Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai

Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/index.php)
-   Enquiries (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   why "Maria"? (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=13813)

M_aria 26th January 2004 07:44 AM

why "Maria"?
 
For a brief moment I was going to say that I've heard the name "Maria" in a lot of J-pop songs, but now only two come to mind (Ayu & hitomi). Anyways, is there some religious aspect to these songs? I've read translations for both of them and "M" sounds like it has a bit more spiritual influence in comparison to hitomi's "Maria", does Ayu refer to the Virgin Mary in "M"? Cause, in a way, it sounds like she's praying. Also, is Maria a popular name in Japan? I swear i've heard it in some other songs, I just can't remember who...

kournikova 26th January 2004 09:19 AM

yep that song is for virgin mary ^^ i often sing it before i pray

Aga-chan 26th January 2004 09:56 AM

Yeah, some J-Artists have songs entitled or with references to "Maria".
Gackt-san has one, too. And LUNA SEA have a song called "VIRGIN MARY".

starr5245 15th February 2004 10:31 AM

so cool and so nice!!

Chrono 15th February 2004 12:39 PM

it's weird, isn't it. i doubt the people are christian.. somehwo they just like maria :P

sxesven 15th February 2004 12:41 PM

It has been rumoured a lot though that Ayu is a christian. I dunno, I'm guessing she isn't but I can't be 100% sure.

Chrono 15th February 2004 01:54 PM

well... she's always wearing those crosses... i can't really picture you doing that ^^. at least i wouldn't... but maybe if the record company demands...

aargh... it's... so......... confusing!!

sxesven 15th February 2004 01:55 PM

She flirts with all kind of religions, not just being a christian.

Chrono 15th February 2004 02:00 PM

all kinds? which other? i never saw her with anything else than a cross....

sxesven 15th February 2004 02:00 PM

Buddhism and such.

Chrono 15th February 2004 02:05 PM

well, i don't really hear songs about some buddism people.. only maria... isn't weird...

what a coincidence.... maria just starts playing here on my winamp shuffle mode ^^

Shiso 15th February 2004 02:06 PM

The www.ayu-mi-x.com 's database says that Ayu's 'M' isn't a song about the 'Virgin Mary'

From the site:

Ayu wrote this song after reading the story of Mary Magdaline. For those of you unfamiliar, Mary Magdaline is NOT the mother of Jesus (as according to the christian bible) - thats another Mary - but rather a reformed prostitute and friend to Jesus and Mary (Jesus' mother). The story of heartbreak and seperated lovers im 'M' was drawn from Mary Magdaline's story.

sxesven 15th February 2004 02:08 PM

I wasnt talking bout songs, Chrono, but about image. Uraayu book.

Chrono 15th February 2004 02:10 PM

aha

now the lyrics make more sense i think :)

ricekid 15th February 2004 03:11 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Chrono
aha

now the lyrics make more sense i think :)

yea, the virgin mary and love didn't quite connect...

I highly doubt ayu is anything other than christian. she always wears crosses, she did that whole thing on joan of arc (though joan of arc can be seen as a feminist figure rather than a christian one) and, of course, M.

if she does do buddhist thing (none of which I'm aware of) it's simply cultural.

jerms 15th February 2004 06:15 PM

shiso's right, but it wouldnt be that odd if it was the ohter mary

Shiso 15th February 2004 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by ricekid
I highly doubt ayu is anything other than christian. she always wears crosses, she did that whole thing on joan of arc (though joan of arc can be seen as a feminist figure rather than a christian one) and, of course, M.

The cross thing isn't necessary a sign she's christian! Crosses are really popular in Japan even though some Japanese don't know what they represent... the topic "is Ayu a Christian?" is an often topic here... there aren't any proofs that she's a Christian or not... and about the crosses - I wear a cross too... on a lace, but I'm an atheist... :)

Chrono 15th February 2004 06:29 PM

but the music video made it very confusing.. with the church and stuff..

the option 'different mary' didn't even pop up here :)

ImpactBreaker 15th February 2004 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Chrono
but the music video made it very confusing.. with the church and stuff..

the option 'different mary' didn't even pop up here :)

I still think Ayu is representing Virgin Mary and not Mary Magdaline.

