[News] Who...10th Anniversary Full Version

[sitara]

Originally Posted by jonneh

I love "Who.." but her vibrato in this version is a liiiiittle too much for me to handle in some places. it's like she's trying too hard. *runs away before the angry mob forms*
But actually, it's mainly in the beginning...after she gets going her voice is more normal and beautiful.

same here. too much vibrato, not only in the beginning for me.
actually i was expecting a version where she says "minna" instead of only "anata" once. like in the concert. that would have been 10th anniversary style in my opinion ^^

[Aggar]

thank you

[dawnss]

The song does sound different, but good. Like many people have said her voice does sound different and it will because she has gone deaf. I am not saying this to be rude, but Ayu's voice will sound different her needs will be unique because not many singers are deaf. And for her she will have some work cut out for her vocally wise. Her voice might sound strained because she probably did not record this song until recently, which suggests that the song was recorded during her tour, and her voice will be strained after singing for so long. I think that for her she could use a hiatus to accomadate to her voice and find out what works for her vocally. I don't know if i am blabbling sorry if i offended anyone.

[Darling]

This sounds so amazing!
Thanks for the link and putting it up ^_^

[..:DisarO:..]

owwwwwwwwww soooo cute! Makes me wanna run and hug ayu!

[LEOyumi]

I love this new version! A great one.. But nothing beats the original! <3~

[Purple Neko]

I like it alot! thank you!

[pbs1605]

Awesome,thank you.

[BoBo]

Awesome 10x

[Lanz16]

I LOVE IIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!!
It gives me teary eyes... ;____;

[Ayumiko]

will avex release a capella version for download? I really like it in the cm...

[tourniquet]

Originally Posted by Ayumiko

will avex release a capella version for download? I really like it in the cm...

unlikely. it's not a digital single, only a bonus track for A COMPLETE.


but I really like this version and I'm not a fan of the other two.

[Deep snow]

wow, thanks, it's about time anyway ^^

[kiseki89]

I'm in love with Who AGAIN!... That is if I'm ever out of love with it...

[howtousesexy]

Thanks so much, haven't had the time to listen to it. Will do now.

[haikudasai]

It's not as 'epic' as I was hoping for... her vocals seem strained during parts and a little sharp.

Who... is one of my favorite songs ...

[Tom Punks]

Originally Posted by haikudasai

It's not as 'epic' as I was hoping for... her vocals seem strained during parts and a little sharp.

Who... is one of my favorite songs ...

Yeaaaaaaaaaah, I really hope this isn't how she's going to deliver all her ballads from now on. :< Something about her vocals just bothers me now.

[panda87]

^ must agree. i was listening to it and was like... gawsh, she's just... not that great at singing anymore. she doesn't sound as steady anymore. she sounds restrained... and overdoes that a~a~a~
i can't help but think that she sounds like an old lady *scratches head*

and thanks to poster of the link.

[jbrat2219]

^ Ouch! Is it really that bad? =/

[ultracat]

This is yesterday's HK newspaper

濱崎步國語歌哄香港Fans
08/09/2008

將於本月下旬來港開騷的濱崎步，為紀念加入樂壇十周年，本周三發行收錄了43首單曲的合輯大碟。近年甚看重 亞洲市場的她，早前秘密地把歌曲《Who...》錄製成國語版，收錄在亞洲版的唱片內，並有意在香港的演唱 會上獻唱，為樂迷送上驚喜。而她性感演出的Wacoal內衣廣告，已在大中華三地同時面世，吸引不少Fan s拍照留念。

Source: http://the-sun.on.cc/channels/ent/20080908/ (World entartainment News)

It said that Ayu has recorded a mandarin version of "Who..." and contained in the Asia version of A COMPLETE. It also said Ayu may performed it in Hong Kong's concert...

If it is real, we will have a full mandarin version of Who... that performed in AT07...?