that Ayu's effort even half that timeline is so pitifully disregarding. And Ayu is a waaay better singer, writer, and performer than Yumi.

Andrenekoi 5th August 2019 10:42 PM

^I find that comment to be really unfair to her...
In the past 10 years Ayu touched a lot more of urgent issues than her peers. She sang being a woman in Japan, shared the spotlight with LGBTQ people in a culture that pretend they doesn't exist outside of the romantic/sexual fantasies of straight people, sang about feeling alienated, about the risks of escapism through partying ans alcohol. She sang about her fears about her future, about her current health state, about the issues her see on human relationship on her culture. She gave the middle finger about the expectatations her culture have about her while also singing about how hard it is for her doing that.

And she also performed about her personal struggles, the women condition, thr LGBTQ people issues, the feeling of isolation that exists so agressively on her country.

People want Ayu to be bold, but not too bold. To take risks, but not too much risks, to be a non conformist, but only if she is ultimetely conforming.

And them there are those rants about "Ayu, what people will think! D:" everytime she doesn't just pretend be edgy by simulating she is going against the norms, but actually does so. If there's something the world needs in face of rising extreme conservative thiking is someone of Ayu's scale being as unapolagetic, shamless and non-conformist as Ayu is.

That being said, this whole book thing is a clearly publicity stunt, and it's so silly and make people unconfortable with so little that I can't help but live over this. Lol.

DA1SUK1DAY01691 5th August 2019 10:52 PM

Your most helpful Amazon reviews (as of 8/5/2019):

Spoiler:
Makikou (Best 500 Reviewer)
8/1/19 (3 stars)

"No one wanted to compare answers like this"

I've said it regarding her concerts as well, but since Ayu's voice became unwell, I'm a fan who stopped listening to her music before I knew it.

Since this book was being talked about so much, I bought it out of curiosity. It showcases her conflicts and anguish from before her debut until she became an artist.

I think everyone has connected her songs to their own memories. M, for example, was popular as a love song, as were others. For a love song, it's not strange for that person to have their own person in the background (to which the song is written). But personally, I didn't want us to be comparing answers like this. If you'd like to leave these memories as memories, I wouldn't recommend reading this book.

Anonymous customer
8/1/2019 (5 stars)

"My tears didn't stop"

As someone around Hamasaki Ayumi's age, it made my heart hurt to find out that even she couldn't have what she really wanted, even as a great singer who was so cute at the time, and seemed like she could get anything she wanted. However, I think exactly because she had those experineces she was able to write those lyrics that can make you cry. I'm moved thinking about the drama behind the songs that seemed to sell so quickly. Even though people are saying that releasing this book now (after all these years) is cringey, knowing this background makes the songs we listen to deeper, making me want to listen to Hamasaki Ayumi's music again. To have met someone you love this much, be able to create a life together, and create a relationship that you couldn't show as lovers or through a marriage, I think it's a wonderful life.

Hide
8/1/2019 (1 star)

"Who is this book for?"

A lot of TV programs today kept talking about this today so I read it. I finished it instantly. The content is lacking and flimsy. If you were enough of a fan, this was common knowledge. It's just written as a dramatization and made to be moving, and dishonest with its vague writing style making you question what's fiction and what's nonfiction. The writer's position isn't clearly established. As a bonus, Hamasaki Ayumi appears on the last page as if to make an excuse for this book. Who is this book written for? This is the first time I've seen a book that disregards its fans this much.

ExodusUK 5th August 2019 10:56 PM

She needs to remake/recycle Days ASAP to capitalize on this.

Andrenekoi 5th August 2019 11:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ExodusUK (Post 3304757)
She needs to remake/recycle Days ASAP to capitalize on this.


M-2019 shameless gossip explotation mix- where she sings "Masa" instead of "Maria"

SunshineSlayer 6th August 2019 12:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freedreamer (Post 3304731)
I read through 4 pages and im still confused. LOL

1. Is this fiction or non-fiction ultimately?
2. M is about max?
3. Boys & Girls is about max too?!?

It is a fictionalized retelling of non-fiction is what I'm getting from it. Kind of like movies based on real events; not verbatim what happened, but the gist of it.

And yeah, I can totally see M being about her Max breakup. The lyrics to Boys and Girls don't really scream it to me, but sure.

Evan Odinson 6th August 2019 12:48 AM

Ok I'm lost and really curious about how this works, does Ayu have anything to do with this book? I mean the idea/writting process/ publishing, etc. I really don't know about these topics so if someone could clear it out for me it'd be much appreciated! Because for what I get, this is "reality mixed with some fiction from the author and some interviews quotes" if so I wonder if Ayu had anything to say regarding it being published (or not), sounds pretty vague to me, if she didn't have anything to do with it I don't get how is she "seeking attention using her personal life", is she credited as a part of the book process or was just the inspiration? like those unofficial Britney biographies where they made her look really bad :rolleyes

SunshineSlayer 6th August 2019 12:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evan Odinson (Post 3304761)
Ok I'm lost and really curious about how this works, does Ayu have anything to do with this book? I mean the idea/writting process/ publishing, etc. I really don't know about these topics so if someone could clear it out for me it'd be much appreciated! Because for what I get, this is "reality mixed with some fiction from the author and some interviews quotes" if so I wonder if Ayu had anything to say regarding it being published (or not), sounds pretty vague to me, if she didn't have anything to do with it I don't get how is she "seeking attention using her personal life", is she credited as a part of the book process or was just the inspiration? like those unofficial Britney biographies where they made her look really bad :rolleyes

Yes, Ayu is very involved with the book. She wrote the forward to the book, if I'm seeing correctly. She also gave interviews, as did Max, to the author of the book with the intention of the author making this book out of them.