Reasons:

-Virgin Mary is much more well known worldwide, even for people from different religions. While Mary Magdaline, some christians don't even know about her so how would ayumi talk know about her like that? :shrug

-In the PV Ayu is in a wedding dress...ok so what does it matter? well the dress is WHITE! A girl who marries in white represents that she is VIRGIN. Thus Ayu is representing Virgin Mary (Nalso notice that she isn't marrying of course because she has no pair. The wedding dress was just a way to show Ayu is representing a virgin). And Magdaline was anything but virgin lol

-Ayu is praying in the PV. Most obviously to Virgin Mary and not for Mary Magdaline :shrug I've never seem someone praying for Mary Magdaline.

hanabiwings 15th February 2004 06:38 PM

Hmm... I dunno. It makes sense that it was a story about Mary Magdaline that got her thinking along these lines, but it's not possible that she was praying to such a person. She's praying to the Virgin Mary in the song, known in Japanese Catholicism as "Maria" just as in Spanish and Portugese culture.

In my experience, the Virgin Mary is seen in Japan by non-Catholics and perhaps some Catholics as a deity of mercy. Popular culture associates her with love, though this is likely not the intention of any Japanese Catholic. I remember reading an article about Ayu's thoughts on the song and said something like she had regarded Mary as some holy person but then understood that she was a person as well.

Okui Masami sang a song called Maria some years ago on her album Her-Day and it mentioned "cross" and "love" as concepts along with a song-prayer to the Virgin Mary. Ayu's seems very much in line with this song as well. I think that she is seen as a deity of mercy by people in love. I could be wrong, but in my experience, this is the feeling I get.

The translators at Centigrade-J (http://centigrade.blandplanet.com/) said this on the song in their translation notes:

MARIA is the Christian Religion Holy Mother of Christ. The whole song is a prayer to MARIA to help Ayu find everlasting love in a world where that doesn't seem possible.

Shiso 15th February 2004 06:38 PM

But please notice that THE LYRICS aren't THE PV!

Ayu's PVs very often don't match with the lyrics, so while the lyrics is about Mary Magdaleine, the PV is about Virgin Mary ;)

Chrono 15th February 2004 06:50 PM

hahaha...

i don't think it's a prayer to maria... it just doesn't feel like one

ImpactBreaker 15th February 2004 06:55 PM

ahha and how can you tell the difference? O_o;

Chrono 15th February 2004 07:10 PM

i can't.. plain feeling and intuition

Ayufan11 13th April 2004 08:58 PM

M was for MARIA? o.o whos maria?

voltron 13th April 2004 09:05 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Ayufan11
M was for MARIA? o.o whos maria?
The virgin mary. The song is kinda like a prayer...she's singing to Maria. Maria is the first thing said in the song.

Unimatrix Prime™ 13th April 2004 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by voltron
The virgin mary. The song is kinda like a prayer...she's singing to Maria. Maria is the first thing said in the song.
Hmm..I remember hearing from someone a while ago that the song was actually for someone Ayu knew named Maria.. forgot where I heard that from :think

Larisa-chan 13th April 2004 10:54 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Unimatrix Prime™
Hmm..I remember hearing from someone a while ago that the song was actually for someone Ayu knew named Maria.. forgot where I heard that from :think
...er are you sure about that? I mean the PV takes place in a church, the musical rendition from the A ~Museum~ has like organ, bells, and choir sounds going on too (which sound VERY similar to the beginning of the song "Ave Maria").. and the lyrics have a line like "I'm praying now that this is my final love". I dunno, but it sounds like she's talking about the Virgin Mary to me ^.^****

AfanforXX 14th April 2004 12:45 AM

Yea, the song M is about one of the Marys of the Bible, not some book. She said it herself in an interview

fantaisie.sign 14th April 2004 01:18 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Larisa-chan
I dunno, but it sounds like she's talking about the Virgin Mary to me ^.^****
Mary Magdalene is what fans normally say, even though her costume in the PV relates more to the Virgin Mary in my opinion. Plus my friend who is a devout Catholic says that the lyrics and PV content are directed to the Virgin Mary, not Mary Magdalene. I agree.

