Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai - View Single Post - It's After Eden in the 2nd thead of Kalafina!
View Single Post
  #301  
Old 9th April 2013, 12:49 AM
Damita's Avatar
Damita Damita is offline
WHATEVER Initiate
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 482
Here's my rating for the tracks:

al fine (10/10)
consolation (9.5/10)
moonfesta (ムーンフェスタ) (9/10)
Door (10/10)
Mirai (未来; Future) (9/10)
Hanataba (花束; Bouquet) (10/10)
Signal (6/10)
obbligato (9/10)
Kiichigo no Shigemi ni (木苺の茂みに; Raspberry Bushes) (8.5/10)
Manten (満天; Sea's Sky) (9/10)
to the beginning (9.5/10)
Hikari Furu (ひかりふる; Falling Lights) (9.5/10)
Yume no Daichi (夢の大地; Land of Dreams) (10/10)

Comments:
- Overall, AMAZING album! I can understand why people are calling it their weakest, since their albums are SO strong to begin with.
- I don't know if I like the tracklist. I feel like it's too jerky how the moods change so easily from sad to angry to happy to nostalgic and back to happy. It should've been smoother. I'd like to see them really do a concept album, which the intro to the album, "al fine", would've been perfect for.
- Only song I don't like is signal. It's okay in parts, but in some parts it's next to unbearable!


To rank their albums now, I'd say:
1) Seventh Heaven (10)
2) Consolation (9.5/10) and Red Moon (9.5/10)
4) After Eden (9/10)