Who...10th Anniversary Full Version
 

http://www.wretch.cc/mypage/ayu200403
credits to: http://www.taiwan-ayufansclubs.ddns.info/tw

click play on the little player in the right corner
this is the full version..i'm totally loving it!!!!
the song is totally making me cry...10 years of ayu...

Rip of the audio, thanks for Luna62
http://www.mediafire.com/?d6ajvvnzhhx
so this is a little bit HQ than the link Foyuki had provided

OMG!AHHHHH!

thanks

Wonderful! It sounds GREAT.

What!

the guy says.. "foo" right? jaja sounds cute.

Thanks!

OH MY GOD THANKS SO MUCH!!! *runs to listen*

I didn't know it was already out. :) Thanks.

oh my..THANKS ALOT.

OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH!
just the beginning and I'm already starting to cry

thanks! i havent heard it!

omg thanks a lot

Thanks ^^!~

Its kinda cool but I dont feel emotional lol.

Did they use the same instrumental?~
I think so~ so just different voice.
I really love it~ then~ T T~

thanks!!!!!!

i LOVE it :DDDDDDDDDD

is the arrangement of the lyrics different this time around? it sounds different...

i havn't listen to it, is the only value for me for the 3CD but for what i've read the instrumental is the same and,, for me is the best they could do.

Who is a classic song, is good as it was and it would be the worst thing in the world if the had changed it... who... is who... no other way so i'm happy ^^


bye!

OMG! So awesome

Wohaaa I LOVE the Song! ♥♥
Do you think Ayu has re-recorded it? Or did they take the voice of the normal WHO version?

Its awesome!!

I agree entirely. I do think alot of her songs need updates, but Who... is not one of them. I was actually kinda disappointed when I heard Who... was getting a 10th anniversary version, cuz I was like, "how are they gonna change it? It's perfect as it is!"

Her voice is, in fact, the only thing different (cept that part during the instrumental break sounds more like it did on the instrumental version we have than it did on LOVEppears, if anyone here knows what I mean).

THANK YOU AYU for not RUINING this song like you did on A BALLADS <3 :)

Who... had always been one of my fave ballads ^^;

omg~ is so good!~ its like the version taht they play at the end of the asia tour.. like a more updated version of who...!!!! ><

I'm gonna wait for it to come before hearing it~ But thanks for reporting the news =D!

U r right, I felt so emotional. I love this song very much. And the guy use dome tour 2001 for background. I was so happy, I miss that concert very much

sounds great! :love

but since when did ayu have a song name "fu"?....lol

Wow that's so amazing!!!
I feel so much while listening to it!!!

And I don't get how people don't here soem differences in the arrangement.
The beats are stronger than the original track, it's more like a live instrumental XD

hmm
it soudns the same to me -_- .. quite disappointed

it kinda sounds like the one from AT 2007! the intro is beautiful!! I love it, thanks for sharing

For me.. the backgroundmusic also sounds a little bit different.
I like it. But... I think, I prefer the original Version.
And by the way... I also like the version on A Ballads. (^_^)'''

boooring... shouldn't be named 10th anniversary version....

I like the idea of having the same instrumental track.
I have to say it's really beautiful. Ayu's vocal's changed a lot again since A BEST it's more redeemed and soft but also more powerful

thx .... *going to download section* >>>>

absolutely beautiful.......

It's really nice. I'm glad they didn't mess around with the music (I hear only very slight differences) and her voice sounds good~

they remastered i think the instruments..
but it's pretty much the same, I think.
Love it~~~

thanks!!! :)

she definitly re-recorded it.
the vocals aren't the same at all

like some of you I'm glad they didn,t change the music. the arrangements
we can see some differences but not BIG ones which is great because

Who... stays Who... you can't change this song.
and I love ayu's vocals in it!

GAH ayu needs to stop releasing another version of her songs =x ~!!! lol I dunno I just feel u can only create so many versions of the same song until its just too much XD ~!

Woah! Thanks for sharing!

It's definetely re-recorded. I love this version more.

O____O O M G

Her voice is so beautiful, more then You and DoY 10th versions. I love this version of Who...

uhm, its her 10th anniversary..

Thank you

yeah finally full version!!! thanks!

wow...love ayu vocal
i think they just retake the vocal but not change the arrangement

thanks :)

Did that guy just tell me to "Fu?"

Hahaha just kidding. What an AWESOME song. :)

she sounds happier than the original one--or maybe thats my imagination...haha but i love this song--both the original and 10th anni one :D

OMG gonna dl!

nice..love it:D

thank you

The original version will always hold a place in my heart, but I definitely like this one better than the one on A Ballads.

