I thought it was obvious that the overacting in
FLOWER was intentional, just like in
Don't look back (that's the first example that comes to my mind). I also believe that the "amateurism" in the video makes it even more raw.
I know that people are entitled to their opinions but I find it impossible to understand how
Hikari is "beautiful and well-executed" while FLOWER and Mad World are cheap and crappy. I bet y'all didn't find amazing a footage of Utada washing dishes back when the video was released