. . . isn't this a bit off-topic?

Unimatrix Prime™ 14th April 2004 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Chibinina4
Mary Magdalene, even though her costume in the PV relates more to the Virgin Mary in my opinion.
That's the name I heard! I used to think it only related to the Virgin Mary, because of the church, the cross, the outfit, etc. , but then I thought that Ayu's probably not Catholic, so that kinda threw me off for a while ^^

Chireresu 14th April 2004 01:29 AM

Mary Magdelene, isn't she the women who Jesus saved that commited adultery?They were going to stone her if memory serves me right.And, I don't remember where, but I read that M does refer to the Virgin Mary and Ayu wrote the song because a friend told her the story of Mary and Jesus.

fantaisie.sign 14th April 2004 01:36 AM

Quote:

That's the name I heard! I used to think it only related to the Virgin Mary, because of the church, the cross, the outfit, etc. , but then I thought that Ayu's probably not Catholic, so that kinda threw me off for a while ^^
But the lyrics still have nothing to do with Mary Magdalene, and this is coming from someone who knows "The Book" fairly well. I won't explain why it's not Mary Magdalene because it strays too far away from the topic of this thread.

If the picture posted at the beginning of the thread really is legit, then I'll continue to believe along with a few others that "G" stands for "Game" and possibly another song whether it's one that begins with a "G" or a remix of "Game." That's what speculations are for. ^_^

jerms 14th April 2004 04:23 AM

http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showth...ht=virgin+mary

Unimatrix Prime™ 14th April 2004 04:34 AM

Ahh..I see now... sorry for going off-topic :(

Guess my mind has been thinking of a lot of things lately (moving, etc), so I'm surprised I didn't remember this from before :laugh

Ok..back to the topic at hand.. :)

miruku 16th April 2004 09:00 AM

well..... whatever M stands for~ i'm sure ayu has her reasons..

A little thing off topic,
I read in an article a few days that now the McDonalds Logo, the BIg golden M arch logo is more famous than the Chrisitian cross :P

kournikova 16th April 2004 12:37 PM

wohohohoho ^^ i think even its bout mary magdalaine... but its a prayer song... but its depend of everyone perception :) my perception could be different to others :) :D

waffle_chic 17th April 2004 11:38 AM

i read somewhere that ayu wrote "M" after her friend told her the story about the virgin Mary. They were talking on phone, as i remember. Ayu inspired by the story and she wrote the song. it's what i know :shrug

Rebirthia 29th October 2004 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ImpactBreaker
I still think Ayu is representing Virgin Mary and not Mary Magdaline.

Reasons:

-Virgin Mary is much more well known worldwide, even for people from different religions. While Mary Magdaline, some christians don't even know about her so how would ayumi talk know about her like that? :shrug

-In the PV Ayu is in a wedding dress...ok so what does it matter? well the dress is WHITE! A girl who marries in white represents that she is VIRGIN. Thus Ayu is representing Virgin Mary (Nalso notice that she isn't marrying of course because she has no pair. The wedding dress was just a way to show Ayu is representing a virgin). And Magdaline was anything but virgin lol

-Ayu is praying in the PV. Most obviously to Virgin Mary and not for Mary Magdaline :shrug I've never seem someone praying for Mary Magdaline.

totally agree with you,

she's acting like virgin mary in the PV, not as the other Mary


I think that the verb flirting is very adequate to what she's doing with religious culture

I suppose she has only one religion, that of avex! LOL

Rebirthia 29th October 2004 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shiso
But please notice that THE LYRICS aren't THE PV!

Ayu's PVs very often don't match with the lyrics, so while the lyrics is about Mary Magdaleine, the PV is about Virgin Mary ;)


perhaps! she has wanteed to make amix, but I don't think that she knows about that stories.... i think she is very busy "mending" her past.... the name of Maria is just a kind of cliche, she has not made a thesis about christiany, I suppose...

extepan 29th October 2004 03:54 PM

i have always wanted to ask this, and now i have the answer..in fact i have two answers...and i have to make up my mind which one to believe :)

evolution 29th October 2004 05:16 PM

Maria definitely refers to mary magladene... she said it in one of the interview.. if u actualli read the da vinci code, some parts of the book talks abt in the drawing of the last supper, jesus and mary magladene together forms a letter "M" in the drawing, and thus the name of the song "M" ..it;s an interesting book btw
there is this myth that mary and jesus were actualli lovers... and such... that;s the idea of the whole thingy..
i;m pretty sure Maria refers to mary magdalene

SunshineSlayer 30th October 2004 01:09 AM

I also think it is refering to Mary Magdalene. Yes, there is the bible rendition that says Magdalene was a prostitute but, there are many people that believe she and jesus were married. Thus the PV and the lyrics do then fit with Mary Magdalene more than the virgin Mary imho.

