Your Opinion || Great song > Horrible PV

Foxxy_Fuyumi · #1 25th August 2007, 08:05 PM

Great song > Horrible PV

There are always songs you like that have terrible PVs.
So tell us your opinion, and ideas for a great PV.
Inspired by JPM

cloud♥honey · #2 25th August 2007, 08:09 PM

Stephanie - Kimi ga Iru Kagiri
Utada Hikaru - Beautiful World
Utada Hikaru - COLORS
Utada Hikaru - Automatic
Ayumi Hamasaki - glitter / fated
Ayumi Hamasaki - momentum
Namie Amuro - Hello
Namie Amuro - FUNKY TOWN
Namie Amuro - WoWa
Hitomi Shimatani - Anata to Ita Toki
Hitomi Shimatani - Ramblin'
Hitomi Shimatani - Koimizu tears of love

There are a lot of PVs but I can't remember one more.

sora2522 · #3 25th August 2007, 08:11 PM

hikari
maybe something technologically enhanced?
before i saw the actual pv, i thought the pv was gonna be something like:
someone opens up their e-mail
they get sucked in or something and then
everything starts becoming crazy cool or something

kiss & cry/beautiful world deserve new pvs, too

thinkingoutloud89 · #4 25th August 2007, 08:13 PM

misono - LOVELY CATS EYE
Ayumi Hamasaki - poker afce
Ayumi Hamasaki - Boys & Girls
Ayumi Hamasaki - vogue, far Away, SEASONS
Ayumi Hamasaki - Daybreak
Koda Kumi - Trust Your Love
Koda Kumi - Kiseki
Namie Amuro - BODY feels EXIT
Namie Amuro - Chase the Chance
SOULHEAD - fiesta
BoA - Kimochi wa Tsutawaru

chibi_sunny · #5 25th August 2007, 10:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloud_Honey

Utada Hikaru - COLORS

The song is so beautiful; there were so many things she could have done with the PV...

Quote:

Originally Posted by sora2522

hikari
maybe something technologically enhanced?
before i saw the actual pv, i thought the pv was gonna be something like:
someone opens up their e-mail
they get sucked in or something and then
everything starts becoming crazy cool or something

.
Much better than washing dishes.
Again, I only have the same thing as I said for COLORS.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monkey_D_Ruffy16

Ayumi Hamasaki - vogue, far Away, SEASONS

I wouldn't complain about the trilogy. At least...it was unique...

I always thought Maaya Sakamoto's PV were very dull. Her songs are great; her voice is amazing; but her PVs, not so much. Usually she just stands around...no special effects...absolutely nothing.
Hitomi Shimatani's PVs are also lacking in something...can't quite put my finger on it...

Compared to some of these artists, there's no reason to complain about Ayu. At least she releases some noteworthy PVs once in a while. Even BLUE BIRD got me up and dancing. Lol.

fanmail · #6 25th August 2007, 08:14 PM

Koda Kumi "No Regret"
Koda Kumi "m.a.z.e"
BoA "Sweet Impact"
Ayu "WHATEVER"

...yeah.

namiie · #7 25th August 2007, 08:19 PM

Ayu - "JEWEL"
Ai Otsuka - "CHU-LIP", "PEACH"

That's all I can think of for now

fanmail · #8 25th August 2007, 08:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by namiie

Ayu - "JEWEL"

BLASPHEMY!!!! That's such an amazing PV!!!

And, for those who choose "Daybreak" .... I'm gonna dig up that analysis of it that made me love that PV

bondingo · #9 5th May 2008, 05:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by namiie

Ayu - "JEWEL"
Ai Otsuka - "CHU-LIP", "PEACH"

That's all I can think of for now

Those are like their best PVS

As for my choices:
evolution (Ayu) - MOST DISAPPOINTING PV EVER!!!
Voyage (Ayu) - Just clips from the film, bleh...
CAROLS (Ayu) - Amazing song, but the PV is boring as all hell
HEAVEN (Ayu) - Another boring PV for a great song
glitter (Ayu) - Stupid concept that I dislike a lot. Could have been a great, normal PV
decision (Ayu) - It's like a concert performance lipsynched and in good video quality. I wanted something great for such an amazing song

ALARM (Namie) - Awesome song, the PV could have been a lot more interesting. Plus I hate black and white

Hikari (Hikki) - Like seriously?! She's washing ****ing dishes!

real Emotion (Kuu) - Such an awesome song shouldn't have had such a typical PV

Luv ~Venus~ · #10 25th August 2007, 08:20 PM

Crystal Kay - Motherland
Koda Kumi - Shake It, Butterfly
Sowelu - I will
Utada Hikaru - Hikari
Ayumi Hamasaki - Jewel
.....hmmm, I can't remember anymore for now!

