Songs never performed live

[Chibi_Venus]

I remembered a discussion about why kanariya was never performed live (conert/tour and unpublished performances), and I noticed some others that were never performed either.

o FRIEND
o Wishing
o As if...
o from your letter
o Introduction*
o P.S. II
o kanariya
o still alone
o taskinlude*
o everlasting dream
o Over
o neverending dream*
o sotsugyou shashin
o Liar
o HOPE or PAIN
o In The Corner
o criminal

* - Instrumentals

I didn't include the 2005 songs (so far alterna and Will weren't performed, but they're new) and I wasn't sure if most songs from MY STORY counted because they're kind of new (almost a year).

So, was it just because some of these songs weren't popular? I was just wondering what the deal is. lol

[Love Appears]

Depend on You was performed live several times at the beginning of her career, I believe. And I think "Happy Ending" was included in the Arena Tour '05. But as for the rest... you're right. I don't really have any answers about those, but it's quite a shame. I think "As If..." is an especially underrated song. I would've liked to hear it live.

[Chibi_Venus]

Oh, you know what? I forgot about Arena Tour 2005. Oopsie... ^^'' I didn't know about Depend on you though. I think that was a mistake... *checks*

Oh yeah, whoops. Maybe I looked at a different song by accident. ^^;; *edits first post*

[shinde]

Sotsugyou Shashin might not have been performed since it was a cover...(but she performed Haru yo koi...)

[Coelacanth]

I don't think FRIEND II has ever been performed, or has it?

[shinde]

a lot of songs from A SONG FOR xx was never performed either..and I don't think FRIEND II was ever performed.

*edit- just curious, did Ayu ever performed SCAR?

[Love Appears]

Also... I don't think "still alone" was performed. And that was one of my favorite songs.

[Chibi_Venus]

still alone- 8 May 1999 ['Make My Mad Mix'] ("Secret Live" concert) (screen caps here).

SCAR- 5 December 2000 [Acoustic Orchestra version] ("Stage 2000 Winter" concert)

[Love Appears]

Originally Posted by Chibi_Venus

still alone- 8 May 1999 ['Make My Mad Mix'] ("Secret Live" concert) (screen caps here).

SCAR- 5 December 2000 [Acoustic Orchestra version] ("Stage 2000 Winter" concert)

Edit: It appears that you're referring to "Signal" because "still alone" wasn't recorded until the "I am..." album, which wasn't released until 2002.

[shinde]

thanks for the info Chibi Venus! I want to hear SCAR live...

[Chibi_Venus]

Originally Posted by Love Appears

Edit: It appears that you're referring to "Signal" because "still alone" wasn't recorded until the "I am..." album, which wasn't released until 2002.

Let me tell you: I'm not myself today. I'm sorry about the wrong info! XP
You're right. That was SIGNAL. still alone wasn't performed live. Alright. And yeah, I liked that song too. What a shame.

Originally Posted by shinde

thanks for the info Chibi Venus! I want to hear SCAR live...

You're welcome!

[Corybobory]

Honey was performed at countdown 2005 wasnt it? I seem to remember loving it... or maybe I'm mistaken...

[walking proud]

POWDER SNOW has never been performed live, has it?

[PickleCookies]

bates, it was performed at a secret live. So it's never officially been out.

[AyuRlz]

yep.. some of those you have listed have been performed but many others have not been performed.. i would really like to hear her sing the songs

[Chibi_Venus]

I took away a couple songs. HAPPY ENDING, Replace, and HONEY. I guess I forgot to look at Arena Tour 2005. *feels stupid*

Other than that, it should be okay.

[emi♡]

do interludes (or introductions?) really count? i dont think she would perform them anyway...unless she has before???

[Chibi_Venus]

Took away Catcher In The Light, WONDERLAND, and Kaleidoscope.

Anyway, yeah it would seem that way, but I mean some like opening Run and taskinillusion were performed so... *shrug* Yeh. Ayu's vocal songs rock more anyway. XP

what about the song "too late" has she ever performed that?

[SunshineSlayer]

Yes, she has performed too late durring her 2000 tour and 2002 Stadium tour. Many of the songs off of herfirst album were performed ata secret live that was never televised.