Quote:
Originally Posted by M.A.X.
lol ^^ I know what I say, many friends think like me but many many fans doesn't believe us, it's ok.
|
Surely many of your friends (I may think they are french and never saw Ayumi in a real concert) believe that Ayumi uses playback a lot. I really don’t know where they found this, since many people who actually went to Ayumi concerts (fans???), said again and again that it’s not true. But let’s them think what they would like to think… it’s ok for me too (maybe not :p). Anyway it’s quite funny, Ayumi is lip-synching, but at the same time, Ayumi is always off-key, and Ayumi forgets her lyrics, and Ayumi is crying during her songs…
No offence M.A.X. but I am tired of the "playback" debate which run around all french websites and forums, will you and your friends realize that you can't judge on DVD?
Your list of “playback” is amazing and quite funny.
For example:
Quote:
Originally Posted by M.A.X.
Countdown live 2004-2005 : M, evolution, AUDIENCE, independent
|
Why not, but since I was there I can affirm that it was not in playback. And I have a proof of that, during independent, Ayumi felt dizzy a little. I saw and heard it immediately during the concert, when you know where it is you can hear it in her voice on the TV version, I don’t remember for the DVD. I may think that it is very to notice it if you don’t know where it is, but it was live.
For AUDIENCE and evolution, no way! It was obvious that it was live! There is the voice of Ayumi in playback, as always but Ayumi sung over it, as always but it’s live.
For M, I know why you think that, anyway it’s not true; you hear a difference between duty and M because Ayumi have changed her microphone between the 2 songs...
I will stop here.
Ayumi lip-synchs sometimes (it is the case for Ladies night yes), but only few times. The problem when you say lip-synching is that everybody will thing that she can’t sing, but what I can affirm after seeing her 10 times in concert, is that she can sing very very well in live even if she is dancing at the same time (well she can also sing bad… but now a day it is quite rare).
Finally, as said
yamogi on DVD the vocals are normalized, but even in TV version there is some filters… We can’t judge on DVD… So I don’t know about the concert of Hong-Kong, I’m waiting for the opinion of people who went there.