[alan] ALAN vs. AYUMI

[GRACE]

Hardest decision ever.

I chose both. I don't really get the comparisons between alan and Ayu. They really don't have a thing in common except they sing in Japanese =/...

I love Ayu, she's my god. But I will say this, alan has a better voice.

[Twinkle !]

ooh >_< i really can't choose i like alan lately so i choose both but anyway i know ayu for long time ago so i'll choose her but this just like sky vs earth

but i like alan too

[elepop]

Ayu and alan don't have similar music style.
And Ayu is also not making more "hip-hop" or "electric" music. IMO. XD

[mimi.chan]

I love both of them but I chose Ayu because I love her lyrics.!

[emi♡]

Originally Posted by Kolongi

^Lol. Some of her songs do make you want to sleep, like Kuon no Kawa. She co-wrote Yume no Garden that's a start, seeing how she still doesn't know Japanese that well. She reminds me of BoA. For her Japanese debut album, BoA co-wrote and composed Nothing's Gonna Change and alan co-wrote Yume no Garden and composed Together.

About 98% of her discography is just boring to me.

But I meant, she should write her own songs, as in the music, because I think she could probably be a really interesting composer, if she learns how to do it...

I don't really care about lyrics. I personally wish she would sing in Chinese. She sounds amazing in that language.

[mcluva420]

oh em gee? poor alan! cant u compare her to some other new artist instead?
this is an ayu forum after all! with about 99% ayu supporters!

[Ahi_max91]

Ayu ayu ayu ^^!~

[Ayumi27]

This poll its kinda unfair since we are in an Ayu forum. Appart from that, I would wait a couple of years and albums before judging alan's material overall

[Kingdom]

Ew. Ayu for sure!

[KarenPang]

Originally Posted by Kolongi

She's basically saying you are comparing alan (the hill) to Ayumi (the mountian). And it's obvious the mountain will win especially on her own forum. I chose both, alan has something Ayumi doesn't and Ayumi has something alan doesn't.

What's wrong with sass? It's apart of a healthy diet you know.

that's right

both of them are polar opposites of each other in the sense that alan's a relatively new artiste while ayumi has been around for so long

it's not fair to compare both of them in this context

it's different if you compare ayumi with another established act on the same grounds as her

[vampireknightzero]

definitely Ayu!

[lovelism]

Ayu

[Yoake]

ayumi^^

[hikaricore]

Ayumi!
Although alan is VERY close. I think alan could become the next Ayu. Maybe.

[mcken200]

well ultimately this an ayu forum so fanbase goes to her, but i would say ultimately ayu is my no.1 over the years but currently alan has my vote for consistently amazing songs.

[Yum!Fruit_Salad!]

Originally Posted by Kolongi

I chose both, alan has something Ayumi doesn't and Ayumi has something alan doesn't.

Quoted for feeling the same.

[Melon Panda]

I like them both. alan has the better voice, hands down, but Ayumi is the better overall artist.

[Miku]

Ayu

[aqua_crystal]

Both rock but the are tooo diff to be compared! So I chose both.

[waterballoon]

Er, is this poll even logical? I won't choose at all, simply because they are in their own leagues of awesomeness and IMO it's unfair to both Ayu and alan, whoever I choose.