Don't beat yourself up about it - on the bright side, you can give them to friends and not worry if they get scratched!
I have a MIYA records MY STORY that I keep in the car and don't worry if it gets stolen/damaged
I'd recommend either
MY STORY, (miss)understood or
NEXT LEVEL. You can get her back catalogue pretty cheap on eBay from stores like Dora's store but I'd suggest waiting a few weeks til the hype of the new album dies down - prices go way up before new albums/singles!!
If you were in the mood for something different you could go for
LOVEppears with the second CD disc, it's full of remixes and if you put it into your computer you can view CMs, see her discography (at the time, so it's out of date now!) and hear cute clips of her voice.
I ripped the voice clips and put them up on AHS a while back:
http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=81655 but I really like the rest of the bonuses too. As you can get the album for under $10USD it's well worth it <3
Good luck with whatever you choose, let us know where you start! ^_^
EDIT: PS - All items in Dora's store are legitimate Avex presses, he buys them in bulk lots on Yahoo! Auctions japan, which is why most albums start at around $6USD - he usually gets CD-only but often gets CD+DVD, I got MY STORY from him the other day CD+DVD
EDIT2: If you're getting NEXT LEVEL, you only have about 24 hours to order it on CDJ to be in the lucky draw prize. For YesAsia I think you have til the 21st march, so get in quick! You might get a freebie~