^ So if no one can prove anything with that clip, what about the live reports then? It seems people just like to conveniently ignore those because it doesn't suit their arguement and are focusing on the clip only.
Anyways, it seems people are still continuing the lip synching thing anyways even though people HAD already dropped the subject. Maybe it should be brought to the playback thread. As for the breathing thing - yes, you should hear breath sounds - just as that report I translated said: they couldn't hear any breath sounds in Energize, but could in the next song (Audience) which both used the headset mic.
Quote:
Originally Posted by maikaru
You didn't even see the concert yourself or have no clear proof visually.
And if those messages are from two channel, then I will laugh.
|
But even if I had seen it myself, I'm sure you'd still continue denying it.
Also, I already gave the link to the report about it being lip synched and its not from 2 ch. The other comments I have gotten from various Japanese message boards about the subject.
And right now it seems the anti-lip synch people are the ones determined to continue the discussion.
So basically, what's been said that doesn't have any validity to it? All people have said is that based on the video we have, it doesn't appear live (which is all we have to go on in terms of video and audio evidence) and then I backed it up with several comments from people that have seen the show that don't think its live either. Is the idea that she lip synched the song really that threatening that you would deny anything to the contrary?
Quote:
Originally Posted by waterballoon
Actually it's possible to take deep breaths without like making noises.
|
With regular mics yes, with head mics no. I have never been to a concert where you can't hear breathing sounds when the artist is actually singing into the head mic. btw, Trauma 04/05 yes, you can hear mic sounds - you can even hear her clapping into the mic and also when she takes deep breaths.