Videophone VS Rude Boy

[SURREAL__RAINBOW]

I loveee the idea in both clips. I think they're both really creative and cool. But which one do you prefer?



Beyoncé feat. Lady GaGa - Videophone
http://www.youtube.com/watch#playnex...&v=CtIdxk2zqXs


Rihanna - Rude Boy
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e82VE8UtW8A

[Kingdom]

rudeboy. the only good thing about videophone is gaga

[Cherry Dynamite]

I absolutely hate Videophone.
Rude Boy is creative wherein Videophone is dumb..

[happiholic★]

I liked Videophone better, actually. I dunno it was funny and odd. Rude Boy didn't do anything for me. In fact, Videophone's MV made me like the song.

[JackieRos]

Videophone of course
LADY GAGA completed this video

[ohsixthirty]

i kind of hate them both...songs and videos.

videophone was so boring that i could barely sit thru it and rude boy looks like something m.i.a. would vomit up if she got sick.

[Sundae]

Videophone made me like the song. I liked Rude Boy before the MV but it didn't make me like it more. I was looking forward to sexy RiRi with amazing style, but it was delivered in weird clothes. I like the fact that both are colorful.

[Paparazzi]

This is like comparing shi* to p*ss. they both suck. seriously awful songs. ironically, i love the artists involved.

[ohsixthirty]

Originally Posted by Paparazzi

This is like comparing shi* to p*ss. they both suck. seriously awful songs. ironically, i love the artists involved.

kind of how i felt too.

usually i at least kind of like what these artists do, but not this time.

[Paparazzi]

i know. the worst by the best.

[fake_foxtail]

Rude Boy. I love Rihanna's current style. I thought this video would be something like her old stuff, but no.

[SURREAL__RAINBOW]

aw I just love them! too bad some of u guys cant see the awesome background of the ideas for this 2 videos!

videophone is like a mix of bee's sexy r&b style+gaga's craziness which i think is hilarious and weird but somehow works for me and i think for nearly everyone else too (yea, people is always afraid of new things i believe)


rude boy is like SUCH a cool video!! omfg i just love all the ideas that they brought up from the 80's and stuff! loving rihanna's fashion! she's a gaga herself ^^


anyway i picked videophone cause i cant get enough of it!

[TITANIC]

rude boy sounds great to me

[pommy48]

Rude Boy

I don't like either one of the songs...but I like the idea behind the music video better~

[Kingdom]

Originally Posted by SURREAL__RAINBOW

videophone is like a mix of bee's sexy r&b style+gaga's craziness which i think is hilarious and weird but somehow works for me and i think for nearly everyone else too (yea, people is always afraid of new things i believe)

videophone wasn't a mix of gaga and beyonce's style, beyonce asked gaga how she wanted to do the video and gaga told her that she didn't want any gaga to show through. she wanted to do it beyonce's way.

cool theory though.

[kirei_ayumi]

I prefer video phone

[SURREAL__RAINBOW]

Originally Posted by ero-kakkoii

videophone wasn't a mix of gaga and beyonce's style, beyonce asked gaga how she wanted to do the video and gaga told her that she didn't want any gaga to show through. she wanted to do it beyonce's way.

cool theory though.

knew that lol but obviously the fact that gaga appears and sings gave the song and the video her touch of craziness as well

[love in music]

I hate both of these videos so much but gaga made the videophone video funny and had me laughing when I was cringing at most of beyonces moves. There is nothing good about Rude Boy. ugh, I rly do not like rihanna.

[4minute Girl]

My two favorite videos in the history of music, I can't decide!

[hearted]

i love both beyonce and gaga but videophone is just disgusting D: i did like some crazy gaga parts though XD

so im gonna vote for rude boy,,