Hilary Duff or Lindsay Lohan?

[imagina12y]

haha, i was watching VH1 and they had this show with celebrity battles. they were talking about whether hilary or lindsay was the next britney..both girls are actors turned singers and have a growing fan base. what do you guys think? i personally like lindsay lohan better.

[tl1029530921]

lindsay can sing better...lindsay's a better actress too..but Hilary's more popular for some reason..o.o

[boogieordie]

Hilary. Nice girl.

I'd say more but then that would break our rule of no bashing, so I shall shut my mouth right now.

[drewbilation]

Hilary! She's so cute! ^_^

[Nu-NRG]

Lindsay ^-^
she is really cute, can sing pretty well
in the movie Mean Girls was her best performance out of all those movies she did imho

[natalaxie]

I like Lindsay's acting better, but I don't like her personality. Some of the things they say about her in the papers and stuff..... she's out of control. it might not be true what they say tho. I don't really care about either of them much tho

[Ayumi_Hamasaki902]

I don't like either of them. Hilary Duff looks like Ayumi from her Long Blonde Days. That's what my friend said. And it does look true.

[Zeke.]

Originally Posted by Ayumi_Hamasaki902

I don't like either of them. Hilary Duff looks like Ayumi from her Long Blonde Days. That's what my friend said. And it does look true.

Yeah! I don't really think so but I have a picture of that Ayumi one you have in your sig and everyone thinks it is Hilary Duff, lol.

Anyways... Don't even get me started on this because I could sit here for hours and tell you why Hilary Duff is better than that [beep, beep, beep, beep, beep, beep] Lindsay Lohan (although I like her too). Hilary is just so much more of a better person. She isn't like the other pop-stars before her and Lindsay is. Hilary doesn't show off her skin and isn't racy where as Lindsay is concerned, she is the queen of raciness! Hilary has a good head on her shoulders and is SO MUCH BETTER than LOHAN!

[yulen]

neither

[ayumi_pukka89]

Originally Posted by yulen

neither

wo0t wo0t
^^; I second that

[paper_doll]

Originally Posted by yulen

neither

[shinji1698]

LINDSAY LOHAN ****EN ROCKS.

[Larisa-chan]

errr neither x.x both of qualities that really piss me off and I have no respect for them. Hilary's "clean" image is a fake, and Lindsay's image is just... ....

[Brittany]

I used to like Lindsay, but when I saw her video on MTV.. I nearly died.
Come on, if she is talking about the papprazzi and wanting them to leave her alone, than.. uh, then stop being an actress. I hate when people complain, especially celebrities about being stalked. They chose to be an actor, they have to suffer the concequences of being one :| Sorry it's such a harsh statement, but it's my opinion.
So for me, neither
.........I prefer Ayumi. Simple as that.

[PsyGen]

Neither. I really don't like either, singing nor acting-wise. Gimme Ayu/ELT/Mika anyday man...

[Cyria]

I like Hilary better and almost voted for her, but then I noticed that the actual poll question said 'next Britney'.

I then changed to Lindsay. Not so good fashion choices, partying, dodgy boyfriend? Getting close to Mrs Federline.

In the sense of Britney as a huge celebrity I really can't guess. I thought it would be Lindsay because of her movie success and because she seemed to get more respect from 20+ people (I used to see a lot of 'Lindsay the next Julia Roberts' talk on movie forums right after Mean Girls was released). I've been starting to doubt that though. Hilary's image seems to be in better shape right now, and that does matter. If Lindsay just parties with the Hiltons she might lose the advantage she had.

Hilary and Lindsay have a chance of becoming Britney-famous, they just need something (a blockbuster movie, a major hit album) that even those who aren't part of their usual audience can recognize them from. But it's probably an either-or situation. I doubt they'll both be massive stars five years from now.

[cleftjuston]

they are equal to me

[bondingo]

Originally Posted by Cyria

I like Hilary better and almost voted for her, but then I noticed that the actual poll question said 'next Britney'.

I then changed to Lindsay. Not so good fashion choices, partying, dodgy boyfriend? Getting close to Mrs Federline.

In the sense of Britney as a huge celebrity I really can't guess. I thought it would be Lindsay because of her movie success and because she seemed to get more respect from 20+ people (I used to see a lot of 'Lindsay the next Julia Roberts' talk on movie forums right after Mean Girls was released). I've been starting to doubt that though. Hilary's image seems to be in better shape right now, and that does matter. If Lindsay just parties with the Hiltons she might lose the advantage she had.

Hilary and Lindsay have a chance of becoming Britney-famous, they just need something (a blockbuster movie, a major hit album) that even those who aren't part of their usual audience can recognize them from. But it's probably an either-or situation. I doubt they'll both be massive stars five years from now.

My thoughts exactly...

I definitely prefer Hilary as she was, oddly enough, my favorite singer before Ayu. However, Lindsay is much more similar to Britney than she is and equally more likely to inspire controversy.

[bernardation]

i love hilarys "come clean" and she's such a cute girl.
but "rumors" is great too...

[~^V^~]

i'd say lindsay, tho they arent both super