Originally Posted by M.A.X.
Ok I have all concert and tv version and I know Ayu since long time so:
All concert before the CDL 2001-2002, there are not playback
CDL 01-02
- UNITE (Chorus)
- evolution (Chorus)
Same two I suspected for the same part
Arena Tour 2002
- Free & Easy
I really doubt this one was playback, really, or she did a PERFECT job miming it, and shes not good at miming xD also, it seems she used a mic that produces almost no mic-noises, otherwise, AUDIENCE would be a pretty sure playback as well(at least in parts)
- evolution
Just rewatched evolution and I think you're right, the recording is WAY worse than museum,CDL0607,AT07, CDL0708, but the facts that there are no mic noises and no speaking to the audience make it a pretty sure playback, and her mouth looks weird
- UNITE!
possible, very possible
- independent
her voice suddenly is really different, i think you might be right
Stadium Tour 2002
havent watched it
- UNITE!
- evolution
- independent
- Boys & Girls
- AUDIENCE
CDL 2002-2003
havent watched it
- UNITE!
- evolution
A Museum
thats kind of my list as well, i just have to check every song against the tv version first(i dont think shell do two different playbacks for two different days of the same concert^^)
- evolution
- poker face
- trust
- depend on you
- appears
- vogue
- Fly high
- UNITE
- forgiveness (same as Tv version)
- no way to say
Arena tour 2003-2004
sure about the upper two, but not about UNITE!, Moments and Who, mainly because I didnt watch them xD
-ANGEL'S SONG
-Greatful days
- UNITE!
- Moments
and maybe Who... for first time
CDL 2004-2005
- M
that one was doubted for long, you might be right
- CAROLS (same as Arena Tour 2005)
interesting
- evolution (verses)
I KNEW IT! the second verse sounds exactly like CDL0607 and so on!
- audience
Arena tour 2005
- Happy ending
only the last line, or do you really think shed record a playback for the song and use the studio recording for the last line?
- UNITE (chorus)
havent really watched it...
- GAME (same as a nation 2004 except voice effects)
ok, expected something like this
- my name's women
my point all the time^^
- carols
possible
- step you (same as all performance in concert)
ok
CDL 2005-2006
- STEP YOU
- UNITE (chorus)
- fairyland
doubt this, her mouth moved much better than in a-nation 2008 and i think she would have used the same playback for both tours, but i havent watched the tv version, so its possible
- theme of a nation
Arena tour 2006
- Step you
- Ladies Night
- alterna
- rainy day
no...please not...i hope not...
- Startin (same as a nation 2006)
I KNEW IT! I KNEW I KNEW THIS AUDIO! but i think Startin' CDL0506 might be playback as well
- UNITE!
CDL 2006-2007
- ourselves
hmm...have to watch tv version
- Fly high
sure about this? i havent watched it, but i seriously doubt it
- Beautiful figthers
- evolution
Asia tour 2007
- evolution
- UNITE!
- 1 LOVE
- until that day (same as a nation 2007)
- M
- appears
CDL 2007-2008
- talkin 2 myself
- Step you
- evolution
Asia tour 2008
just like my list
- talkin 2 myself
- Don't leave me alone (I doubt)
- Marionette
Premium CDL
kind of my list as well, but I really doubt Over was playback
A lot of songs but I doubt.
For sure:
- Angel's Song
and maybe
GREEN
Will
Real me
and then
naturally
in the corner
over
scar
signal
too late
everywhere nowhere
|