Also to answer someones question about whether people worship Magdalene in churches and what not. The answer is yes, there are several churches in Europe, especially in France that are devoted to and named after Mary Magdalene.

Piccolo 30th October 2004 01:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by evolution
Maria definitely refers to mary magladene... she said it in one of the interview..

What Interview? I'd like to see that please.

When I heard the song, watched the PV and read the lyrics I thought Maria was the Virgin Mary.

starr5245 30th October 2004 06:26 AM

do you know that some of Ayu's songs have the same title as hitomi's songs?

E.g.: poker face, I am.

extepan 30th October 2004 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by opal tanya cho
do you know that some of Ayu's songs have the same title as hitomi's songs?

E.g.: poker face, I am.

that is not a surprise. there are so many songs called 'love' or 'goodbye' and similar things :)

kenkamken 1st November 2004 06:31 AM

um... O.o I got lost with accouple paragraphs..and now im double LOST....Um...(*Confuesed & Scared *) Um...What should i DO?!!?!!?!?! (*-*) so she IS or ISNT referring to a religion mary, or just a chick name'd mary? .. lol... or wait, mabe shes in the church becazuse she wanted to be, and so happends she liked a dress that look'd like a wedding dress, and thought it'd be cool, and probley she has a home gal thats name'd "maria", Hey it COULD happen...lol.. and pluss i wear a cross, and i aint catholic..Heh. I didnt even know that wearing a whyt dress means ur virgen..i just thought that it fitt'ed the senerio...lol
I feel so much smarter :D................NAh...Still dumb..lol

CREATE 2nd November 2004 04:54 AM

well, i dunno much about Mary Magdalene, Virgin Mary nor MARIA because i'm not a christian myself, but i can tell from the lyrics that ayu is praying to MARIA [i dunno which one] about her love or sort of...

FYI
M is my all-time favorite ayu song, it's her first song that i heard, i've been listening to her since then

Rebirthia 3rd November 2004 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Piccolo
What Interview? I'd like to see that please.

When I heard the song, watched the PV and read the lyrics I thought Maria was the Virgin Mary.

yes, which interview?

kenkamken 8th November 2004 07:16 AM

what does "FYI" mean? and btw???

ElegantAyu 8th November 2004 09:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ImpactBreaker
I still think Ayu is representing Virgin Mary and not Mary Magdaline.

Reasons:

-Virgin Mary is much more well known worldwide, even for people from different religions. While Mary Magdaline, some christians don't even know about her so how would ayumi talk know about her like that? :shrug

-In the PV Ayu is in a wedding dress...ok so what does it matter? well the dress is WHITE! A girl who marries in white represents that she is VIRGIN. Thus Ayu is representing Virgin Mary (Nalso notice that she isn't marrying of course because she has no pair. The wedding dress was just a way to show Ayu is representing a virgin). And Magdaline was anything but virgin lol

-Ayu is praying in the PV. Most obviously to Virgin Mary and not for Mary Magdaline :shrug I've never seem someone praying for Mary Magdaline.

Mary Magdaline is actually very well known and is considered a savior in some smaller classes of catholicism and Christianity. Some people believe that she will become a prophet before christ returns. After all, she was one of the key people to find Christ's grave empty. And the angel called out to her directly.

There are anime series with Mary Magdaline in it with little mention of Mary wife of Joseph. Take Chrno Crusage: Rosette, the main female character, is the reincarnation of Mary.

