S.H.E fans views on copying ayu songs

[Qt Mashi]

Originally Posted by Mad_Cactuar

I think SHE is getting more publicity with the help of Ayufans.. Noticed that we, who have NEVER EVER heard of their songs are suddenly downloading it and listening? Wont that make it possible for SHE to gain new fans..?

it's probably the same for Ayu, some ppl who hasnt heard 'about you' probably d/led it to compare it with S.H.E's song so Ayu is probably gaining more new fans and hate fans

I love their song 'wo ai ni' ... the video is very beautiful.

The short film that was on the dvd version of that album was sad but kinda made me mad lol old woman left her family!

[Darkevil]

No point arguing on these small issue. Find it rather childish, don't listen to the song if you don't like it.

Btw, S.H.E doesn't compose their own song, it's not their fault! So what for blaming them? Instead, the one who's on fault are the FANS.

[Aya Ariki]

Originally Posted by Darkevil

No point arguing on these small issue. Find it rather childish, don't listen to the song if you don't like it.

Btw, S.H.E doesn't compose their own song, it's not their fault! So what for blaming them? Instead, the one who's on fault are the FANS.

Agree too...

There's really no point having this going on and on.

If you really don't like that artist, just don't listen to their song, why bother bad mouthing them while you know that it would hate the feelings of their fans???

[elepop]

This whole copied thing is giving me an headache...

Anyway, I like "Superstar"! Never thought it was a cover! LOL.

[ruixiong89]

I think if people want to fault SHE on the PV for it's similarity with GAME, I think I can accept that. Song-wise, yup, again, I think you'll have to like blame the composer more than SHE. SHE just sings whatever they're given!

For the PV, I'm not really sure whether the artistes have a say in it but again, I guess those people in the production team didn't do their research and homework before planning. That's all I have to say!

SHE's a good female band, they do have quite a lot of nice pop songs especially SUPERSTAR (though apparently, it's a cover song?) so I think it's ok to just appreciate what they've been doing. It's quite apparent they don't try to wholesale copy and assimilate everything Ayu's been doing (unlike others *ahem*) haha, yup, so I think it's fair enough if we give them a break.

Again, I don't think we should bother much about those unreasonable fans ... they're entitled to their own opinion. But if they badmouth, I'm quite ok with attacking them back ... hehe, okie okie, no flaming and no wars!

[gakkun]

S.H.E's most popular song is perhaps "Superstar", which is often mistakenly thought to have been originally titled, "Chyna Girl" and sung by Sweetbox. In actuality, the song was produced for S.H.E by Geo, who then ported the tune back to his home country of Germany for his band, Sweetbox.

from Wikipedia

though they have covered Destiny's Child, Britney Spears and Backstreet Boys(eh?).

[Aya Ariki]

I hate selina...

She only knows how to act cute.

I prefer Ella, the one that looks like boy.