S.H.E fans views on copying ayu songs

[ohsixthirty]

another thread on this?

wow...just wow.

seems that we've moved from hating jolin to hating s.h.e. around here. haha.

[LacusClyne]

Originally Posted by devilayu

Well, whatever the case, please try not to bring another forum's drama here. It'll only exacerbate the situation and bring unnecessary grief to Ayumi fans AND S.H.E. fans.

sorry about that, i just thought we should have a right to know what the fans of S.H.E are thinking. i hated to jump to conclusions, i'm the type who would listen to both sides of the story. but their fans answers are too unacceptable, but thankfuly, there are still some reasonable S.H.E fans...

[elepop]

Originally Posted by touchedstar

another thread on this?

wow...just wow.

seems that we've moved from hating jolin to hating s.h.e. around here. haha.

Well, you know the "Ayu-fans". Always searching for more trouble. Haha.

[Qt Mashi]

Originally Posted by ayuzilla

o no not this **** again...this has pretty much already been posted...she biting off of Ayu blah blah blah. Both artists are produced by Avex ppl. yeesh get ur facts straight. so sick of hearing this whiny nonsense.

omg..if some people wanna discuss the SHE and Ayu issues they have the right to, but dont just come here and give rude comments without any arguable points, lacking originality

for those people who are just going to post here saying "not this again" or "get over it, this is old" save your time and just ignore this topic please~~

[Qt Mashi]

Originally Posted by miyuchan

for those who can't read chinese, i got a summary. most of the fans think it's no big deal in copying a song, as long as S.H.E sings it well. some even had the nerve to say that ayu must thank S.H.E for copying her songs. since people would get curious and pay attention to ayu's song!!! what a bunch of nonsense.

well i dont relli blame SHE fans for thinking that way, they're trying to protect their idol and most of them are probably young anyways

but for SHE saying that their song is nothing similar to Ayu's 'about you' is a big booboo they just lost my respect, i thought they would atleast give Ayu some credit for the song but instead they claim its original, that also makes their fans hating on Ayu for no reason

[Mad_Cactuar]

Originally Posted by asongforXX

Well, you know the "Ayu-fans". Always searching for more trouble. Haha.

You know, I think thats true! We fans are a little hard-headed and aggressive sometimes!

[momobean]

but for SHE saying that their song is nothing similar to Ayu's 'about you' is a big booboo they just lost my respect, i thought they would atleast give Ayu some credit for the song but instead they claim its original, that also makes their fans hating on Ayu for no reason

...I totally agree on this point. I wouldn't even have minded if they said it was only a coincidence, after all there are so many repeated tunes around the world.

Pfft. Tone deaf or what? Sorry I don't know how to mince my words.

[firefox]

i heard the song and it doesnt sound alike at all and i never listen to SHE only d/led it this time to see how similar it really is....and my verdict: The pv is but the song isnt similar

give it a rest

[Mad_Cactuar]

I think SHE is getting more publicity with the help of Ayufans.. Noticed that we, who have NEVER EVER heard of their songs are suddenly downloading it and listening? Wont that make it possible for SHE to gain new fans..?

[LacusClyne]

err??? you live in malaysia where S.H.E are so popular and you NEVER heard of them??? oh my god!!! their songs are quite nice! i like 'Superstar', 'nian ren wei man', 're dai yu ling'...you NEVER heard that before???

[momobean]

Superstar is a cover song. I like Hou Niao and Dou Niu Shi Zhi Ge from their Encore album but I hate their singing in general. Not that they're below average or anything, but they always try to sound sweet and angelic. Probably a marketing gimmick by their company or whatever but it annoys me.

I love their song 'wo ai ni' ... the video is very beautiful.

The short film that was on the dvd version of that album was sad but kinda made me mad lol old woman left her family!

[Qt Mashi]

Originally Posted by firefox

i heard the song and it doesnt sound alike at all and i never listen to SHE only d/led it this time to see how similar it really is....and my verdict: The pv is but the song isnt similar

give it a rest

well i have an 8 year old niece she's an S.H.E fan and a bit of Ayu fan, she relli liked the song "About you" and a few days later when i put on the S.H.E song my niece says "hey! isnt that About You?" and then she asked me "did they copy Ayu?" so im like "yes..."

i relli do think it sounds familiar i have also given that song to many friends and asked them wat they thought of it and they said "this song sounds like About You?"

[Qt Mashi]

Originally Posted by Mad_Cactuar

I think SHE is getting more publicity with the help of Ayufans.. Noticed that we, who have NEVER EVER heard of their songs are suddenly downloading it and listening? Wont that make it possible for SHE to gain new fans..?

it's probably the same for Ayu, some ppl who hasnt heard 'about you' probably d/led it to compare it with S.H.E's song so Ayu is probably gaining more new fans and hate fans

Originally Posted by Qt Mashi

well i have an 8 year old niece she's an S.H.E fan and a bit of Ayu fan, she relli liked the song "About you" and a few days later when i put on the S.H.E song my niece says "hey! isnt that About You?" and then she asked me "did they copy Ayu?" so im like "yes..."

i relli do think it sounds familiar i have also given that song to many friends and asked them wat they thought of it and they said "this song sounds like About You?"

Maybe you shouldn't feed that when something is 'similar' it equals 'copying'?

I'm more the sure S.H.E doesn't care about any of this. They sing the songs that they're given. Logic and rational thinking don't come to this forum often I guess.

[Qt Mashi]

Originally Posted by //hikari

I'm more the sure S.H.E doesn't care about any of this. They sing the songs that they're given. Logic and rational thinking don't come to this forum often I guess.

well fine, SHE's composer copied then, is that better? since they don't compose their own songs....

sorry if you took it the wrong way, but i'm not tryinig to bash on S.H.E. i'm just makinig a point that the song has a similariity to "about you" that many ppl find obvious

[Aya Ariki]

Originally Posted by Qt Mashi

well fine, SHE's composer copied then, is that better? since they don't compose their own songs....

sorry if you took it the wrong way, but i'm not tryinig to bash on S.H.E. i'm just makinig a point that the song has a similariity to "about you" that many ppl find obvious

Totally argee...The problem is with the composer, not with S.H.E... Blame that Composer if you guys want to blame someone...

[Darkevil]

No point arguing on these small issue. Find it rather childish, don't listen to the song if you don't like it.

Btw, S.H.E doesn't compose their own song, it's not their fault! So what for blaming them? Instead, the one who's on fault are the FANS.

[elepop]

This whole copied thing is giving me an headache...

Anyway, I like "Superstar"! Never thought it was a cover! LOL.

[Aya Ariki]

Originally Posted by Darkevil

No point arguing on these small issue. Find it rather childish, don't listen to the song if you don't like it.

Btw, S.H.E doesn't compose their own song, it's not their fault! So what for blaming them? Instead, the one who's on fault are the FANS.

Agree too...

There's really no point having this going on and on.

If you really don't like that artist, just don't listen to their song, why bother bad mouthing them while you know that it would hate the feelings of their fans???