Ehh..its nothing special.
*runs*

i like it...but i kind of wish they had played around with the instruments just a little bit more.

still, i'm happy with it. :yes

thanks for sharing it.

thanks!
but i prefer the original one

The definitely enhanced the background im sure...
and her vocals are nice..(retained the young AYu flavour)

i also felt a lot while hearing...its like...10 years...goshhh
finally a improved version of the Original Who...

(i dunno what those disappointed people were expecting...it's a classic song...)

As ayumisrael stated before, the beats are indeed stronger in this track than the original. Nonetheless, it's still a beautiful version. One of my favorite songs now. :)

I do wish that she made the vocals as strong as her lives. But other than that, it's a SUPER nice version.

I heard FU too lol.

I love prefer this version to the original one..but this version has ALOT more vibrato though :(

it's sounds pretty much the same.

but the vocals are so much better than her first version (not trying to say her first ver sucks though).

i think the second link is the to the original Who... . it's definitely not the 10th anniversary version.

this version is much better the old version!!!

yep, same here, I really liked it!

Thanks really alot!!!! her vocals are really good in this version! :luv2:luv2

This version is OK. It's basically the same as the "LOVEppears" one. I prefer the original "Who..." though.
I guess I prefer seeing a completely new side/image of a song (like "A Song for XX" on "A BALLADS") or leaving it the way it is (meaning: no re-recording)...

And yes, I think they say "Fu". Fu=Who.

PS. I forgot. Thanks for sharing. ^^

AYU BEST SONG
:cry

thanks for the link, Pommy

oh yeah! it's out!!
Thanks for the link!

The bg music sounds a lil different. Ayu does sound different. Quite touching =)

sounds good
i love who...
such a song!
*-*-*

thanks a lot!

thanks ^-^

OH WOW!@#!!@!! Thank you soooo much!!!!

o.0 why this one so diff from others one.. i mean is so TOUCHING !!!

WOW its out?! Thx sooooo much for posting!!!! I love it! Its very much alike the old version. And I thought it was going to be this part when the instruments is quiet and only she is singen. Well, well. I love it anyway! ^^
:heart

can't wait for the album to come out (Y)

Thankies~

I'm a purist so i almost always like the original best through no fault of the new one lol! My only grouse is that some notes at the end of a phrase should have been held longer but otherwise it's nice enough. Thanks for the link!

^haha yea! i felt the same way...but probably she is trying to have the same feel as before?

thanks, gotta listen to ;)

Aw, I thought that too!! D: It sounded SO pretty in the CM, so I was hoping we'd get that acapella part in the final song too xD Oh well~ It's still so beautiful, though! <3 I can't wait for the HQ version ^_^

Thanks so much for the link! I love this song. That would have been really cool if it did have the acapella

I love "Who.." but her vibrato in this version is a liiiiittle too much for me to handle in some places. it's like she's trying too hard. *runs away before the angry mob forms* :P
But actually, it's mainly in the beginning...after she gets going her voice is more normal and beautiful.

same here. too much vibrato, not only in the beginning for me.
actually i was expecting a version where she says "minna" instead of only "anata" once. like in the concert. that would have been 10th anniversary style in my opinion ^^

thank you :)

This sounds so amazing!
Thanks for the link and putting it up ^_^

owwwwwwwwww soooo cute! Makes me wanna run and hug ayu!

I love this new version! A great one.. But nothing beats the original! <3~

I like it alot! thank you!

Awesome,thank you.

Awesome 10x :P

I LOVE IIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!!
It gives me teary eyes... ;____;

will avex release a capella version for download? I really like it in the cm...

wow, thanks, it's about time anyway ^^

I'm in love with Who AGAIN!... That is if I'm ever out of love with it...

Thanks so much, haven't had the time to listen to it. Will do now. :yes

unlikely. it's not a digital single, only a bonus track for A COMPLETE.


but I really like this version and I'm not a fan of the other two.

It's not as 'epic' as I was hoping for... her vocals seem strained during parts and a little sharp.

Who... is one of my favorite songs ...

Yeaaaaaaaaaah, I really hope this isn't how she's going to deliver all her ballads from now on. :< Something about her vocals just bothers me now.

^ must agree. i was listening to it and was like... gawsh, she's just... not that great at singing anymore. she doesn't sound as steady anymore. she sounds restrained... and overdoes that a~a~a~
i can't help but think that she sounds like an old lady *scratches head*

and thanks to poster of the link.

^ Ouch! Is it really that bad? =/

This is yesterday's HK newspaper

It said that Ayu has recorded a mandarin version of "Who..." and contained in the Asia version of A COMPLETE. It also said Ayu may performed it in Hong Kong's concert...

If it is real, we will have a full mandarin version of Who... that performed in AT07...?

I like the version in A BALLADS more >_<