Originally Posted by noidea
^ I dont see how its speculation if, let me make an example, we can see or rather hear in CDL0607 TV VERSION(live broadcast from 31st of december 2006 to be exact) that she uses the audio from CDL0203, A Museum and some other performances, its impossible to sing a song twice in exactly the same way, and ayu sings it exactly the same for several performances, when her overall singing is great(A museum) AND when its bad(CDL0203), she even sings it exactly the same several years later!(CDL0607, AT07, CDL0708) however, in other performances and tv performances, every single performance sounded quite difference from the others, but this vocal track is always 100% the same, every note is the same strenght, hold the same lenght, on the same pitch(+ she doesnt talk to the audience in the parts where she usually shouts come on!...weird that in EVERY SINGLE PERFORMANCE using the good vocaltrack she does NOT speak to the audience, but did so in EVERY SINGLE PERFORMANCE that can be said to be live for sure(every performance where she was VERY out of breath, VERY off-pitch or forgot her lines))several people even prove that by computer audio comparement, just a few weeks ago I got a pm by somebody who did so with some of her performances to encourage me because he was scared to be *****ed out of the discussions if he posted a single post saying that yes, ayu synched other songs than the two where she made lyric mistakes, people dont seriously think she synched two songs and just in these two she does mistakes, while the camera is on her mouth, i once made statistics about her forgetting her lines and compared it to how often she forgot her lines while singing playback(only counted countdowns for both, only counted VISABLE mistakes), i got the result that, if the mistake-rate is the same when she synchs like it is when she sings live, she synched around 25-50 songs in all cdls since 02-03, of course, this is nothing to prove anything with it, but it makes sense...
@Andrenekoi
actually, I think some of her best vocal performances were live, or rather MOST of her best vocal performances, but if a song does give me a playback-impression, ill state that i think its playback, especially if...well, you CAN prove it(like in the example, theres no way the opposite can be said except by some "AYU ONLY SYNCHED TWO SONGS, AND ONLY IN THE CONCERTS THAT WERE ON TV, AND ONLY 1 WORD EACH, AND ONLY TO MAKE FUN OF HERSELF-kiddies), however, i wont insist on something being playback that does not use a "used" vocaltrack already
|