[noidea]

I wrote (probably), I know it can't be said for sure, but this thread was a idea for gathering all discussions in 1 thread instead of spreading them over the forum and so that people who think she might have lipsynched a song can look that up, I never insisted that the information here are 100% accurate, thats why I always write a comment about why I think it's playback, so people can think about it theirselves and then agree or disagree with me

@ SunshineSlayer

Thats what I wanted with this thread, there shouldnt be discussions about wether its good or bad in here, but about which songs are sung playback(and maybe why they were sung playback?) and which not.

@ alternarist and other people that hate every discussions about playback:
This thread makes it easier for you, too, if you dont want to be caught up in playback discussions or dont want to have to read all the playback discussions, you can just stop visiting this thread and youll see way less of them^^

@ SunshineSlayer(now about the real topic xD)
you visited A-nation 07 and ASIA TOUR 2007, right? And 1 LOVE and Until that Day seemed lipsynch in both? That means that they probably took the same playback for it, we should just check that and maybe well find out a bit, only thing i know is that CDL0607 the first computerized voice of ayu in until that Day... sounded horrible, up to parts where you didnt hear her much, so i think that performance at least was live, they would have computerized it better(like in AT07) if they had time to edit a playback

AT08: My hearing isnt good enough to sense that difference between her voice before and after, but i didnt notice anything in that way, not at all, maybe they had many performances playback in the beginning of the tour because ayu was very bad from her deafness, it became better and later it was less playback? I just cant believe shed choose such a bad my name's WOMEN playback and why would they add mic-noises? Theres many people not even knowing there are mic-noises when using a headmic and they probably dont know about all the playback discussions in the international forums, is it the same in japanese forums about playback? and i wrote somehwere else already: CDL0405 Trauma had almost no mic sounds(at least in the DVD version, im planning to download the tv version in a few days), yet it was live.(forgot lyrics)