Okay... I see everyone's points here, but I think we are still "undecided" about this genre splitting, so I'm gonna go ahead an make a new thread, with a poll, where people can vote on whether or not to do the genre splitting.
Also, having a separate thread, more people will notice the dilemma we have. Not everyone who comes to this thread is reading the whole thing. Most are just reading the first post and they agreeing/disagreeing with the idea presented!
I'll go put the poll up now and after edit the first post with the link!
POLL (& further place of discussion for the 'genre splitting'):
http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=85236