Quote:
Originally Posted by extepan
gosh, i have always believed that ayu sings live in every tour. i was so angry that eason chan accused ayu of not singling live 30% of the time in AT07. now when i come to think about it, the boys and girls performances in various tours have "sank-yuu" and "ai ai ai ai's" in the same time. weird, or maybe it was a live playback.
|
Boys and Girls I do think that she sings live pretty much everytime. She just has a lot of set phrases that she says in that song. And yes, I remember the Eason Chan thing. He was attacked a lot for saying that even though he himself is a professional singer so I think he would know better than anyone whether it is lip synched or not.
In my early days as a fan, I too believed that she never lip synched but mainly because that's what I
wanted to believe, but as I saw her more times live and really began collecting all of her concerts and tv lives and watched them many many times did it gradually become obvious to me that she has lip synched, and a number of times more than people usually think - its just almost impossible to definitively prove unless there is an Angel's Song type mess up.
Quote:
Originally Posted by AyUmIXx
^
too bad that we don't have much fancams for ATs in Japan..
|
Yeah, I've never found an Ayu bootleg - not audio or video. Why can't more Japanese H!P fans be into Ayu? haha. HP fans bootleg just about every concert.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Evolution7/4
M at CDL 04-05 definitely sounded like playback to me.
|
There was a big discussion about that at the time. I've never listened to the performances back to back but it did sound mighty similar, if not exactly the same, to M at the Asia Song festival which occurred close to the same time.