Evan Odinson 6th August 2019 01:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer (Post 3304762)
Yes, Ayu is very involved with the book. She wrote the forward to the book, if I'm seeing correctly. She also gave interviews, as did Max, to the author of the book with the intention of the author making this book out of them.

I see, I kept reading "reality mixed with fiction" and blah blah and got really confused lol thanks for clarifying! :yes

love in music 6th August 2019 02:43 AM

I'm interested in the TV adaptation... might be cringey but sounds interesting. I kind of assumed Max had a thing for Ayu when he discovered her and that they probably hooked up but didn't really think Ayu felt anything serious for him. Her life is pretty interesting, why not write a book about it. I just think she should write one herself, I think she'd be a great author.

chocopockymaster 6th August 2019 05:03 AM

I think the two things that are really bothering me are: why now, and why this medium?

Maybe the first question is less important than the second one. The randomness of it really does make it seem like a cash grab or a ploy for publicity. She just had a milestone anniversary and I would have loved to see this story, since she clearly wants to tell it, in the light of a broader retrospective on her earlier career.

At the end of the day, I just can’t wrap my head around why she chose to present it like this. I get that it’s her story to tell and she ultimately gets to decide how the public hears it but...you’re going to let a stranger write a dramatized version of the story of one of the most formative relationships of your life? I’m sure she was able to give the final OK before it went to print but this is just so fucking bizarre that I can’t help but sit here, shaking my head in complete bewilderment.

JinHamasaki 6th August 2019 05:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chocopockymaster (Post 3304765)
I think the two things that are really bothering me are: why now, and why this medium?

Maybe the first question is less important than the second one. The randomness of it really does make it seem like a cash grab or a ploy for publicity. She just had a milestone anniversary and I would have loved to see this story, since she clearly wants to tell it, in the light of a broader retrospective on her earlier career.

Bohemian Rhapsody was a huge hit in Japan - I think it was 13 weeks in top 5 chart. I agree that the book wasn't as hyped, but maybe this is just testing the waters.

They are probably banking on the TV adaptation.

njanjayrp 6th August 2019 08:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chibi-Chan (Post 3304752)
I'm working at a summer school at my university right now and teaching German to Japanese students. Since it is always an easy topic to talk about in a language one just started learning, I talked to them about what kind of music/artists they like. In return they asked me whom I like. Also a Japanese friend came to visit me just today and stays at my place. Everyone seemed to have heared about this book and the first thing my friend asked me was like "is Ayu ok?". And she only was that nice in formulating the question that way because she knows how much I like Ayu. What she actually wanted to ask and did so later was more like "has Ayu gone totally nuts now?". The reaction from the students was kinda the same and it was obvious that they tried to be nice. What they said about her regarding the book in Japanese because they assumed I wouldn't understand was pretty clear.
My opinion on the whole "Max dating 17 year old Ayu" aside, selling her private gossip from 20 years ago was the worst idea she ever came up with. It's one thing if gossip like this is out there and something she can't control. But selling it on purpose? This really is a poor move only absolutely irrelevant people would normally do. If she wanted to prove the public right and to see her as irrelevant and as some has been and desperately attention seeking, she succeded.

I don’t understand what’s “nuts” about it? Also I think it’s safe to say that whatever she does latest is according to you the worst idea she has ever had :P

Tabloids earn a lot of cash writing shit about her all the time, why not monetize on your own story/misfortune while everyone else is making money out of it anyways. It’s business and you are taking it a bit too personally imo.

Also being judged by the Japanese society means that to the rest of the world you are regular person with an actual life and not some make-believe shit fantasy of innocence and fake moral. If Utada Hikaru released a book about her relationship with a guy who directed her music videos, also considerably older than her, this would be the best selling book with no judgement attached.

You guys have problems with ayu dating both older and younger people. It’s best for her to join a covent and spend her life not having sex with anyone.

orbitalaspect 6th August 2019 09:16 AM

Unfortunately, people, Ayu is a Japanese artist, not an American or European artist. And I know this is a lot to swallow, because diversity is only skin deep in the West, but Japan has a culture, that culture has certain traditions, one of those traditions is to not be the reason others gossip. So, arguing that this is perfectly normal for you and thereby perfectly normal in the context of Ayu is honestly shameful and ignorant.

We can all agree that relative to our own cultures, a lot of norms in other cultures seem completely nonsensical. But cultural relativism is racism. We're talking about Japan and Japanese culture. We're not talking about how much Japanese culture should approach this situation the way our cultures would approach it.

Andrenekoi 6th August 2019 10:52 AM

^Shameful and ignorant projecting your perception of a culture on her in order to belittle her, someone who is actually a part of that culture and way more aware of its complexities, so you can complain she doesn't fit an idealized version of how you believe she should be or how she should act as a japanese person.
She herself chose her lifestyle as a actual Japonese woman and how to approach her own issues with her own culture the way she does and most likely is well aware of its consequences.
This also doesn't happen only in Japan as every culture has its own share of hypocrital expectations over and will suffer some level of moral judgement once they go against it.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:24 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.