Thoughts on "MOON ~short edit~"?

[tokyoxjapanxfan]

so far? boring.
there's really nothing happening yet.
but i thought the pv looked boring just from the ViVi pics, so at least I'm not disappointed. haha

But I think it will get more interesting, as we know about the oil stuff. or whatever. haha

[primavera♥]

Originally Posted by Neko?munication

It was kinda the climax, but of the short edit. I'm not judging the entire PV by this, I just posted my opinion on the short edit. Thank you for being respectful about it though

I'm really not an Ayu basher, and I don't want anyone to think I am T_T

But...but ur not an ayu basher. Tbh idk what these really are difined by this forum. But ur definitely not. Everyone just has the right to question everyones opinion. And u started the thread so urs is read quite a bit.

Ayu basher, no? Now there's the people who I expect to give a negative opinion of ayu cuz that's all they ever do (which is so amusingly ironic to me when I see the stuff they praise in other threads)

-----------------------------

I just feel so much missing. (Of course)....so I'm really excited for the full. I love the artistic direction so far. With the visual beaty and the small things. My mind follows each. I can't be so idle and bored

[prussian blue]

So far so "ordinary" !? I dont even want to watch it until the real full one appear.

[Nessa]

Her nails really bother me... I hope they have something to do with her bandaged fingertips.

[C+R+E+AYUMI]

ordinary it's the correct word.

I excpected something strong for a summer single.

Will blossom have a full PV in the end?

[Cherry Dynamite]

It's okay but god I couldn't even finish the whole PV, It was so boring.

[Rurutia]

beautiful but boring

[Lizzyboo]

i liked it!! lol the video reminded me of a mixture of Dont look back, Marionette and Is this love all of which i love so, i also love this one

[Tony G]

Its like don't look back. The short edit was the same.. ayu sitting in a chair. Here its the same. You can tell that something is not right.. you can see ayu is panicking/upset in the flashbacks. There is more to be seen, the twist is going to be in the full edit and then the PV will be amazing, no doubt.

How can anyone judge the whole PV from this? THERE IS NO CONCLUSION.

[Tony G]

There are clues:

- Chandelier is shattered on the floor
- Ayu is crying in the flashbacks, depressed on the chair, you see her crying at 2:41 on the chair
- Dining chair falls over
- Ayu's fingertips are covered in some white glue substance or bandages??
- dripping black pen ink and falling cups of water through the PV
- flashes of her playing with a dog
- red roses layed out on the floor

And if I'm not mistaken, you can see the flash of someone else (looks male) in a white shirt at 2:42. Unless that's Ayu.. can't tell.. but it doesn't seem like her.

So there's plenty of clues. Maybe someone close to ayu has died in the video?

[Karori]

Originally Posted by DA1SUK1DAY01691

Is it just me or does it remind you of "Moments" so far??

I thought the same when I saw it!!
It is okay, I think. It is only the short version, so we'll have to wait a little more. But right now I can say I like it. It kinda reminded me of Moments + a little of Don't look back, but in a darker version.

[GRACE]

Originally Posted by Neko★munication

Umm, I resent being told to calm down when I really wasn't being that negative. Having an opinion other than "OMG LOVE" isn't that scandalous, and I didn't think I was being rude or whatever.

I DID acknowledge that it was a short edit, and the thread is even CALLED thoughts on "Moon ~Short edit~", so really... Should I apologize for not automatically loving it?

I'm not telling you to like it, I'm telling you not to judge the whole PV based on this boring and bland preview for it :l It looked like it was just about to get good when it ended based on the cool flashes. You wrote that post essentially about how the WHOLE PV was boring and bland and saying how it was incredibly disappointing that this was the PV for MOON when we haven't really even seen the PV for MOON yet :l

People who judge if something's good from previews bother me is all, because it's just stupid

[Kazeyomi]

I like it. But I need the full version to judge it.

Anyway even Don't look back would look boring as PV.
It's just:
Ayu's sitting and crying
Ayu's staying in front of her big A BEST 2 cover and 'tehee i'm happy ' and then 'oh noes i'm sad '
Ayu's sitting and crying again, but then 'omg my right side of the face is dirty!!1'

But! Don't look back it's full of meaning, even though Ayu doing anything during the whole PV. And that would be the same for MOON, for sure.

[AyUta]

it reminds me of moments too! and marrionette

[agashi]

Originally Posted by Rurutia

beautiful but boring

exactly ...

[SURREAL__RAINBOW]

LOL

Its too short to either love it or hate it!


I really don't get those comments saying how boring this pv is, or whatever... HOW CAN YOU EVEN TELL!?!!?!



Seriously... stupid nonsense comments.

[AyuGAME]

there is two screencaps showing her face covered with ink...
already get more excited about the full version of the PV

[Mintkisses]

Meh, nothing is really happens in the edit version. All I know is that she's upset about something.. lol. But, I can tell this will be an intense PV.

[Beauty4123]

i've been loving all of ayu's PVs this year, so i don't hate the MOON PV so far either. i like the dark feeling of it and i like the setting of the video. but at 2:40 it looks like ayu is having a bad stomach ache with the way she's holding her stomach, lol.

[Michan]

Reminds me moments too =D. I think the feeling of this short version is the same of moments I could expect something like that. Also reminds me Marionette 'cause I think they used the same room of Marionette pv =D.
By the way I don't think it's boring you. I took this short version like a introduction of the real thing will happen =D At least I hope so =)