Ayu's TO BE covered by Angela An.

[truehappiness]

In the newest album by Angela An, one of her songs, 有你陪著我, covers TO BE.

Video and audio samples respectively found here:

Video: http://grm.cdn.hinet.net/nextv/hiliv...077A_003_V.asf

Audio: http://grm.cdn.hinet.net/nextv/hiliv...90077A_003.asf

I think it loses its.. innocence :\ Plus the video is just her on a beach.

x.x

[Manross]

Hmmmm....the music is exactly the same...i dun reall like singers get the music from other singer and change its lyrics..btw whos angela an?

[ImpactBreaker]

Originally Posted by Manross

Hmmmm....the music is exactly the same...i dun reall like singers get the music from other singer and change its lyrics..btw whos angela an?

So you probably hate "Bold & Delicious", "Pride", "rainy day", "Beautiful day", "Ladies Night" and "In The Corner" right?

[Kikaru]

Originally Posted by ImpactBreaker

So you probably hate "Bold & Delicious", "Pride", "rainy day", "Beautiful day", "Ladies Night" and "In The Corner" right?

Don't forget Memorial Address.

Although I thought Ayu's cover of those songs were better, simply because Ayu had a different arranger, and I thought I like the new arrangement better.

Originally Posted by cleftjuston

angela an, is it the new singer who looks like vicki zhao?

...From far away I though she looked like Utada Hikaru...

[momobean]

^I don't like cover songs that either, though it depends whether the singer can sing well or not. I haven't heard of Angela An either..

TO BE is one of my favourite songs, I think this singer did okay but I definitely prefer Ayu's version..

[alternarist]

it sounds so yucky!

[cleftjuston]

angela an, is it the new singer who looks like vicki zhao?

[Nu-NRG]

^ yea....take Cyndi Wang for instance also in Avex and also done some cover songs: Hitomi Shimatani for exacmple

Originally Posted by cleftjuston

angela an, is it the new singer who looks like vicki zhao?

uhm...that's Angela Chang:張韶涵
the cover one is by Angela An:安又琪

I hope Ayu gets credit for the song!

[tinyppl]

If they cover a song and do a better job, I have no problem with it.

But usually Taiwanese/Hk singers do inferior versions.

Doing a cover is not stealing or copying. But when you cover a song that was first done by another singer, people tend to set certain expectation of the cover song to be as standard and quality as the original. Unfortunately, for those who did cover of ayu songs so far, I would say didn't do a very good job.

As for Ayu's cover of Sweetbox songs, you got to admit that many of ayu's versions sound very good still thanks to the composers who did the new arrangement of the music. Eg: Ladies Night. I personally feel that the credit should goes to the ppl who did the arrangment for ayu's versions, instead of just Ayu alone. And Sweetbox definitely still owns because they made the music.


And nope Ayu doesn't get the credit because D.A.I composed the music of To Be. Ayu only did the lyrics which was completely redid into chinese in this cover.

[AyuGAME]

i think all of that song that you have mention was original ayu
jade was cover it...because ayu release it first and then jade release it
by the way i want to hear this version of to be

[Kikaru]

^actually, GEO composed it for Sweetbox's new album, but then he send them to Ayu. So technically, it is a Sweetbox song.

[AyuMayu]

I think it sounds ok...

[elepop]

It doesn't sound too bad. Her voice is okay, and the music hasn't changed. But I still like Ayu's version better.

Here's her website: http://www.avex.com.tw/angela/index.asp

She doesn't look like Vicki Zhao Wei at all! Zhao Wei is prettier.

[Alessia_Tateno]

Memorial Address? is it a cover too?

[Kikaru]

^yes, the original is called Kumo. The composer is also the composer of Kumo. And like those songs, the arrangement is also different. I think that's why they called it "take 2 version".

[tomoko-stepyou]

I think I actually prefer this person's version to ayu's. I was never much of a fan of TO BE anyway, but for some reason this version feels slightly more heartfelt and passioate, it just has a better arrengement in my opinion.

[Maiku]

"Bold & Delicious", "Pride", "rainy day", "Beautiful day", "Ladies Night" and "In The Corner" right?

in my opinion those ayu songs have to be the worst ive only listen once sadly i hate missunderstood cause of those songs

as for the cover of Tobe the girl isnt doing a bad job at it

[Alessia_Tateno]

oh but the words of Memorial Address are also written by Kumo or written by her?

[elepop]

Originally Posted by Alessia_Tateno

oh but the words of Memorial Address are also written by Kumo or written by her?

The lyrics of Ayu's version are written by herself. She took the music but changed the lyrics and the arrangements a little.