Rina Aiuchi's 'Ruby Stars'' and "A Song for XX"

[immel]

Did you check up on the composer/arranger of the two songs? Maybe it's the same? When was those two songs released in relation to eachother?

Downloading it right now, I'm gonna listen and see if I find it similar.

[*Petit*]

Thanks! I like rina a lot. =)

immel, that's highly unlikely, Rina Aiuchi is on GIZA.


edit.

Actually there are certain similarities in the melody in the beginning I think (not trying it out on the piano.) The firrst four notes, except ayu's in minor.. I think.

And I definetly get what you mean, allthough I think that if you haden't pointed out Asfxx to me before I heard this I probably woulden't noticed as much. THese are two totally different songs. Rina's is much brighter. =)

[RoboNyanya]

Originally Posted by immel

Did you check up on the composer/arranger of the two songs? Maybe it's the same? When was those two songs released in relation to eachother?

Downloading it right now, I'm gonna listen and see if I find it similar.

A friend of mine told me they weren't the same already. Yuri Godai was responsible for 'Ruby Stars' and though I don't remember the one for AsfXX, I'm pretty sure that wasn't the same person. I thought that was possible but yeah, Rina is GIZA and Ayu is Avex, so it's unlikely, as Petit said.:O

Originally Posted by *Petit*

Thanks! I like rina a lot. =)

Actually there are certain similarities in the melody in the beginning I think (not trying it out on the piano.) The firrst four notes, except ayu's in minor.. I think.

And I definetly get what you mean, allthough I think that if you haden't pointed out Asfxx to me before I heard this I probably woulden't noticed as much. THese are two totally different songs. Rina's is much brighter. =)

Yeah, exactly. Didn't notice it the first time around either, only that it vaguely reminded me of Ayumi. Even with all their similarity, they're still distinct enough that I like both songs for different reasons.