★ ayaka : the 4th official thread ★

[Beauty4123]

the PV was so simple, but the song is nice. not as good as her other ballads, though i'll miss ayaka

[TITANIC]

song is excelent but the PV is damn boring
it's like the have no idea anymore to make a PV.. very cheap

[elepop]

Yes, I believe she actually sang live in the PV! Didn't look like lipsynching to me.
The song is beautiful, almost sad to listen to. I wonder though... Is the actual song half a Capella and half with instruments?

[freedreamer]

the original song definitely has the instruments and sounds...from the imeem preview...so no worries

[KarenPang]

ok I saw Minna Sora no Shita's PV earlier on

it's so low budget & boring ;____; . It looked like it was done within 1 take or something T_T

but the song structure's unusual . The 1st 1/2's acaeplla which's awesome & when the 2nd 1/2 comes in with a melody , it's nice

& I was staring at ayaka's ever long lustful hair

[Yoake]

I've just finished to see her new pv. It's quite boring.
I love the song is really better than Yume wo mikata ni. However, I think that 3 min of a capella is really so long!

[GRACE]

I don't have a clue what everyone is talking about =/ The PV was incredibly moving in it's simplicity. It's rare that music or videos really choke me up, but that one did. It was just so perfect. Using the sun was incredibly hopeful. When you see a sunset, it's sad because the sun is going away, however, it's not sad because you know it will return again.

[Yoake]

It's always the same thing. Maybe, she could walk, use butterfly,... I don't know why...

[Beauty4123]

Originally Posted by GRACE

I don't have a clue what everyone is talking about =/ The PV was incredibly moving in it's simplicity. It's rare that music or videos really choke me up, but that one did. It was just so perfect. Using the sun was incredibly hopeful. When you see a sunset, it's sad because the sun is going away, however, it's not sad because you know it will return again.

that actually makes alot of sense. maybe i'll go watch the PV again

[Yum!Fruit_Salad!]

Thank you GRACE, took the words right out of my mouth.
I honestly wouldn't love Minna Sora no Shita as if it weren't a capella for those 3 minutes. Kept totally tuned and the way ayaka looks at the camera is like she's focusing on only you.

[KarenPang]

Originally Posted by Yum!Fruit_Salad!

Thank you GRACE, took the words right out of my mouth.
I honestly wouldn't love Minna Sora no Shita as if it weren't a capella for those 3 minutes. Kept totally tuned and the way ayaka looks at the camera is like she's focusing on only you.

true but you have to admit , the 3 mins acapella's ACE

that's still proof in the pudding on why she's still 1 of the best live acts around

it's hard to find an artiste that sounds good if not even better/the same live when you compare it against on what you hear on a CD

damn

[freedreamer]

^YEA im really surprised at the acapella...it felt genuine and I was touched too

[cloud♥honey]

The CD version is not acapella and has nothing to do to the non-acapella parts featured on the PV version too. It sounds like a Te wo Tsunagou less rockish.

[KarenPang]

you can download a much better quality/version of Minna Sora no Shita - http://community.livejournal.com/win...ony/45602.html

[Yoake]

Originally Posted by cloud♥honey

The CD version is not acapella and has nothing to do to the non-acapella parts featured on the PV version too. It sounds like a Te wo Tsunagou less rockish.

Not a capella. Even none a capelle intro? It's sad. I'll be ok to have a little intro like that. It's so powerful

[Yum!Fruit_Salad!]

Originally Posted by cloud♥honey

The CD version is not acapella and has nothing to do to the non-acapella parts featured on the PV version too. It sounds like a Te wo Tsunagou less rockish.

So basically we have two versions of Minna Sora no Shita.
I adore Te wo Tsunagou so I'll be able deal with real Minna Sora no Shita when it comes out.

[KarenPang]

Originally Posted by Yum!Fruit_Salad!

So basically we have two versions of Minna Sora no Shita.

I adore Te wo Tsunagou so I'll be able deal with real Minna Sora no Shita when it comes out.

I 2nd that

regardless whether the video version or not , I like Minna Sora no Shita

[Yoake]

I can't wait to hear the single version. ^^

[elepop]

Originally Posted by freedreamer

^YEA im really surprised at the acapella...it felt genuine and I was touched too

Yes, I agree completely. It felt beautiful yet sad. And her a Capella sounded almost flawless.

[Misato]

Does someone know, where i can find ayakas "sing to the sky" as CD+PV DVD Version?
Can´t find it anywhere. But i want it sooo badly!