Question Reg Together When ... & Mirrorcle World

[KarenPang]

ok I'm a bit confused not between both songs but as to whether to count Mirrorcle World as ayumi's 43rd or 44th single .

Is Mirrorcle World counted as the 43rd or 44th single ? I think it's the 43rd since Together When ... is a digital single but I personally don't know about this .

[Zemus]

I'd count it as her 43rd. Digital Singles are a different category imo.

[Deneb]

43th I only count physical singles. digital single its different... i can't buy it physically xD

[KarenPang]

Originally Posted by Deneb

43th I only count physical singles. digital single its different... i can't buy it physically xD

haha that's true reg physical sales & the likes

[pop909]

I think that it shoudlnt really be the digital or physical part but the single part.

I think that Together When... is her 43rd. and Mirrorcle World has her 44th.

[truehappiness]

Officially, her 43rd is Mirrorcle World.

No artist counts a digital single as part of their "original single canon" or w/e.

[KarenPang]

Originally Posted by truehappiness

Officially, her 43rd is Mirrorcle World.

No artist counts a digital single as part of their "original single canon" or w/e.

that's true

thanks everyone !

[alternarist]

i dont get it. the official website said its a digital SINGLE.

so i thought Together When... is considered as a single? but oh well. shall listen to the great truehappiness cos whatever he says are always true.

[KarenPang]

I don't know that's confusing also .

ayaka also released a digital single too but that's not counted in the pic so ok lor take it as it's .

apparently her duet with Kobukuro's ala WINDING ROAD is counted as her 5th single . 6th's Jewelry Day , 7th's CLAP & LOVE + WHY & her latest's her 8th

[truehappiness]

Originally Posted by alternarist

i dont get it. the official website said its a digital SINGLE.

so i thought Together When... is considered as a single? but oh well. shall listen to the great truehappiness cos whatever he says are always true.

Exactly.

It says DIGITAL SINGLE.

Digital singles are almost never categorized with original singles. Like how studio albums and best albums are separate. Just because they're both 'albums' doesn't make them the same... just like original studio albums and original mini albums..

http://avexnet.or.jp/ayu/jp/discography/
See the different category for digital singles? O_o

[alternarist]

Originally Posted by truehappiness

Exactly.

It says DIGITAL SINGLE.

Digital singles are almost never categorized with original singles. Like how studio albums and best albums are separate. Just because they're both 'albums' doesn't make them the same... just like original studio albums and original mini albums..

http://avexnet.or.jp/ayu/jp/discography/
See the different category for digital singles? O_o

alright.. i must admit that whatever u said made sense..