But we can't know for sure what Ayu means unless she flat out tells us. I think it's up in the air for everyone.

ricekid 8th November 2004 11:16 PM

If you think about the lyrics, she's saying there is someone she SHOULD have loved. Obviously, the Virgin Mary (I'm no theologian, btw) has never had any issue of love or anything. However, if Mary MAGDALENE was indeed in love with Jesus and we go by the catholic teachings, she never got the chance to truly love him.

I"m not christian/catholic btw...

Echiko 9th November 2004 05:40 AM

I didn't know that M had so much deeper meaning to it..=D

Kazuko 9th November 2004 05:44 AM

haha i was going to say because it was the name of my mother XDDD but i guess i was wrong :rolleyes

Catzi 10th November 2004 12:04 AM

I read somewhere that was about Mary Magdaline, but I don't remember where....

chibi_sunny 16th November 2005 12:25 AM

Quote:

why "Maria"?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For a brief moment I was going to say that I've heard the name "Maria" in a lot of J-pop songs, but now only two come to mind (Ayu & hitomi). Anyways, is there some religious aspect to these songs? I've read translations for both of them and "M" sounds like it has a bit more spiritual influence in comparison to hitomi's "Maria", does Ayu refer to the Virgin Mary in "M"? Cause, in a way, it sounds like she's praying...
Close, but i heard that Ayu wrote this song when she first heard Mary Magdelene's story (she was not Jesus's mother. This Mary was the prostitute). Ayu was greatly inspired by this story, especially about love and heartbreak, and that's why she wrote "M".
i also dont think that Mary Magdelene and Jesus were in love...O_o...that just sounds wrong. And the Da Vinci Code was never meant to be taken seriously...Moreover, wasn't the person sitting next to Jesus in the Last Supper the disciple John? (though it wasn't directly said in the Bible). Yeah, i just happen to remember certain parts of the Bible.
Anyway, a change of subject:
Did you also know that "M" was gonna be named "Bliss"? But it was changed for the purpose of the song's meaning.

Hazard 16th November 2005 01:37 AM

Ah, in regard to Ayu's religion. Just becuase she wears a cross, doesn't mean she's Christian. The cross is mostly just a fashion statement. After all, American's wear the Egyptian ahnk and the Tao yin yang, but have little knowledge of the religions they're connected with.

As far as the meaning of 'M'. Well, the letter obviously stands for 'maria' a common Japanese spelling of the name Mary. I, too, believe that Ayu is referring to Mary Magdalene, and not the Virgin Mary. My reasons are basically the same as those already stated.

Dreamland 16th November 2005 02:01 AM

nv

ImpactBreaker 16th November 2005 02:05 AM

Funny because I've never seem catholics going to churchs and praying for Mary Magdelene. I've seem them praying for Virgin Mary. Is ayu praying for Maria Magdalene in the start of the PV? I doubt it.
The song is obviously a Prayer, a prayer she's making wondering about how life can have it's up and downs, how relationships can begin slowly but they can end fast, how some people are facing happiness and other sadness at the same time, and in order to bear such insecurities people usually resort to praying, so she's doing that now, praying for Maria (she's not talking about Maria, she's praying for Maria). I don't really think she would be praying for Mary Magdalene :think

chocochii 16th November 2005 04:07 AM

It's nice to make an understanding to the concept of religion and the concept of listeners and fans. When artists make a reference to a religious figure (japanese figuratively choose maria, based on roman catholic traditions that are closely linked and related to Shinto, which ayumi happens to be a member of) they always try to make a spiritual connection in their music.

Maria, happening to be the "Virgin Mary" is a glorious and misunderstood figure that looks like an angel even in human form, but yet is battered down and slain because of her deathly beauty.

Another take on this is Mary Magdeline the supposed mother of Jesus Christ. A good concept on this that ayumi could have been doing is to promote a cultural shock in her music, a balad song is good mix with spirituality and however the momentum used, Maria is a figurehead that is easily rejoiced in music over... however never in anything rockish as seen in "greatful days" or "ourselves."

It's good to think of this as a call.. or a prayer.
When someone can connect to ANY spiritual energy, then they too can understand the passion that can be felt by song or by writing. Hamasaki-san has a wonderful ability to use these objects and ideals in her music to promote a figure that makes you fall to your knees to shout "MARIA!"

