YUI -V.S- Erika Sawajiri as Kaoru Amane from "Taiyou no Uta"
 

Both YUI and Erika Sawajiri (1 Litre of Tears) play Kaoru Amane in "Taiyou no Uta". YUI in the movie. Erika in the drama. Which song is better?

http://img181.imageshack.us/img181/554/r0187007hr9.jpg

"Good-bye days" - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhNdE0hZEUw

V.S.

http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/1819/cxhb3.jpg

"Taiyou no Uta" - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_pyZl-HDRng

---------------------

I vote for Erika! She's just simply amazing. I think her song is better than YUI's in many ways. (Her voice too. I like YUI's voice, but sometimes, it's just annoying... I don't know why...) The melody is so beautiful. I heard she wrote the song. I hope Erika will continue to sing because she's not only a great actress... she really can sing! :yes

YUI for me. taiyou no uta wasn't as good as Good-bye days to me.

YUI all the way! Erika Sawajiri can't sing =P

01： タイヨウのうた
作詞：白鳥マイカ / 作曲：白鳥マイカ

02： Stay with me
作詞：永井真理子 / 作曲：COZZi

Doesn't seem like Erika wrote it.. o_o;

YUI pwns all. :heart but I also love Erika.

Thanks for poiting that out! Actually, I misread the article. XD

Sawajiri Erika....I heard both artist's work..

As much as i love Erika, YUI just blows her completely out the water. YUI is far and wide the better singer (and currently one of the best singers in jpop). Goodbye Days seems a much more heartfelt and touching song to me. Sure, i can't understand the lyrics to either song so i'm going on how they sound as whole and the feeling i get. YUI for definite.

YUI by far. "Good-bye days" is easily one of the best pieces of Japanese music that came out this year... well then again she didn't really have anything to compete against really.

Wow, the result is so close!

I liked both songs but I overall love YUI more! :yes YUI is great :D

I'll say Erika. Erika is not a good singer, but it's not like Yui is very good either, and as an actress I definitely like Erika better.

wow i havent heard erika's voice yet!
im going to look for this song!!

You've made me cry :cry

i want to hear erika voice
can someone upload her songs?

i think Yui is great in her 1st acting..But if about the songs them sings..i think yui is more better then erika..The drama os Taiyou no uta is not so good as the movie act by yui..:D :D

Hmm..Erika single can be found in jpopsuki..But the quality is not so nice..I think u can hear it as a preview..I will wait until tmr..Then the singles will out..:D :D

LOL! you said what I wanted to sayy! Though Taiyou no Uta IS a good song, her voice just sorta ruins it.

YUI's voice can be nice. But it can get a little annoying for me.

I think Erika is a wonderful singer. I really enjoy her voice. She makes me think of Maki for HIGH and MIGHTY COLOR (my favorite voice!) but sweeter and cuter. I really hope she'll release more stuff. She's doing very well in the chart right now. Beating ORANGE RANGE and TOKIO! She's currently #1! WOOOHOOO!

I haven't seen the movie and just one episode of the drama. So, I don't know which one is better. But I'm 100% sure Erika is a better actress. Doesn't get better than this girl!