Q about Forgiveness PV - Complete Clip Box
 

I've just ordered the CCB, and have a question about the version of the Forgiveness PV that's on it. Is it the original PV aired on TV last year, or is it the edited version that's on the Memorial address DVD? Just curious...

i think its the edited version from memorial address.. i havent got my ccb yet... sorry i cant answer... ^^ but its 60% possibility from memorial address

it is the memorial address version.

Just wondering, what's the difference between the two??

So it is the MA version? Doesn't matter - I still have the original version that aired on TV that I downloaded. Just wanted to know.


gakkun, the difference in the two versions of Forgiveness is in the version from TV, where the 'egg' thing forms around Ayu [where she's got a sheet over her] - in the MA DVD, it doesn't close around her, it just cuts to the 'egg' falling down to the Ayu surrounded by rose petals.

does anyone knows for sure why they did this? my guess is the first transition from ayu on the sheets to the egg was not smooth something like being harsh? is that the word? you know with all the edges on the leaves plus it has nothing to do with the nature of the clip....

Can any of you post Screencaps of the difference? i have difficulties to imagine...

Oh i get what u mean. But when did they cut away the part where the 'egg' surrounded ayu? Dont understand leh... If possible can someone put up a dl for the TV ver?

Yes, the part where the 'egg' forms around Ayu was cut out. I can't upload the TV version, but I can do some screencaps from that and the DVD version tomorrow.

I would like to see the caps.