The idea for the PV was good. It just wasn't executed as well as it could have been. So good points...
- This was my first time hearing the song green all the way through. I liked the song alot.
- The Chinese feel of the PV.
- Midoring was in a suit.

- The part where Ayu and Midoring were dancing and there was the face touching.

- Ayu looked good in the red dress. (Isn't it called a qípáo?)
There's more good points but yeah...
As far as if Midoring was a guy or not....
Midoring was wearing heels.
It could be a worse PV... but you can't please everybody. Overall, I like the symbolism and such. But again, it could have been executed better.