@Cloud_Honey:

How can u not like the COLORS PV....It was so beautiful and symbolic!!! lol

Foxxy_Fuyumi · #11 25th August 2007, 08:23 PM

My Opinion:
Mink - Omajinai
Mika Nakashima - LIFE (It's that bad, but could be better than just her face.)
Morning Musume - Ambitious! Yashinteki de ii jan!
Utada Hikaru - hikari
Ayumi Hamasaki - Connected
Mika Nakashima - Aishiteru
Olivia - Sea Me

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloud_Honey

Utada Hikaru - COLORS

KILL TIME!

Raiu-Ayu · #12 25th August 2007, 08:25 PM

ayu - glitter / fated
AAA - No End Summer
Koda Kumi - Ai no Uta
Koda Kumi - Yume no Uta
Koda Kumi - Futari de... (those 3 are more or less the same damn video!! And yes I know Yume no Uta and Futari de... are supposed to be that way but WHATEVER!!)

fanmail · #13 25th August 2007, 08:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by imuyA

i think it's a little harsh to say that about a PV you say you don't understand. anyway, daybreak is a pretty simple PV, but it does have a lot of symbolism. the long road is one... it represents the journey of life. ayumi in white is another... white is usually the symbol for purity, cleanliness, innocence... etc

you should also notice the camera work. the whole video is a continuous shot. there are no cuts away from ayumi... meaning she had to get it perfect without any editing (like the heaven pv). this has meaning too... that life has no reset button like a video game, do-overs... editing... although it may not be your favorite pv, i hope this post at the very least helps you gain some respect for the pv ^^

^_^

thinkingoutloud89 · #14 25th August 2007, 08:43 PM

^ still think she looks weird (make up wise and the turban or whatever) and its boring XD thx anyways for the nice analysis

I forgot:

Ayumi hamasaki - Dearest Acoustic Piano Version

namiie · #15 25th August 2007, 08:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fanmail

BLASPHEMY!!!! That's such an amazing PV!!!

"JEWEL"? Eh. If I wanted to watch a jewelry store commercial, I could just turn on the TV and only have to sit through 30 sec of it instead of 4 min.

It was pretty much just eye candy....for a song so poignant, it sure had a rather shallow PV.

fanmail · #16 25th August 2007, 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by namiie

"JEWEL"? Eh. If I wanted to watch a jewelry store commercial, I could just turn on the TV and only have to sit through 30 sec of it instead of 4 min.

It was pretty much just eye candy....for a song so poignant, it sure had a rather shallow PV.

LMAO, well at least you have good reasons xD

Luv ~Venus~ · #17 25th August 2007, 09:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by namiie

"JEWEL"? Eh. If I wanted to watch a jewelry store commercial, I could just turn on the TV and only have to sit through 30 sec of it instead of 4 min.

It was pretty much just eye candy....for a song so poignant, it sure had a rather shallow PV.

^_^; Well, at least....she earned herself another spot on "the most expensive video chart!" lol

sora2522 · #18 25th August 2007, 10:10 PM

that was her least expensive out of the 3 that she had (funny, fairyland was her most, and my name's WOMEN was in the middle)

Foxxy_Fuyumi · #19 25th August 2007, 10:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sora2522

that was her least expensive out of the 3 that she had (funny, fairyland was her most, and my name's WOMEN was in the middle)

No no But I think JEWEL passed those.
Jewel is now the most expensive.

sora2522 · #20 25th August 2007, 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Foxxy_Fuyumi

No no But I think JEWEL passed those.
Jewel is now the most expensive.

nope
it didn't

i checked the list. it was the LAST most expensive pv that ayu had

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of...e_music_videos

see?

speaking of videos:

Quote:

Popular clips have featured death, ghosts, executions, werewolves, reincarnation, clowns, doppelgangers, cyborgs, angels, and Santa Claus.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayumi_h...i#Music_videos

THAT IS JUST TOO FUNNY