HEART STATION vs. Guilty vs. Kingdom!

THA FAISU!
GIRUTII! THAT ALBUM ROCKS!
HAATO SUTAATION WAS REALLY NICE TOO~
KIINGUDOMU ******* SUCKED, SOOO DISSAPOINTED.

Originally Posted by austin. ♥

THA FAISU!
GIRUTII! THAT ALBUM ROCKS!
HAATO SUTAATION WAS REALLY NICE TOO~
KIINGUDOMU ******* SUCKED, SOOO DISSAPOINTED.

What is this all about

[sugarbasil]

^^Um, Austin...I love you, but even I think that was a bit much. XD

I have yet to hear HEART STATION, so I won't vote just yet. I'm holding off until a day when I can just sit down and do something on my computer and put it on in the background, because I keep hearing disappointing things about it. :/

[Earth_maiden]

Guilty

[greggerz189]

HEART STATION was foul. GUILTY all the way.

[njanjayrp]

1 > GUILTY 2 > HEART STATION 3 > Kingdom

*I loved every single track on GUILTY. All the songs fit perfectly on the album, and the whole albums seems really carefully put together for a reason.
** HEART STATION, has Boku wa kuma (which isn't really a song), then there is the retarded BUS song, and of course Celebrate which I hated, so only 2 new songs were awesome (Fight the Blues and TAKE5). This album is not as good as DEEP RIVER and ULTRA BLUE were.
*** Kingdom, is indeed the worst one, most of the songs sound cheap with poor arrangements, and most of the PVs are really boring. The only new song I liked was Wonderland, and I could survive hearing MORE, while Under annoys me the way nothing else does.

[ImpactBreaker]

Originally Posted by njanjayrp

** HEART STATION, has Boku wa kuma (which isn't really a song)

I wonder why some of you guys say that..I wish you could ellaborate more. What exactly doesn't make it a song? It has lyrics (dumb ones, but intelligence in lyrics is not a basic need in order to call a song a song), it has a composition and it has arrangements. A melody flows there, which basically makes it a song.

[njanjayrp]

Originally Posted by ImpactBreaker

I wonder why some of you guys say that..I wish you could ellaborate more. What exactly doesn't make it a song? It has lyrics (dumb ones, but intelligence in lyrics is not a basic need in order to call a song a song), it has a composition and it has arrangements. A melody flows there, which basically makes it a song.

The fact that Catcher in the Light is 20 seconds longer pretty much explains it all. Boku Wa Kuma is more of an interlude, the way I see it.

[ImpactBreaker]

Originally Posted by njanjayrp

The fact that Catcher in the Light is 20 seconds longer pretty much explains it all. Boku Wa Kuma is more of an interlude, the way I see it.

Song length is not what makes a song a preludfe/interlude or a full song. Catcher In The Light was made with an obvious intent of being a prelude. The lyrics on it are short and vague and somewhat incomplete. Boku Wa Kuma is a complete song, as it delivers what it should: simply to be a simple child's song. You don't see a single made out of an interlude song. Boku Wa Kuma had its own single, thus, it is a full song, people like it or not.

[fanmail]

Let's see~
HEART STATION - As I say, it's almost a single collection with some random new songs. The new songs were decent, but only Take 5 stood out for me. You Lose Hikki!

GUILTY - Another album full of "oh I'm so broken blah blah" rock songs. You Lose Ayu!

Kingdom - Bwhaha. Amazing. I adore every track, the packaging was sex, the gimmicks were amazing, and the methods they used were genius. You Win Kuu!

Originally Posted by dddaiyamondo

What is this all about

I have nooo idea...

Originally Posted by fanmail

GUILTY - Another album full of "oh I'm so broken blah blah" rock songs. You Lose Ayu!

Oh I'm so broken blah blah rock songs? Is that a new genre? :s

[JaysenRyan]

Kingdom 9/10
HEART STATION 10/10
Guilty 8/10

[Maemi]

i must say Guilty.
Heart Station is nice,but the most of songs are boring to me...
Kingdom sucks.

[bondingo]

HEART STATION and Kingdom were both pretty big letdowns, while GUILTY was Ayu's best album in awhile. It's definitely GUILTY, hands down.

[Melon Panda]

My ranks are also HEART STATION, then GUILTY, then Kingdom. HEART STATION seriously amazed me the first time I heard it, and GUILTY (while not my genre's cup of tea) was still solid. Kingdom only had a few tracks that I liked, and Koda Kumi's releases are starting to bore me.

[AyUta]

HEART STATION 10/10
GUILTY 9/10
KINGDOM 8/10

[Ryuuzaki]

Guilty 10/10
Heart Station 08/10
Kingdom 06/10

[Zachery!]

GUILTY (10/10)
HEART STATION (6/10)
Kingdom (5/10)

GUILTY was great.
HEART STATION and Kingdom ... well, I think an average album should be about a 7.

These were so mediocre compared to both of their previous releases.

[TITANIC]

GUILTY

[ayuayu798]

Guilty 9/10
Heat station 8/10
Kingdom 5/10