[YT] is GREEN plagiarism?

[MemorialAddress]

Well, actually they do sound similar, even though GREEN is only a 30 second preview
It's clear that they're very similar, especially in the way they both sing the lyrics almost exactly the same, so I think the fact that GREEN is only a preview is completely irrelevant. . .

[GRACE]

Originally Posted by MemorialAddress08

Well, actually they do sound similar, even though GREEN is only a 30 second preview
It's clear that they're very similar, especially in the way they both sing the lyrics almost exactly the same, so I think the fact that GREEN is only a preview is completely irrelevant. . .

It's COMPLETELY relevant. We don't know what the full GREEN sounds like, so we can't make a judgment yet. They aren't all that similar really, they even sound like they're in different keys...

[MemorialAddress]

Originally Posted by GRACE

It's COMPLETELY relevant. We don't know what the full GREEN sounds like, so we can't make a judgment yet. They aren't all that similar really, they even sound like they're in different keys...

Yes, we can make a judgement.
Yeah, it's only a preview, but it's still the song, so we know how it sounds.
It would be different if it were a 5 second preview, but it's not. It's 30 seconds. And that is PLENTY long enough to make a connection with that Chinese song...
And, I didn't say it was a copy either. I'm just saying it sounds similar.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally Posted by MemorialAddress08

Yes, we can make a judgement.
Yeah, it's only a preview, but it's still the song, so we know how it sounds.
It would be different if it were a 5 second preview, but it's not. It's 30 seconds. And that is PLENTY long enough to make a connection with that Chinese song...
And, I didn't say it was a copy either. I'm just saying it sounds similar.

you don't know anything about how the song sounds as a whole if you hear 30 seconds of it. you do, in fact, know how 30 seconds of the song sounds but that's it.

[truehappiness]

Originally Posted by MemorialAddress08

Yes, we can make a judgement.
Yeah, it's only a preview, but it's still the song, so we know how it sounds.
It would be different if it were a 5 second preview, but it's not. It's 30 seconds. And that is PLENTY long enough to make a connection with that Chinese song...
And, I didn't say it was a copy either. I'm just saying it sounds similar.

If that's the case then you could've made the judgement/judgment that Will sounded like that song from Kiki's Delivery Service since that was like a 30 second snippet of the melody and etc.~

But guess what? They were NOTHING ALIKE OTHER THAN THOSE >>30 SECONDS.

It's frustrating that people love to defend something that has a tiiiiiiiiiinny bit of proof and then in the end, it's all worthless.

-see One's all / claim-

[ren0210989]

Originally Posted by truehappiness

If that's the case then you could've made the judgement/judgment that Will sounded like that song from Kiki's Delivery Service since that was like a 30 second snippet of the melody and etc.~

But guess what? They were NOTHING ALIKE OTHER THAN THOSE >>30 SECONDS.

It's frustrating that people love to defend something that has a tiiiiiiiiiinny bit of proof and then in the end, it's all worthless.

-see One's all / claim-

i dubble that. you took the words out of my mouth XD



gosh i hate when ppl do this things....


and PeincessAyu; i'm not even gonna comment your post...