[NEWS] Eason Chan critcises Ayu of Lip-synching

[truehappiness]

It sucks when people try to bank off of others' popularity by insulting them..

[WillofDusk]

He could increase his popularity by imitating Paris Hilton, that'd be much better than accusing Ayu of lip-synchin.

Lame lame lame

[freedreamer]

his is such a Ars

the more i read...the more irritated i get...so stoopid..unprofessional....I doubt he could even pay attention to the lip-synch when he was so tired...NONSENSE

[WillofDusk]

Let accuse him of his groin injury and compare it to Ayu's lip-sync rumour.
He'd cry desperately to his *ss

[bluegie]

Well HK media, esp newspapers and (gossip) magazines, have such an amazed power to turn everything upside down. We should be more objective on Eason's comment. He didn't really mean to bash ayu, but he does have an error tho. He shouldn't have talked about this in the public. Now (almost) every single newspaper in HK used his comment to create story or so. It's good that he commented ayu's lip-syncing during a tv interview instead of newspaper ones. I watched the clips, he's not being harsh... He's just... too straight forward sometimes. (I'm not his fan btw so no need to think that I'm protecting him or something)

Grasshoppers, on the other hand, are just totally old brats. I just feel like vomitting to their faces at this moment.

[djinn]

damn him
maybe he just wanna get attention and envious about ayu
just look at what have u done
dare to sleep sumore
i was sooooooooo pissed off when i read bout this article

[Dustie]

yeah, he was probably jelous it's not him having an Asia Tour or whatever, or was really tricked by her voice and sound system...

[truehappiness]

Well, the fact that he even brought it up is proof that he "doubts" her singing abilities.. D:


PLUS, what he said brought those old farts into the mix.

[yamogi]

Originally Posted by tinyppl

Reading eason's article initially and watching his video has a rather big difference. I realised in the video, he's alot more polite. The article made him out to be much more rude. Yes he stands on his opinion that he thinks ayu lipsynchs because of the massive dancing. But in a way he also tried to defend ayu that lipsyching is not a big problem even Michael Jackson (the King of Pop) does it.

If they are so sure that she lipsynched, all the more I want to the live video myself and judge by myself. That's if they are ever gonna release it or something.

And hmm, I don't think ayu will drop her future asia tours just because of this, she don't have to disappoint all her fans because of one eason guy. So don't worry about that =)

Some concert videos are already on this forum
you should see the one of until that day
and you'll hear that ayu went off-key during "uh~la~la~la" while she was having "massive dancing", she also stuck a little in the song.

[bluegie]

Originally Posted by Qt Mashi

this is what a person look like when they are jealous



it's like all these weak voiced guys attacking queen Ayu, in the end Ayu will win hehe

LOL... I dunno what to say anymore. you did capture one of his ugliest expression ... the caption on this pic is "(seems like) you dunno how to sing". In reality he's talking something like "well lip syncing is not like a really bad thing blah blah blah, it is not something (seems like) you dunno how to sing blah blah blah".

I dunno... i will slap eason (for underestimate HK media's power).. that's all.
Grasshoppers should be burnt (cuz I really hate how they jump to conclusion without encounter the real incident).

[babamon]

Originally Posted by bluegie

Well HK media, esp newspapers and (gossip) magazines, have such an amazed power to turn everything upside down. We should be more objective on Eason's comment. He didn't really mean to bash ayu, but he does have an error tho. He shouldn't have talked about this in the public. Now (almost) every single newspaper in HK used his comment to create story or so. It's good that he commented ayu's lip-syncing during a tv interview instead of newspaper ones. I watched the clips, he's not being harsh... He's just... too straight forward sometimes. (I'm not his fan btw so no need to think that I'm protecting him or something)

Grasshoppers, on the other hand, is totally old brats. I just feel like vomitting to their face at this moment.

I gotta agree. Comparing both eason and grasshoppers, eason sounded more polite than them.

[xxjonxx]

eason = old fart that has no songs that want to make me listen to him ...
how can he grade a goddess way above him,a little dust compared to ayu...
he seriously need to learn 2 criticize b4 he gets his groin busted by fans all over the world

[freedreamer]

my friend said "he probably thought she was singing cantonese or sth. then the mouth shape different"

LOL!

[WillofDusk]

That face showed no respect or even politeness.
He's junk and he just drives me crazy of this.

[babamon]

-_-" I think ppl shld watch the whole video rather than looking at that screencap and imagine how he looked like talking abt ayu thruout the whole interview. Cos seriously in the vid he doesn't sound that bad.

[Devil Ayu]

Well...I've watched all of her Live DVDs and she never lip-synched!

This Eason just wants everybody to pay attention at him!!!!

[yamogi]

Originally Posted by tinyppl

Okay for people who did not understand chinese, here's what eason said in the video ayu_fan929 posted.

"To me, lipsynching is actually part of a performance. But Hong Kong has this perception that if you lipsyc, it tends to portray that you can't sing. But seriously, even Michael Jackson does it. Yesterday, I saw this part. She was dancing vigorously yet the voice quality standard heard at that moment of time does not seem possible to reach. It applies to everyone else. No matter how great you're singing, when you're dancing, it's not possible that you can mantain such flawless voice quality. But I do not think it's a problem (or rather, a big deal) to me. I just thought, eh? Ayumi does it too."

I think this is more accurate than the article (reporters rephrased it) since it's directly translated from what he said in the video though I do not guarantee you my translation is that good, I tried to make it close to what he had mentioned in chinese and hope you understand what I translated.

About the sleeping part, the video ayu_desu posted is in cantonese which I do not understand. But she kindly translated that he dozed off at certain parts due to couple of sleepless nights, and that it's his own fault, not ayu's fault.

Initially, I was really mad at him >_< But now, I kinda don't think he meant it in a harsh and bashful manner but was just stating what he thinks (which might not be right). I guess I really wanna watch the live myself to convince and confirm myself that ayu did not lip-sych. =)

She actually DID NOT lipsynch because I was there at the show too. Very obviously, during those so-called "massive dancing songs", ayu stuck in some part. That was not "flawless" at all, I heard quite a lot (...some) flaws. She can't breathe probably during until that day, just like something was stuck at her throat. During uh~la~la~la, she even went off-key (sorry to hear that), how can it be flawless???

Did I convince you enough?

[WillofDusk]

I like this fighting stuff. AS long as it's for Ayu, i'll kill him yay!

(Mags are crazy, but Eason did start all of these)

[tinyppl]

Originally Posted by babamon

-_-" I think ppl shld watch the whole video rather than looking at that screencap and imagine how he looked like talking abt ayu thruout the whole interview. Cos seriously in the vid he doesn't sound that bad.

He had that expression when he was imitating hong konger's perception of lip-syncing that they think you can't sing that's why you lip-synch.

[yamogi]

Grasshoppers sings and dances like crap. Johnny's are a lot better than them.
It'd better for them to take some trains in Japan and find out how Japanese artists actually SING.

BTW,
I believe Eason is not mischievous, but his words DID contain FACTUAL ERRORS. It showed that he is not very responsible for his identity as a celebrity. He should be remained that his words have the ability to crash someone's reputation entirely.