Know what, sometimes we can't really know whether Ayu does lip-synch or not ..because when we think she is, but it turns out that she is not.. then we think she is not where in fact she is.. even it's kinda hard to recognize if you're really there at the concerts..
because, like example, in Marionette AT08, Ayu's voice definitely sounded so different from the CD version's voice and it sounded live, but sometimes, it made me think that the way of her singing with the whole acting and dancing throughout that song, how could her voice sound so stable even though it sounded live, didn't we suppose to hear a little bit of her breath?? so what i could think of the method she's been using (to make ppl think she sings live where in fact, she's not, that in some songs that are seemed difficult to sing live when she has to dance and act at the sametime) is that she will record some of the songs with the live band music arrangement first, during rehearsal, in a studio maybe, then at the day of performance, they will play the recorded version of Ayu's singing to match with the live band music (where Ayu has recorded together with the live band before),so that when she's singing, she can just pretend to sing where at the same time, she can save energy to sing the next song.. she can at least save her vocal for the next song..can you guys imagine of her to sing for like more than 30 times of performance?? sing the exact same list for 30 times?
well that's only what i could think of though whether Ayu sometimes sounds live and sometimes not..
but from my experiences attending both AT07 and AT08 before.. she sang mostly live for all the songs except for maybe 1-3 songs per AT~ which songs that i couldn't hear her breath at all~
that's all the proof that i could think of..and i really couldn't make sure which songs she used playback and which not..even i was in both concerts before.. i was getting too hyped up to forget whether she sang live or not.. all i could hear that she's live..haha..but only with Marionette AT08, i felt she used playback..other than that, she sang live...
oh yeah, it's certainly very obvious that she used playback at PCDL's angel's song..
and it's funny that i insisted my friend that Ayu obviously lipsynched on that song, but he insisted me that she didn't, he said thousand reasons to defend Ayu.. then i told him.. relax, it's really not a big deal if Ayu lipsynch in some songs.. she's human being, she has limits...
it's totally a blind person who said Ayu sang angel's song live at PCDL..where in fact, she sang wrong lyric, but the singing turned out different..haha that's sooo obvious..thx for the camera man who has zoomed Ayu close up so that we could make sure that Ayu really lipsynched on that song
