Quote:
Originally Posted by Delirium-Zer0
I guess I just don't feel like November is dynamic enough. I've truly listened to the song on a gazillion levels trying to figure out what's really grabbing people. do it again I understand, even crossroad I understand more than November, but November... November's pieces ARE very good but it lacks gestalt so I can't feel it really. I can acknowledge a bunch of what it does right, but it's like... you know when you have a joke explained to you it's not funny anymore? It's like that. I can't FEEL any excellence there. But I feel that way with a good deal of mid-tempo ballads to be honest so that may be personal bias on my part.
I also think it builds up to something it never reaches, and in some songs that's done to very good effect, but about 75% of the time it ends up just being unsatisfying, and that's the case for me with November.
|
I felt this way initially actually. You can FEEL it's heading somewhere and then it kind of gets stuck in this loop. Like
it's as if it's on the brink of reaching a climax, but it never quite truly does.
The chorus is essentially a really long "pre-chorus" and it can make the listener feel somewhat
anxious and quite uneasy? So I understand where you are coming from.
But I think, maybe that's the feeling they/she was/were going for? Like that feeling right before you fall in love? You know it's coming, you can FEEL the emotions bubbling, you know SOMETHING is happening and you're afraid to 'dive in', to let yourself 'fall'. However, as ExodusUK mentioned, the final chorus truly is a freefall. I think, that's the point, where she moves from being on the verge of "falling in love" into head-over-heels love and admiration.
That video is astounding! It really makes me want to work harder in my piano class lessons. The November video is seriously beautiful as well. I'm jealous, lol.