It helps to think of this open-mindedly... Don't fall into the religion traps thinking that Hamasaki-san is Catholic or anything of the suit, that only brings up rumors and unfortunately can disbain the name of our glorious white princess.

It's a nice song to listen too when you're down, when you need a chill pill... and I've even heard it saved a live from suicide.

If a song can touch even one person, Hamasaki-san should be proud.

ph33r 16th November 2005 04:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chocochii
Another take on this is Mary Magdeline the supposed mother of Jesus Christ.

Mary Magdalene is not Jesus' mother.

And ImpactBreaker is correct, Catholics nor Christians pray for Mary Magdelene. Catholics pray for Virgin Mary.

Yarumi 16th November 2005 04:57 PM

too lazt to read all these pages... but I don't see her singing to Mary Magdelene. Like alot of people have said... Catholics pray to Virgni Mary... plus I've heard if you are christian in Japan then you are Catholic... so Ayu could be Catholic... but at least it's more known than Baptist or Methodist, so she could have been educated or researched it in some way since Catholism is easier to come by than some other branches of christianity

chococii- Mary Magdalene is definately not Jesus's mother... now some do speculate that he married Magdaelene and had a child possibly (Davinci code and others) but none of that is proven... and VERY sacreligious to christians... but she is never been said to be his mother :)

kendelle 16th November 2005 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hazard
Ah, in regard to Ayu's religion. Just becuase she wears a cross, doesn't mean she's Christian. The cross is mostly just a fashion statement. After all, American's wear the Egyptian ahnk and the Tao yin yang, but have little knowledge of the religions they're connected with.

As far as the meaning of 'M'. Well, the letter obviously stands for 'maria' a common Japanese spelling of the name Mary. I, too, believe that Ayu is referring to Mary Magdalene, and not the Virgin Mary. My reasons are basically the same as those already stated.

Exactly what I was going to say! :yes Just because it has religous meaning in the west doesn't mean that Ayu is wearing it for religous purpose.

There could be a reference or allusion towards the story, but since Japanese-English translations are so liberal, and can be interpreted so many ways, it's almost impossible to make an absolute guess. This conversation is sort of like a Japanese person trying to find the hidden meaning behind an American band wearing an Ankh necklace, or a shirt with Buddah on it. We'll never know the truth unless we sit Ayu down and ask her personally.

devilayu 17th November 2005 12:44 AM

You all realize that this thread is over a year old, right?

Anyways, in an old article, Ayumi says the song apparently came about because her producer was like, "Let's write a Christmas song" and they thought about it for a while (even sent out pleas to others to write the music, but in the end Ayumi/CREA was credited for it) So, I think any claims that Ayumi is Catholic or Christian just because of this song are most probably wrong.

ImpactBreaker 17th November 2005 12:53 AM

Yeah, the fact she wrote the lyrics M doesn't mean she's christian or catholic. It's kinda like actors acting as a lawyer for example, they aren't one, but they study a bit of how a lawyer works and such in order to do a good acting. The same goes to novel writers, they can talk about things they don't really live in real life, just by reading and researching about it. (of course in the case of producing M, there wasn't really much to study about since the references picked were rather simple and ayu used a lot more of her personal thoughts than religious references).

orenji_jaro 19th November 2005 07:45 AM

ayu is catholic! ^___^
100%! ^^
and why maria? it's because it was shot in the church, she's in a white wedding dress. she has a cross necklace.. there were pigeons! ^^
so it resembles to virgin mary! ^^
and as the song says.. she's like talking to virgin mary and wishing that the guy she loves will meet her in that snowy day! ^^ but he didnt appeared and still ayu keep on waiting and keep on praying to maria. ^__^

devilayu 19th November 2005 07:44 PM

^ Ok, seriously, that doesn't mean anything. It's just imagery for the PV. The first cross necklace Ayumi got was from her stylist and meant as a fashion accessory.

In all the articles I've read with "M" references, Ayumi never mentions anything significant about religious stuff and she never said that the PV was her idea (in fact, she's more likely to mention that her band was in the PV and that's what's so different about it)

Delirium-Zer0 20th November 2005 08:20 AM

Okay, I have to step in here. This is for everyone knocking the Mary Magdalene theory on the basis that The Da Vinci Code is inaccurate.

