[News] Ayu scolds Eason 'Stupid'

[Ayu_Jayson]

Hmm, duno about Eason, but when I go concert I enjoy it rather than find errors in it. Haha maybe he's a fan of Simon from American Idol.

I wouldnt say if Eason is right or wrong since I trust my ears and I didnt hear him say that. We all have 2nd-hand info so commenting on it wouldnt be fruitful. By adding more comments, I feel we're kinda being used by those HK media (and no different from them) since we're helping them to spread this rumour even further. The least we could do is know about the rumour and dun take it seriously.

Even if Ayu did lip-synch, her dances more than makes up for it, I'm sure everything Ayu does has a reason, we have to be understanding. Ayu's continuously on the move during concert so maybe a few songs she lip-synch to catch her breath doesnt hurt right? Haha. Or it could be the company's idea for Ayu to lip-synch so that it isnt too taxing on Ayu.

As for Ayu crying after hearing Eason's comments, I highly doubt Ayu will cry since she's such a strong person having gone through the hardship of her life (single parent life and working at an early age) before being a star and gone through the difficult path of being a j-pop queen. Outside Japan, Ayu only shed a tear or two when she sees the hardship of less fortunate ppl (in URRAYU Book) and during the time her heart was touched when kids in taiwan sang her songs (on youtube).

Still not convinced Ayu didnt cry? There are a few clips on Youtube that has Ayu forgetting lyrics for Trauma during concerts in Japan. She didnt cry, she just said "Sorry" and "Rarrrrr" after that. Hahaha, thatz more Ayu. Crying coz another singer said she lip-synched just seems so haha impossible. Yes Ayu does take pride and effort but comments I'm sure she takes it in her stride =) Ayumi Hamasaki is a fighter and her tears dun drop for small things =)

Just a line from a korean show: "The mouth is the source of trouble, the tongue is what cuts the body." So watch our words =)

[alt.total-loser]

She was crying? LOLZ

[°~Kitty~°]

I don't think that she was crying xD I want that Ayu strikes him xDD and I want to help her^^

[ImpactBreaker]

LOL you guys are too purists saying ayu would never say things like that or that it doesn't sound like ayu at all. She's not a holy divinity. This article could be fake, however saying things like "it isn't like ayu at all" isn't in any way a justification for that. You guys make ayu look like such a pure being, which is a complete distortion of reality.
Eason is a BAKA, if she said that she just stated the obvious that even "pure girls" would yell out loud something like that to the public.

[Ayu_Jayson]

Yeah agrees with Impact haha. But u knw such is the nature of most of us here, haha, always want the best image of Ayu =) We always filter out the negative human aspects. Just like even if Ayu frowns, itz still the most beautiful and perfect face =)

[ayu_fan929]

Originally Posted by Surreal

I mean, it's not really wise to say she lip-synched when the whole stadium didn't hear it, right? He could have kept it to himself, or said it in a less direct way. I think he just made trouble for himself. *shrugs* We all talk without brains sometimes, he just chose the wrong event to do so.

The less direct way could have helped I guess but it's not like he's criticizing her for lip synching. He said there's nothing wrong about it, it's just people's perceptions that think lip synching = bad singer.

Originally Posted by kiseki89

He seems to have another issue with 張學友 for having the same song title 好久不見 = not very sure, this is what my friend told me]

Jacky Cheung is his idol. But the title is kind of common/generic though (common/generic like "Yume no Uta" for example).

[elepop]

Lip-synching or not, I don't care. (I'm pretty sure Ayu didn't because she never does it. Except many the 2nd song of each concert, after the big opening number.) Ayu is being childish. Eason is being ignorant.

Originally Posted by Surreal

Eason: "If Hong Kongers do that they will definitely get scolded."

Wow, how funny of him to say that. At LEAST 2/3 of Hong Kong artists lip-synching ALMOST ALL THE TIME. I know that very well because I always watch many Chinese shows from Hong Kong with my mom such as concerts, charity event, award shows.... And it's VERY rare to hear someone sing live. It's a fact. And it's really obvious. So I'm guessing almost all Hong Kong artists are being scolded.

[ayu_fan929]

^But they still do get talked about on forums though.

[Peger]

I don't understand why people are buying into this conflict, it seems pretty clear that it's a bunch of ******** the tabloids made up.

[WillofDusk]

Nah~ things are just being blown up.
Let's just forget about this, I'm bored, at least Ayu has commented on this case ( I mean the TA one, not this tabloid)

[Ayumiko]

Originally Posted by asongforXX

Lip-synching or not, I don't care. (I'm pretty sure Ayu didn't because she never does it. Except many the 2nd song of each concert, after the big opening number.) Ayu is being childish. Eason is being ignorant.



Wow, how funny of him to say that. At LEAST 2/3 of Hong Kong artists lip-synching ALMOST ALL THE TIME. I know that very well because I always watch many Chinese shows from Hong Kong with my mom such as concerts, charity event, award shows.... And it's VERY rare to hear someone sing live. It's a fact. And it's really obvious. So I'm guessing almost all Hong Kong artists are being scolded.

oh yes that reminds me...those charity shows, big shows like anniversary, new years, and stuff were really obvious XD and most of them just stand there and sing too. Also I remember watching a china outdoor concert with a mix of artists from mainland china, HK, Taiwan, etc. They even faked the crowd cheers XD Every time theres cheers which sounds like stadium cheers, it sounds exactly the same and when the cameras zoned in on the crowd, they were just calmly clapping even though there was a loud cheer sound and no clapping sound at the same time. Ballads or fast songs, all have lots and the same cheers...LOL

[Ani_C]

If I were her I would so be pissed as well

[WillofDusk]

That's much better than in my country, they even faked the fan club~
Lucky that I've never had to join any concert in my country. The last time I went there was more than 8 years, wat a record.

[MemorialAddress]

What a jerk, how dare he say that!
Ayu never lipsincs!!!

[cater2u]

I hate war. i hope they will b friends

[alternarist]

i dont think ayu lip-synched cos ayu forgot her lyrics in AUDIENCE and only music was played... no one was singing..

[ayu_ready?]

all this is crappy & funny

[kimono_jet_girl]

I am on Ayu's side in this matter - and I think this guy Eason should make an apology to her.

[jpopfan]

Originally Posted by theprojectzero

I wish Ayumi did scolded "Stupid!" out loud publicly cause anyone would be mad too when they've been trying so hard to get everything together and prepared for the concert. Hoping everyone that went to the concert have an amazing time! Since she's the legendry, Ayumi.

And Eason destroyed everything by saying such thing. People that don't know much about Ayumi would surely think so too then. All Ayumi hardwork is gone!

i agree with that. For people who dont really know who she is that could ruin their chances of finding more interest in her or for people who know her this chould mess up the image about her they have

[Butterknife]

I don't think Ayumi would have said anything like that. Ayumi wouldn't start crying just because somebody accused her of lip-synching, she's a hell of a lot stronger than that. I don't think she would be angry enough as to call him stupid either, if she did say it at all, it would probably be jokingly.