Since 90% of the people who have voted in the poll so far are in favor of revising the ranks, it looks like we will be changing them.
We will be using songs from all the albums (but not every song) in chronological order. The downside of this is that initiates with higher post counts may have to go through the same titles twice.
It's too bad, but there is no way around it.
Thanks for all the suggestions everyone, keep them coming.