Yes, the book is inaccurate on alot of counts. Like that's not Mary in The Last Supper, it's Saint Peter, who was almost always described as VERY effeminate looking.

But the theory is not at all based on anything in that book. I think i was one of the first people to introduce the theory a few years ago (WAY before I ever read the Da Vinci Code, btw), and it ended up being backed up later by an interview somewhere that I haven't read but I've heard about.

I'll tell you why I came up with it here though. Mary of Magdala was Jesus' best friend, and most likely in love with him. I'm not sure it was requited, but she really cared for him. He trusted her VERY deeply, and to the other disciples it often seemed as though he gave her more attention than he gave the rest of them. In the Gospel of Mary of Magdala (yes it exists, I recommend the interpretation by Karen L. King if any of you want to read it), it is written that Jesus came in the night, giving Mary insight into the nature of goodness and sin that he did not give the other disciples (what he said is VERY controversial to Christianity as it is widely taught now). When Mary told this to the other disciples (who asked for any wisdom the Christ may have given Mary, as he loved her more than he loved them), they cast her away. Jesus' intention may have been to pass his teachings down to her, for her to pass down and carry the word. The other disciples, however, took the story for their own and taught it how THEY wanted it taught. The first bible as we know it wasn't written for several hundred years so the details may never be known. But it does seem like Christianity, as taught by Jesus Christ, was intended for Mary to pass down. They call Mary's life "rife with sin", but they also talk about how she was the first to see that Jesus had risen, and the angel spoke to HER directly, telling HER to spread the word.

Mary had to endure so much heartbreak; the true lessons of the man she loved were lost to the pride of jealous friends. Her reputation was tarnished for nearly two thousand years following, the man she cared for most was lost to her forever, and her friends all betrayed her. The resulting heartbreak could translate easily into lyrics like those in "M". Only recently has this story really been accepted by any measurable amount of people so it's worth writing about. Given the controversial nature of the subject, Ayu may have left the "Mary" reference ambiguous. But she is a very feminist person and Mary Magdalene, not the Virgin Mary, is the one who feminists most admire and, I'm sure, pray for. Mary Magdalene was not a prostitute, but a woman considered equal with the other disciples by Christ. Her memory, though, has become so dirtied that it's worth praying for, and it's worth praying for her to be reunited with her love in heaven.

ImpactBreaker 20th November 2005 10:33 AM

^Mary Magdalene is way too specific for ayu to know about. A lot of people hardly know who she is. As far as I know catholicism is the religion that pray for saints, I don't think other christian religions pray for saints (might be wrong though). Most of these people pray for Virgin Mary, I'm actually yet to see someone praying for Mary Magdalene, because I've never seem that (I live in the country with the largest ammount of chatolic population in the world). And honestly, if there ate people who pray for Mary Magdalene, they must be a very restricted group compared to the ones who pray for Virgin Mary. Delirium that story you told is long and complex, do you really think ayu knows all that? We are not even sure about what her religion is, much less that she will know about controversial stories of christian religion. I honestly don't think so. I think it was much simpler, she just picked a very well known religious icon and put it in the song to make it sound like a prayer, and it is undeniable that there are far more people who knows who Virgin Mary was than Mary Magdalene, specially those who hardly knows anything about christian religion.

Plus, a lot of japasnese artists have songs for Virgin Mary (i.e LUNA SEA)

JackieRos 30th December 2005 05:34 AM

also dragon ash made a song named M

ShadowMehMeh 30th December 2005 10:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chrono
it's weird, isn't it. i doubt the people are christian.. somehwo they just like maria :P

I heard that religious Japanese are either Christian or Buddhist.

There's a lot of religious ideology in the song "M" from what you guys have said. The song seems to have been inspired by the story of Mary Magdalene but the PV takes place in a church with Ayumi playing as the Virgin Mary. Maybe the PV portrays both, because there's Ayumi dressed in black right from the beginning, and only in the black outfit is she vocalizing (maybe role-playing as Mary Magdalene) while in contrast she's a silent figure when dressed in the white gown (Virgin Mary).

*shrugs* Just a thought.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.