Quote:
Originally Posted by xLuna&1LOVE
Oh, I guess I am the only one who didn't think minkAYuko's posts were hateful.
Strongly opinionated, yes. Like all of your posts are. So I don't get it, why we treat him as if he is an hater/troll.
|
No, you were not the only one. Their opinion was interesting to read and shouldn't be attacked.
Quote:
Originally Posted by minkAYuko
If she's all about the emotions she should be an actress, I wouldn't pay to see her live if she's just going to be just extending her arms with crazy looks in her eyes and rolling around on the floor because she's "feeling" too much. I want her to SING and she doesn't.
|
That's hilarious and on point to be honest. I'm sorry that you're getting attacked.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrenekoi
Mylene murders pretty much anything she sings live, as she mostly lip syncs.
|
False. It's Ayu who had been lip syncing several songs per concert for years (I don't know if she still does). Farmer only lip synced the first verse of "À force de…", the opening song from "Timeless 2013" tour. She used loud backing track in choruses of many songs in Mylemium Tour, but that's about it. She does not lip sync, even with backing track she's singing over it and numerous fan recordings with wrong lyrics, off-key notes and improvisations prove it. There are also recordings from in-ear monitors. Or are you referring to TV lives? 99% of them were lipped, yes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrenekoi
JTB 3 had Ayu alone on stage for a great amount of time. People complaining Ayu's concerts are too big nowadays are just plain stupid, her concerts were mostly all prop filled monsters since the begining.
|
It's not OK to call people names.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrenekoi
Well, there are people who would pay to watch stripped down shows from people like Madonna or Mylene Farmer, who also happen to be atrocious singers, worst than Ayu.
Even if her vocals aren't 100%, she can really sell the emotion a song asks for on a simple setting, and there are people who would pay for that even if the singing is not always spot on.
I mean, Utada is a way worst live singer and she did a scalled down tour through the USA and it all worked. :B
|
For me Ayu, Utada and Mylene are all in the same category for the most part: beautiful and talented women who write their own lyrics, have an amazing catalog of songs, but are disappointing live singers. They all try to sing out of their range.
They all tend to go off-key a lot, however Ayu is definitely not better, she's the only one who screams, her voice doesn't sound like it comes out naturally, it often feels forced. Mylene is able to sell emotions too, but without portraying Ayu's crazy drama on stage.
Utada's vocals depend on the day, she's hit or miss, sometimes she can suprise me with decent vocals, sometimes she is nasally and out of tune.
Ayu and Mylene were not always that bad. Ayu used not to scream, which made a huge difference and she was better at hitting notes. Mylene damaged her voice by decades of smoking, her voice used to be clearer, stronger and she was actually good at hitting notes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aderianu
Than I don't get why are you still here, because she always was like this and always will be
|
If I remember correctly you were ranting about embarassing performance of What Is Forever Love. Why can't other users complain too?